Indian democracy is unusual in that it is dynastic. Rahul says he could have become PM at the age of 25. Since he didn't want to be killed, he refused to step up to the plate in 2013/2014 which is why Modi has been able to rule. Still, he remains the Leader of the Opposition purely by birthright.
V. Ramani, a senile former IAS officer, writes in Scroll.in of the crumbling pillars of Indian democracy. Oddly, he doesn't mention the only pillar which has crumbled- viz. Rahul Gandhi's brain which has turned to shit.
the structure of democracy in India rests on seven pillars, namely (i) legislature (ii) executive (political and bureaucratic) (iii) political parties (iv) judiciary (v) independent institutions (vi) media and (vii) civil society.
All these things can exist in non-democratic countries. There is only one pillar of a democracy- viz. there is peaceful transition of power on the basis of electoral outcomes. That pillar has stood in India because the Army won't interfere to keep a regime in power even if it loses elections. There is no Indian Imran Khan or Field Marshall Munir.
As of today, all the pillars appear shaky, threatening the future of democracy, although it could be argued that structural weaknesses in the Indian democratic edifice have existed right from 1947.
Anyone can say anything at all is shaky. But why bother?
I Legislature
Let us start with the legislatures, both at the union and state levels. Cracks appeared in the post-Nehruvian era.
Congress began to lose elections. Indira lurched to the Left, got rid of the senile Syndicate, and turned Congress into ancestral property.
The “aya Ram gaya Ram” phenomenon of politicians switching parties started in 1967, a legacy that continues to the present day.
Ramani hasn't heard of Rajiv's anti-defection bill.
Reminiscent of Indian Premier League auctions, legislators are tempted by the highest bidders, though other pressures such as the fear of investigative agencies can also act as triggers for crossovers.
No fool like a retired IAS fool.
Disconcertingly, it is no longer just individual bait: shoals of legislators are willing to defect en masse, lured by the attractions of power and patronage and the fear of state action.
Unpopular leaders- e.g Udhav Thakeray- or those seeking to make their party dynastic- like Mamta- may indeed be deserted by the majority of their legislators.
The anti-defection provisions in the Constitution have become a dead letter: in no case have presiding officers ruled against defectors
Because the thing only happens if there are enough of them.
Major legislations are rushed through without adequate public debate and reflection.
Who is to say what is 'adequate'?
The quality of discussions in legislatures, especially Parliament, has taken a deep dive.
Because Rahul has shit for brains.
Presiding officers often give short shrift to Opposition demands for discussion or to notices for legislative intervention, as in the cases of the proposed impeachment of the chief election commissioner and a former High Court judge.
Both are difficult to do. The Opposition doesn't have the numbers. Moreover, it would be a waste of Parliamentary time.
II Executive
At both the political and bureaucratic levels, there is inadequate engagement with public opinion, especially on crucial policy matters.
Losing elections makes you pay attention to public opinion.
The Citizenship (Amendment) Act,
Which confirmed the previous position that non-Muslims fleeing Islamic persecution would have a path to citizenship
the farm laws
withdrawn when farmers objected
and the Special Intensive Revision of the electoral rolls
decided upon by the independent Election Commission. It is supposed to remove the names of dead people rather than let the ruling party use their votes to keep itself in power.
Weakening the EC strenghtens the party which now rules 72 percent of the country.
are just some of the glaring instances.
of what? All were perfectly proper and in keeping with what went before.
Dissent and criticism are brushed off as the handiwork of “urban naxals”, “dimagi naxals” and “anti-nationals”.
When was this not the case? Does Ramani not know that the Government hunted down and killed Naxalites? There are draconian laws against secessionism and terroristic activities.
The use of civil servants, especially those in the investigative agencies, to lodge cases and subject dissenters and political opponents to harassment has become commonplace.
It was worse when I was young.
More disturbing is the fact that civil servants, in violation of the oath to the Constitution they take when joining public service, are more than willing and enthusiastic to implement the orders of their political masters, be it the sudden demolition of structures (by a curious coincidence, mostly owned or occupied by the Muslim community), the interference in prayer meetings of the Christian community and the harassment of interfaith couples on the bidding of lumpen vigilante groups.
Ramani often destroyed Mosques and raped 'inter-faith' couples. Sonia was terrified of him because she was a Christian.
It seems that the senior bureaucracy of the various services has virtually abdicated its role of pointing out to the political executive the absence of legality in the orders it is asked to carry out.
They are welcome to do so and get transferred.
Infrastructure and mineral resource extraction projects are being given virtually blanket permissions, ignoring the voices of caution from environmental experts and groups and bypassing local consultation with affected stakeholders
Which is why India is a little less poor than it used to be.
. The ecological consequences are becoming visible, with repeated hill landslides and flash floods, apart from growing desertification of arable lands.
Civil Servants are sodomizing trees and bushes. This is causing desertification. Ramani was once a Civil Servant. He is speaking out against a practice in which he himself participated.
III Political parties
The initial years after Independence saw many stalwarts from different political parties serve with distinction in Parliament and state legislative assemblies and councils.
Then, we had Nehru. Now, we have Rahul. Sad.
The watershed year was 1967,
when Indira Gandhi got her Daddy's job.
when the lure of pelf and patronage led to the mushrooming of political parties, many of them dominated by one family. The Indian National Congress was no exception.
Things are better now. Modi's dad was a chai-wallah.
Sycophancy became the path for political advancement, with genuflections to the ruling deities in various parties.
It was particularly intense under the Dynasty.
The system of hereditary succession took firm root in nearly all parties. With hard work and meritorious performance receiving no returns, the decades from the 1990s saw wannabe politicians jumping ship whenever they felt the reward for switching loyalties was higher.
An elected politician has to keep the anti-defection law in mind. A wannabe can do what he likes.
Loyalty to the ruling coterie in a party was the sole criterion for political survival. Criminals and carpetbaggers freely entered the political arena.
This is why people prefer the BJP.
Winning elections and deriving the benefits from exercise of power has become the sole preoccupation of politicians. Governance, legislative debate and the quality of enacted legislation have suffered grievously.
Bring back the Brits. They were smart.
Today, India seems to live from election to election: what happens in the five-year interregnum between polls seems to concern neither the politician nor the ordinary citizen.
That was what people said when I was a kid. We only see our MP once every five years.
IV Judiciary
The judiciary, given the constraints of manpower and the burden of litigation, has often been the lumbering elephant in the room. What has been particularly disconcerting in recent years has been its propensity, especially at the highest levels of the Supreme Court and High Courts, to take an agonisingly long time in deciding issues that impact the life and liberty of the individual as also matters that have a crucial bearing on constitutional issues and on the lives of ordinary citizens.
The Bench became more activist. But it kept doing stupid shit.
Bail pleas are deferred for months on end, with the draconian provisions in laws like the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act and Prevention of Money Laundering Act, ensuring that the process itself becomes the punishment.
Both came into effect under Congress administrations.
It took years for the accused in the Bhima-Koregaon and the Delhi riots cases to get bail, with some still in judicial custody after more than six years. Chargesheets are yet to be filed in these cases.
That is a matter for defence lawyers. If they are crap at their job, what can be done about it?
Stan Swamy and GN Saibaba were instances where the rigours of incarceration led to their deaths.
They would have died in any case because of old age or long term health issues.
And who can forget most of the Aam Aadmi Party leadership in jail before and at the time of the 2025 Delhi elections, denying them the right of participating in election campaigning?
Who can forget their corruption?
The executive has also got away with omnibus clearances of projects that affect the environment, in the absence of meaningful judicial intervention.
Ramani is very sad that India is no longer as poor as shit. Why has the Bench not prevented everybody from doing anything useful?
V Independent institutions
At the heart of the crisis today is the severe weakening of nearly all independent institutions, meant to serve as the guardians of democracy.
Nothing of the sort has happened. Shitty institutions are a little less shitty because the country is a little richer.
We are witnessing the continued unrest arising from the SIR, with the names of 130 million citizens being deleted from the rolls.
Why are dead people not being allowed to vote?
The functioning of the Election Commission has come in for scathing criticism.
Trump & Bolsanaro claimed any election they lost was rigged. No doubt, Congress only won Kerala because of 'vote chori'.
But it is by no means the only institution that has suffered a dent in its reputation. Information Commissions, the Lokpal, the National Green Tribunal, the National Commission for Scheduled Castes, the National Commission for Women and the National Commission for Protection of Child Rights have proved ineffective in acting as a check and balance on executive action/inaction.
They were always shit.
VI Media
In a cruel twist of irony, Lal Krishna Advani, one of the founders of the Bharatiya Janata Party, observed about the media after the Emergency: “When they were asked to bend, they crawled.”
They were asked to crawl. Some did. Some did not.
Today, large sections of the media, both print and electronic, need no such suggestions.
Because they need to make money.
They readily genuflect to authority
in Tamil Nadu, they genuflect to the ruling Dravidian ideology.
and are more than willing to carry the messages of the government of the day, forgetting their duty of speaking truth to power.
There is no such duty. Parrhesia was a Quaker thing. But Quaker newspapers supported the Liberal party. They told lies to help it.
The fear of losing government advertising revenues, the apprehension of coercive action and the outright purchase of independent news channels by powerful corporate interests have silenced the media.
Sadly, no. The media remains noisy. .
VII Civil societyLeonardo Bruni translated Aristotle's koinōnía politikḗ into societas civilis ("civil society"). We are all part of it. Unlike the UK, which has a King & an established Church, there is no 'first' or 'second' estate. Everybody is part of the only estate which exists.
It is difficult to decide whether civil society is civil anymore.
It never had any obligation to be so.
Paraphrasing Mahatma Gandhi on Western civilisation, one must say that civil society in the India of today would be a good idea.
It would be nice if Rahul learnt some manners from his sister.
Whether on TV channels or on social media, haranguing and shrill accusations are the order of the day. Communities, families and friendships have been split down the middle. Dialogue and discussion have been replaced by partisan postures, with each side retreating into their respective echo chambers.
e.g. Scroll.in.
The polarisation of society, probably dormant before 2014,
when a nice Italian lady was running things.
has come into the open in recent years, with disturbingly large sections of the “educated” majority community “othering” the Muslim community and lumpen groups and the arms of the state harassing the Christian community on the grounds of alleged religious conversion.
It is Hindus who should be othered. Why has 'sanatan dharm' not been banned?
Governments may change in the future, but the damage to the ruptured social fabric may take far longer to repair.
Nehru should have surrendered to Jinnah. India would now be an Islamic republic.
Civil society stakeholders – corporate bigwigs, politicians, bureaucrats, academics, media persons, not to mention the large army of WhatsApp uncles and aunties – have enthusiastically espoused the ruling majoritarian ideology.
Because the majority is Hindu. Ramani cries and cries when he remembers this.
It might be out of blind adoration, bringing to mind Babasaheb Ambedkar’s warning that in politics, bhakti or hero-worship is a sure road to degradation and to eventual dictatorship.
Assassination tempers autocracy. Three people with the surname Gandhi have been killed. Why not a fourth?
In many cases, ambition dictates obedience, as well as the apprehension of consequences and/or sheer apathy in the garb of self-interest.
Why do people do things which are in their own interest? Why don't they chop off their own heads and shove them up their rectums? Clearly, it is what Ramani has done.
No comments:
Post a Comment