Tuesday, 27 October 2026

The NYT wrong about cockroaches

Lydia Polgreen, an NYT journalist, says she has seen things in India which 'should scare Modi'. Modi knows India better than her. Why is he not scared? The answer is that his party has won West Bengal and Delhi and looks set to retain UP. His party rules 72 percent of the country and is likely to get a fourth term. 

Currently, there is an agitation in India about 'vote chori'- votes being stolen. Sadly, Modi hasn't allowed crazy rioters to invade the Indian equivalent of Capitol Hill. No doubt Lydia felt Biden was very authoritarian for wanting to punish those nutters. 
Narendra Modi, the barrel-chested strongman leader of India for the past dozen years, has finally met his match

Yogi? If Adityanath wins UP for a third time, he will be seen as Modi's natural successor.  

— and it looks a lot like Mohini Majumdar.

a Bengali. The BJP just won West Bengal. 

Just 20 years old, slender and voluble, Majumdar is an English student at Delhi University:

she may want to become a journalist. Maybe she can earn some money writing or podcasting about the 'cockroach' agitation. 

an unlikely antagonist for an omnipotent autocrat.

Rahul Gandhi is the antagonist. The truth is, Rahul's cowardice and stupidity is what keeps Modi in power.

Yet early on Oct. 10, she shared an early morning taxi to the center of Delhi with a gaggle of classmates. Dressed casually in flowing cotton and sensible shoes, Majumdar and her friends could just as easily have been on their way to a stroll in one of this city’s splendid gardens. But their plan, she told me, was to march across the street to a place called Jantar Mantar, a historic monument at the center of Delhi that has for decades served as a designated ground for protest.

It has been denotified. Sad.  

They had been there before, over the summer, joining thousands of other young people in raucous, meme-driven protests after a leaked paper led to the cancellation of a college entrance exam. Eventually, under the banner of the upstart Cockroach Janata Party, they forced the resignation of India’s education minister. It was the first time Modi’s government had dismissed a top official under pressure from public protests.

Modi does get rid of underperforming Ministers but he does it in a polite manner. The rumour is that he Minister who resigned was eager to return to Orissa which the BJP has won recently.  

Now, they were back for an even bigger fish: Modi’s handpicked chief election commissioner, who had overseen the deletion of more than 130 million people from the country’s voter rolls in a murky process that threatened to undermine faith in the voting process in the world’s largest democracy. “These kinds of protests really prove that you should be political, and everything is political in our life,” Majumdar told me as she waited for the march to begin.

The allegation is that the CEC is targetting Muslim illegal migrants. Sadly, this is popular with the Hindu majority.  

She never did get to march that day. A few minutes after I spoke with her and her friends, a column of police officers decked out in camouflage descended on the students, manhandling them into a waiting bus. The officers drove them 40 minutes north of the city center and held them in a police station until after dark, eventually letting the women go; only when they refused to leave did the officers also release the men.

Macron must be wishing he could deal with his revolting students in the same way.  

So great was the threat these students presented to Modi’s rule that his government reportedly deployed over 50,000 security personnel to the streets, shut down dozens of metro stations, blocked long-distance trains from arriving in Delhi and threw up yellow steel barricades across the capital, leaving its usually teeming streets eerily deserted.

India is a 'hard' state with enormous state capacity. So far the police and paramiltary has used kid gloves. But they will enjoy killing cockroaches all the more when the time comes.  

Majumdar was one of thousands of people detained that day by the authorities in an all-out attempt to quash the protest.

Which was in fact quashed. Rahul Gandhi's agitation is a different matter. The BJP hopes it will backfire and lead to 'Hindu consolidation'.  

Despite these efforts, Modi appears more vulnerable than at any time since he was first elected prime minister.

He looked vulnerable in 2024 when BJP lost its majority. His ally- Nitish Kumar- was notoriously unreliable. Then we realised that if a second election were held, the BJP would win by a landslide. Thus it was and is in nobody's interest to topple him.  

Young people like Majumdar, educated, middle-class and Hindu — the children of a generation that rocketed him to power — are in open revolt, incensed by the government’s derogation of education and democracy.

No. Youth is in revolt in France and young people did bring down Governments in Sri Lanka, Nepal & Bangladesh. But Modi can only be brought down by electoral defeat. The problem is that the Opposition are likely to split up and thus fresh elections will be called which the BJP will win.  

Willing to risk detention and the baton blows of the feared lathi, they are setting out to make Modi, who has carefully managed his image as a civilizational figure who will lift India into glory, an object of fun. Majumdar, undeterred by her detention, joined another protest the very next day.

Modi's personal popularity isn't enough for his party to win elections. Candidate selection & booth management remain vital.  The problem with making fun of Modi is that Rahul is far more ridiculous. His sister, on the other hand, is dignified.

For Modi, it is a stunning turnabout.

No. It is like the anti-CAA protest. Congress comes across as depending on a Muslim vote-bank. This helps the BJP consolidate the Hindu vote.  

For over a decade, his rule seemed durable and unshakable. His rise to power, initially inconceivable and then inevitable, was a foretaste of the world to come. Before Brexit blew apart Britain, before Donald Trump ascended to the American presidency, before an influx of Syrian refugees turned European politics rightward, Modi led the world’s largest democracy toward a vision of nationalist, right-wing populism, promising a civilizational restoration.

Nonsense! Modi promised better governance and 'last mile delivery'. His first big speech after becoming PM had to do with ensuring all rural households had an indoor toilet. Open defecation was unhealthy and put women at risk.  

To be fair, all parties have realised that universal benefits and last mile delivery are the only thing which matters when it comes to winning elections. What is important is credibility. 

Today, India is once again in the vanguard — this time leading, perhaps, in the opposite direction.

 The BJP will stay in power even if doesn't get a majority. As the biggest party, it may give 'outside support' to evanescent coalitions with a view to convincing the voters that it and it alone can provide stable government. Unlike the dynastic Congress, where assassination tempered autocracy, killing a BJP PM won't change anything because there are plenty more like him who can do the job just as well. 

As Modi has consolidated his power over this vast nation and its sprawling state apparatus, many Indians have grown weary of the bargain he has offered: growth and national prosperity in return for a hardening authoritarianism.

Why is Modi not letting young people burn down Delhi?  

Beset as Modi is by crises within and without, his iron grip on power is clanging against the steel of India’s messy democracy.

This crazy lady spoke to one Bengali girl. She hasn't even mentioned Rahul Gandhi, Mamta Bannerjee, Akhilesh Yadav or anyone else who matters in Indian politics. 

Indian democracy isn't 'messy'. It is well organised. Unlike the US, there is an independent Election Commission. Sadly, it does delete the names of dead people from the voter rolls and this can cancel out the advantage of an incumbent State government. But that is what the Law requires.  

As governments struggle and discontent flourishes worldwide, the country offers a lesson for us all.

Have an independent Election Commission. Quash crazy protests before they turn violent. 

When I moved to India as a correspondent for The New York Times in 2009, I discovered a place

run by a nice Italian lady. That's true Democracy- right?  

brimming with optimism and ripe with possibility. Fresh off an election victory, the Congress Party formed a sturdy coalition government led by Manmohan Singh, a soft-spoken, teetotal technocrat with a Ph.D. in economics.

He had no power. Sad.  

Unfettered by its most irksome left-wing coalition partners,

Manmohan had done a nuclear deal with the US. Nothing came of it.  

his government would be free to make deep reforms and get India’s economy soaring.

It was already doing well. The Wall Street Crash didn't have much effect. Sadly, Manmohan wasn't permitted to do fundamental reform of labour and land laws.  


It didn’t work out that way. Indians saw their dreams of prosperity founder in the wake of the global financial crisis,

The economy had fully recovered by 2010. 

while their government was snarled in scandals of grubby self-dealing.

There was a lot of corruption. Also different Cabinet Ministers ignored the PM and pursued their own policies.  

An anti-corruption protest movement sprang up, expressive of deep discontent that Modi’s right-wing Hindu nationalist party rode to power. Modi pointed to the prosperous state he governed, Gujarat, and promised to do the same for the rest of India.

The anti-corruption movement morphed into the 'Common Man party' which still rules Punjab. It lost Delhi because of corruption and in-fighting. Two of the 'Cockroach' founders worked for that Party before it imploded. That is why there is media interest in them.  

Abstemious and devout, Modi offered himself up as a servant leader with no personal interests to pursue beyond the uplift of the nation.

Manmohan was equally clean. But he had no power.  

For many Hindus, his assertion of Hindu pride and even supremacy proved enticing. That he allegedly stood by idly as hundreds of Muslims died in religious riots in the state he governed in 2002 — his role in this tragedy led the United States to deny him entry for nine years

because they wanted to please the ruling party 

— was mostly ignored by the public.

Modi's reputation for killing Muslims helps him win elections in a Hindu nation which hates Islam and is frequently at war with Pakistan.  

One of the voters who rolled the dice on Modi was a man named Surender Kumar. I met him outside a popular market in Delhi, where he was waiting for passengers in his motorized rickshaw. Back in 2014, he was angry about corruption and thought it was time for a change. He cast his ballot, with some hesitation, for Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party. But a dozen years on, he is disappointed. “The government came with certain kinds of promises during the elections, and none of them we see right now,” he told me. “Just to protect kingmakers in the government, they are letting kids be beaten.”

 Kids should be allowed to burn buses. That way there will be higher income for rickshaw drivers. 

Though Kumar’s parents had been penniless manual laborers, he managed to leave their world of physical toil behind. Driving his rickshaw could net him between $200 and $300 a month, before expenses, a decent working-class living. But his son and daughter, growing into adulthood during Modi’s tenure, haven’t been able to make a similar leap.

Delhi was ruled by Congress & then the Common Man party. It has come under BJP rule only recently.

Kumar could not afford private school or tutoring classes for them, so neither made it to college. His daughter studied cosmetology and opened a small beauty salon, but has struggled to make a go of it. His son works at McDonald’s, earning what his father describes as pocket change. Inflation eats away at his own earnings: The price of the natural gas that fuels his rickshaw has more than doubled, he told me. “You can’t name a thing which has retained its price,” he said. “Rice, cooking oil, mustard oil, cooking cylinders.”

The cost of living does matter- as Trump well knows. Charges of 'authoritarianism' don't matter. It's just a type of pear-clutching old maids indulge in.  

Further up the economic ladder, among the middle-class Hindu families that make up many of Modi’s most fervent supporters, the struggle to provide economic advancement for the next generation is both all-consuming and increasingly uncertain.

Hormuz is hurting everybody.  


In a sprawling, tree-filled apartment complex at the northern edge of Delhi, Shivani Sharma, 
a teacher, described a life that revolved around a singular goal: getting her 17-year-old daughter, Sanskriti, into a good public university and launched into a well-paying career. This has involved expensive private schools and costly tutoring sessions to sharpen her math and science skills in preparation for the relentless battery of highly competitive government-administered entrance exams.

Higher caste people- like Shivani, want an end to Reservations. That is the real elephant in the room. Young people feel they are being unfairly treated just because of their ancestry. It may be that in 2030, reservations are not renewed. Much depends on the outcome of the caste census.  

“You have to have a very good score,” Sharma said. “Only then you can get entry into the Delhi University,” the prestigious school where she had gotten her bachelor’s degree in the 1990s.

Why not mention that Sharma wants the Government to get rid of reservations so that her meritorious daughter can get into a good College? 


For middle-class families, admission to a good public university is akin to a lottery ticket — the tuition is low and the credential confers real prestige. If Sanskriti does not make the cut, the family may have to come up with upward of $15,000 per year to pay for a private college. As it is, they struggle to keep up with her current educational expenses. In addition to running a school with her husband, Sharma earns extra money by tutoring children in the neighborhood. Her husband has a part-time job in a clothing showroom.


“We live simply,” she told me. “We don’t take international tours. We don’t wear expensive clothes. We don’t spend money here and there. We try to save money for our daughter’s education.” Sharma grew up in a big family, with five sisters and a brother. Yet none of her siblings has more than two children, she said. “We didn’t opt for the second child because I knew it’s very expensive and it’s very difficult to raise both the children and give them a good lifestyle and good education,” she told me.

Given the stakes, the leaked exam paper — expressive of deep corruption in the education system — rattled Sharma. “Some children committed suicide,” she said. “Only insiders can leak the paper. Who else can leak the paper? It’s a lot of corruption.”

It was a mistake for the Central Govt. to take control of such a big exam. Even if there was a leak in one place, only kids in that area should have been asked to re-sit the exam. To make everybody do it was utterly foolish.  

Even a bachelor’s degree from a prestigious college is no guarantee in a country where graduate unemployment is at nearly 40 percent for those ages 15 to 29 and starting salaries are abysmally low. Food delivery drivers often earn more than entry-level tech workers with engineering degrees. To improve Sanskriti’s chances in life, Sharma said they are considering sending her abroad for a master’s degree. That would probably cost $100,000, an unfathomable sum that would require them to go into debt.

There is increasing anger at the reservations policy. Some said that this contributed to the rise of the BJP after the Mandal report (i.e. extension of reservations to Educationally Backward castes). In UP, Akhilesh is backing reservations based on population share but we won't know what that is till the caste census is completed. 

Young people across the country increasingly see this as a fool’s bargain, a debt-filled dead end. And they are not afraid to say so, loudly and publicly. Aditi (she goes by one name), the 29-year-old president of the students’ union at Jawaharlal Nehru University,

She belongs to a Maoist party.  

is emblematic. Her parents are stalwart supporters of the B.J.P. But like many members of Gen Z, she rejects the empty promises of Hindu nationalism.

Because she is a Commie embedded in the Left/Liberal eco-system.  

“People have gotten bored with Modi’s narrative,” she told me. “Young people have tasted blood.”

Maoists used to make a point of drinking the blood of 'class enemies'.  


Modi’s government has faced down discontent before. In 2019, a new citizenship law that targeted Muslims

It didn't. It confirmed that non-Muslims fleeing Islamic persecution would continue to receive assylum and a path to citizenship in India.  

was rightly seen as an affront to India’s foundational ideal of secularism, enshrined in its constitution. But Modi was mostly able to wave that away as minority special pleading. Protests the next year by farmers, heavily drawn from India’s Sikh minority, could be dismissed as separatist agitation, even as the government mostly ceded to the farmers’ demands.

Farmers matter. Cockroaches don't.


But this time, the protests have been driven in part by the concerns of the aspirational Hindu families that are the bedrock of Modi’s coalition.

No. Aspirational Hindus want reservations to end & lower taxes on the urban middle class.  

For many of these Indians, it may have been possible to ignore the ugly aspects of Modi’s rule, indeed to retreat from politics altogether

doing politics used to mean asking nice Italian lady if she would like some pasta 

and focus on building futures for themselves and their children. But many are realizing that all their hard work can be scuppered by a purloined exam answer sheet; by the devaluation of college degrees, which command little premium in an oversupplied labor market; and by a compromised election commission that could silence their most fundamental individual choice in a country of over 1.4 billion people.

All this has been happening for decades. What is new is the threat to IT jobs from AI.  

Modi’s centralization — the very thing that seemed destined to consolidate his power — has become a booby trap.

Modi used to be a Chief Minister. He knows that each State has to pursue its own policies. You can't have micro-management from the Centre. One problem is that the BJP is over-reliant on bureaucrats with an inflated reputation for efficiency.  

He captured and muzzled the mainstream press, especially television news,

the mainstream media need advertising revenue which in turn depends on market share. If people are switching to your rival because of the political line that you take, you may consider moderating your stance.  

only for an enormous ecosystem of independent and influential journalists to rise up on YouTube and Instagram.

This has happened all over the world.  

He centralized the process of college examinations, leaving him no one else to blame when evidence of systemic leaking of exam papers emerged.

The thing was mishandled. Only a small number of students should have been asked to resit the paper. 

His control over the election commission has left him with few options when faced with difficult questions over deleted voters.

He has no control over them. It is the Supreme Court which will decide if they did something wrong. The Bench may ask Parliament to form a committee with a view to improving procedures.  

Modi has also discovered that despite his efforts to project global leadership, his power quickly fades at the water’s edge.

Modi isn't crazy. He knows that India is only a regional power. Still, it is partnering with different countries for different purposes. 

After promising to elevate India to great-power status,

Modi knows that voters don't care about this. 

he has found himself stuck, subject to the mundane gravity of global events over which he has little control. He has suffered a series of embarrassments on the world stage, especially at the hands of the Trump administration.

Trump has embarassed everybody. So what? Indians don't give a fuck about him.  


What’s more, the pressure valve of migration is tightening. On the upper end of society, the dream of sending a child abroad, especially to the United States, is dying. On the lower end, uncertainty in the Persian Gulf is making migrant labor there a shakier proposition too. For a country that is the world’s largest receiver of remittances, amounting to roughly 4 percent of gross domestic product, that’s a big problem. That’s before you consider rising prices for fuel and tariffs on exports.

Economic problems are of great importance. Whom do voters think will be better at dealing with them? Currently, it is the BJP because the Opposition is disunitied & Rahul is a retard. 


There will be no sudden fall for Modi. Though leaders in neighboring South Asian countries like Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka have been swept aside by youth uprisings, there is little chance of that happening here.

Which is why the cockroach protests were utterly insignificant.  

India may seem like a chaotic and cacophonous place, and in many ways it is. Yet India’s government has always changed through the orderly process of elections, and Modi will not face the national electorate again until 2029.

What really matters is the UP election in March 2027.  

But something profound has shifted. Modi’s aura of omnipotence and serene competence has been shattered.

in 2024 when he lost his majority. But since then his party has gained West Bengal & Delhi & Orissa.  

The protests have transformed his main challenger, Rahul Gandhi of the Congress Party, as well. They have given him the chance to shed his image as the pampered and ineffectual scion of a storied political dynasty. The political landscape, settled for so long, is suddenly altered.

The BJP hopes that Rahul will come across as relying on a Muslim votebank. Interestingly, Owaisi- the ambitious leader of a Muslim party- is staying away from 'vote chori' allegations. Why? Hindus will vote for the BJP if they think it really is getting rid of Muslims on the electoral roll. 

India’s democracy has always been improbable.

It was dynastic till assassination tempered autocracy.  

It is a society of boggling diversity and deep divides of religion, ethnicity and caste. Inequality, always pervasive, has deepened as the country has grown richer in ragged, uneven ways. And yet its constitutional democracy has endured, with the brief exception of Indira Gandhi’s emergency rule, since its independence from Britain nearly eight decades ago.

Indira realised that her son's pals would arrange a nice 'accident' for her. The problem with being the Emperor of Delhi, is that your kids will try to kill you to grab the throne. That's why Indira held elections- though she didn't expect to lose them by such a big margin. Fortunately, the Oppposition was deeply divided and thus she returned to power with a full majority within three years.  


It is telling that this unexpected challenge to Modi’s power was catalyzed by affronts to two fundamental features of Indian democracy.

India always had a problem of 'booth capture'. Reforms in the Nineties tackled the problem but in places like Mamta's West Bengal it requried massive presence of police from other states to curb the power of the criminals who controlled the voting booths.  

As the political scientist Pratap Bhanu Mehta

who is utterly useless 

explained to me, taking exams and voting in elections are perhaps the two most important pillars of individual agency in India.

I can't recall a time when the newspapers weren't filled with stories of leaked question papers & booth capturing. Indeed, people weren't even bothering to cheat. They just bought degree certificates. That's how you ended up with illiterate teachers in Government Schools.  

Each contains the possibility of self-actualization, something that can seem nearly impossible in a country that is simultaneously so multitudinous and so hierarchical.

meaningless jibber-jabber. At one time, people thought Mehta might be a proper political scientist commissioning surveys and analysing voting data. He preferred to babble nonsense about how he lurved Lord Rama- who is everywhere and thus ought not to have any Temples. 

Exams hold the promise that anyone from anywhere, with enough hard work, can improve his or her station in life.

Unless there are resrvations and quotas. India has plenty of Jason Arday type Professors.  

Even more fundamental, if diffuse, is the individual franchise, which carries the notion that each citizen has an equal role in choosing who governs India.

Nope. The majority gets to fuck over the minority. India broke apart after the 1946 election. Pakistan broke apart after its first General Election.  

These two pillars, Mehta told me, are “the self-conscious revolt against caste, kinship, religion.”

Which expresses itself as Dynastic parties based on a particular sub-caste.  

This is perhaps why copies of the Indian Constitution have figured so prominently in the protests, along with images of its main architect, Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar.

Everyone wants the Dalit vote.  But Ambedkar wanted a sunset clause on reservations. Maybe they won't be renewed in 2030. 

It is easy to harbor romantic notions about Indian democracy.

it became dynastic. A nice Italian lady was appointing its Election Commissioners 21 years ago. What was her qualification for running the country? The answer is she was the Queen Regent for, the moon-calf, Rahul.  

It is a project never before attempted in human history — for so many people with so much diversity to live together by common assent, under a written constitution that guarantees rights for all.

The Brits had started holding general elections in 1923. India was way bigger (it contained Burma, Pakistan & Bangladesh) back then. What nobody expected was that the House of Nehru would replace the House of Windsor.  

For the past 12 years, India has engaged in a different experiment, one all too willing to brush aside the unfulfilled aspirations of the Constitution in the name of material progress and Hindu pride.

Rahul refused to step up to the plate. He had torn up Manmohan's ordinance but refused to replace that Prone Minister. It was a case of 'Modi or nobody'.  


But a new generation of Indians has risen up,

they have voted the BJP to power in West Bengal, Delhi, & Orissa.  

insisting that the price of that trade is far too high. Armed only with witty slogans

two of the leaders did Masters degrees abroad. They have returned to India in the hope of making money as independent political strategists or Social Media influencers.  

and astonishing bravery, these young people have revived their country’s glorious tradition of nonviolent dissent.

Will the Cockroach party win elections in the same manner as the Common Man party? No. Still, some of the people involved may make a lot of money.  

As peers from Paris to Tirana, Milan to Madrid, take to the streets demanding radical change, they would do well to look to Delhi as a guide.

What they will see is that Modi easily crushed stupid kids. In India, only elections matter. The State has enormous reserves of coercive power. The Brits crushed the Freedom Movement easily enough. Indira crushed the opposition easily enough. Still, Indian politicians like fighting elections because the thing is an addictive competitive sport.  

No comments: