This was by no means a bad thing. Compulsory, state-funded, education had taken root and the need for additional qualifications helped raise teaching standards which, in turn, led to productivity growth and thus higher tax receipts. However, as STEM subjects had a more direct relationship to productivity and military security, there was a growing gap between what CP Snow called 'the two cultures'. Put simply, the Liberal Arts were becoming adversely selective of imbecility. Once the baby boom petered out, there would be fewer jobs for pedants teaching soft subjects.
It means its meaning is obscure. It would take some time and much trouble to decipher it or grasp its meaning. The question is whether undertaking the task would be rewarding in net terms.
My own experience of translating Ghalib (who is depicted as a witless cry-baby by American academics) led me to the conclusion that a 'difficult' poem is one which deals with an 'open problem' (i.e. one where the STEM subjects haven't yet 'closed'). These 'open problems' are crucially linked to the viability of 'business models'- i.e. economic vulnerabilities regarding our 'mode of production'. Thus, they relate to the lived life or life-world of Homo Economicus.
The problem with 'open problems' is that they can give rise to an algorithmic method to write pretentious twaddle. You can give the impression of being a deep thinker without ever having had any thoughts at all. A good poet searches around only to finally acknowledge that significant portions of the 'open problem' have been closed once and for all but bird-brained bards have taken no notice. There is a pathos in this though not precisely the páthei máthos (πάθει μάθος — "learning through suffering" of Aescylus. Still, as a matter of good form, when meeting a Greek person, I am always careful to enquire about my old friend Agamemnon. I hope he and his wife Clytemnestra are very happy with each other. If you bump into him, you might care to remind him that he still owes me a fiver for when he had to catch a train to Troy-town and found himself a little illiquid.
A person may deliberately obfuscate his meaning. Alternatively, the topic may be hard to understand. My notion of 'difficulty' is that it arises by acknowledgement that we haven't updated our structural causal model and this has hysteresis effects.
Language can be used badly or with an intention to mystify. Indeed, some people enjoy ciphering or deciphering messages which might be plain enough in themselves.
We are all aware that it takes some effort to express yourself clearly in a particular language. We also know that there are occassions when you may wish not to talk a lot without communicating anything. One may 'speak in riddles' so only a select few understand your meaning.
No. We can generaly give a good enough answer for any practical purpose. Still, there are situations were we whould have to say 'our information set isn't big enough to understand this particular text. We must suspend judgement.'
we know that not all thoughts have linguistic expression & that a lot texts have very little thought put into them.
Descartes did suggest that sloppy thinking led to opacity. However, even 'an attentive mind' would struggle with 'clear and distinct' ideas encoding cognitively very complex information.
Common sense tell us that our linguistic intentions can misfire. We 'mis-speak'. But, for a great poem, the assumption is that difficulty is intentional. The aim may be to imepede understanding so as to intensify the 'Eureka!' moment. Equally, there may be a 'Straussian' reason why the poet writes obscurely about things which could cause him to be persecuted.
Professor of Literature may be stupider than average. Alternatively, their brains may have been destroyed by 'literary theory'.
This may be the case for some texts. However, the author himself may clarify matters or else those close to him may do so on his behalf.
We don't need a theory. We understand words like 'easy' and 'difficult' from a very young age. Things which are easy when you are young become difficult when your grow old and vice versa.
No. A poem or a theorem or a philosophical argument may be easy to understand for some people but not others with a different information set.
If it is easy for us, we can paraphrase it easily. If it is difficult, we may have to do a lot research before we can do so.
A theorem in mathematics is difficult when proving it requires unfamiliar concepts, bridging separate fields, or overcoming massive technical and logical hurdles. Perhaps, Steiner means 'the proof of a theorem'. Some proofs may be very long or involve hidden assumptions (e.g. stronger axioms).
’s 2012 proof of the abc conjecture is difficult because it spans roughly 500 to 600 pages and relies on inter-universal Teichmüller (IUT) theory, a brand-new mathematical framework built largely in isolation. Rather than using familiar number theory tools, it constructs an intricate system of new definitions and notation that requires hundreds of pages of prerequisites just to approach.
Similarly a poem may be difficult because the poet is using symbols of his own invention or else a private mythology or system of references.
But plainly enough, there is a difference. We may be aiming at something far less inherent or 'substantive ' - a slippery term where languge is concerned - than concept.
There can be a concept for anything at all.
Far more often than not we signify by 'a difficulty' something that 'we need to look up'.
i.e. we need to do research to expand our information set. We may say 'this is difficult for the lay-man or non-specialist.'
In what must be, statistically, the overwhelming plurality of cases, it will be a single word or a phrase which are not at once intelligible to us. Our resort to the authority of the dictionary is precisely analogous to that which we perform when translating from a foreign tongue.
Using a dictionary is just a type of research. But, we may also have to think deeply about the matter.
The word may be archaic: when Venus laughs on every wi'ght in The Merchant's Tale or we meet with mighty di'nts in The Kni'ght's Tale, we may no longer know what Chaucer is telling us. The obstacle may be one of dialect: that Warwickshire mobled which elicits Polonius's approval, or the Northumbrian di'ngle in which Auden finds darkness.
We don't think Chaucer was difficult for his contemporaries.
The expression can be arcane and technical : it might not be immediately apparent to the reader just what 'bliss' T.S.Eliot promises when he qualifies it as pneumati'c (the finesse lies in the Attic and theological antecedents to the epithet) .
billowy breasts. He is talking of 'Grishkin' whose 'friendly bust, gives promise of pneumatic bliss.' That's not tough to understand at all.
Frequently, the poet is a neologist, a recombinant wordsmith : just what suave instrument had Mandelstam in mind when he invoked the music of the tormenvox?
The theremin. A Russian invented this electronic musical instrument.
Writers are passionate resuscitators of buried or spectral words: to disedge fades after the early seventeenth century, but proves to be exactly what Tennyson requires to blunt 'The sharpness of that pain'.
Disedge means to take the edge off a thing- i.e. to blunt it. Again, this isn't difficult to understand at all.
From Theocritus to the Edwardians, the manifold of exact denominations of fauna and flora is the cipher of western lyric poetry.
People know the names of flowers and animals.
It is now largely lost to our everyday awareness.
Fuck off!
Was Matthew Arnold quite certain whether he meant the plant of the genus Fri'ti'llari'a or the species of butterfly, the silver-washed fritillary or the Queen of Spain, when he hailed the 'white and purple fritillaries by Ensham and down by Sandford?'
The flowers. They are the 'grassy harvest of the river-fields'.
Many of us, at least, will tum to the Oxford English Dictionary or the Royal Horticultural Society 's invaluable Di'cti'onary of Gardeni'ng.
Unless, like Arnold, they are English and like to walk by the river.
At certain moments in the history of poetry, le mot rare becomes the object of explicit pursuit and delight: to this day, Mallarme 's famous ptyx, one of the indispensable, sovereign rhymes in the sonnet on ix, appears neither in the Littre nor in the Nouveau Larousse (but it can be unmasked, via Greek and via liturgical art and this, as we shall see, is a key point).
The point about Mallarme is that the meaning does not matter.
The below-ground vocabularies and syntax of slang, of argot, of taboo-usage, are sometimes almost as extensive and polysemic as those of mundane discourse.
Such argot constitutes the mundane discourse of particular sub-cultures.
If a monaker was a guinea to the Victorian underworld, it was a proud ten-oared boat in the Eton College songs and odes of the day.
That boat is called the Monarch. But, in song, it was referred to as 'Ten'.
To Thackeray an ass was a moke.
Probably imported from Romani.
Villon's idiom is, to a large measure, the rhyming cant and hieroglyph of thieves. Poetry is knit of words compacted with every conceivable mode of operative force. These words are, in Coleridge 's simile , 'hooked atoms', so construed as to mesh and crossmesh with the greatest possible cluster of other words in the reticulations of the total body of language.
That is indeed how words work. But that's because that's how thoughts work. Language is about communicating thoughts- at least some of them.
The poet attempts to anchor the particular word in the dynamic mould of its own history, enriching the core of its present definition with the echo and alloy of previous use.
That is what the hermeneut does. The poet may not give a shit about its history.
He is an etymologist, often violent and arbitrary as was Holderlin, who attempts to break open the eroded or frozen shell of speech in order to compel to daylight and release the dynamics, the primal crystallizations of perception that may lie at the roots.
Holderlin was mad. People who gas on about him are merely stupid.
The poet's discourse can be compared to the track of a charged particle through a cloud-chamber.
No. It is easy to track a poet's discourse. Cloud chambers were invented because charged particles are difficult to track.
An energized field of association and connotation, of overtones and undertones, of rebus and homophone, surround its motion,
this is true of anything said by anybody. Some of my more elaborate farts, too, have this quality.
and break from it in the context of collision (words speak not only to the ear, but to the eye and even to the touch).
They will give you a beejay if they really like you.
Multiplicity of meaning, 'enclosedness', are the rule rather than the exception. We are meant to hear both solid and sullied, both toil and coil in the famous Shakespearean cruces. Lexical resistance is the armature of meaning, guarding the poem from the necessary commonalties of prose.
Prose can be poetic. Poetry can be prosaid.
The poem, in turn, is custodian of 'the holiness of minute particulars' (Blake 's phrase).
Plenty of poems gas on about the 'general good' and never come down to brass tacks.
However abstruse the argument or universal the inference, the poet gives local habitation and name. Immediately past the obstacle of word or phrase, it is these we must look up. Mythologies, the names of stars, topography, the unnumbered furnishings of reality through which the poem incarnates and makes concrete .
If we aren't teaching that shite, we needn't bother. We understand words we don't know contextually.I don't know what the word 'cunt' means but since I am generally referred to as a fat cunt, I think the meaning is a person of great beauty and charm.
Because it is ontologically economical
Nonsense! Poetry is morel likely to be ontologically multivalent or dysphoric.
- another difference from prose - the language of the poem implicates a surrounding and highly active context, a corpus, possibly an entire world of supporting, echoing, validating, or qualifying material whose compass underwrites its own concision.
Poems may refer to other poems in a subtle or cryptic manner. If there are rival itnerpretations of those other poems, this may get reflected in the poem itself.
The implication is effected by virtue of allusion, of reference to.
Prose may be 'Straussian'. The writer appears to be talking of some long distant event. He may actually be referring to contemporary events.
The manybranched antennae which literally bristle outward from a line of Milton or Keats or Rilke to classical mythology are the precise contrary to dispersion.
This is because all three saw themselves as standing in a particular relationship to a common classical inheritance.
They make possible the compact largesse of the text;
the reception of that text
they embody the fully declared but unsaid codes and presences from which the poem draws its local generality.
They can be said and have been said at wearisome length.
This is notably the case in Western poetry,
or Persian or Arabic or Chinese or Indic poetry
so much of whose charged substance is previous poetry: Chaucer lives in Spenser
He really doesn't. What in Chaucer was raucous, in Spenser is twee.
who lives in Dryden who lives in Keats.
who all live in some textbook poor sods have to teach to cretins.
The continuity inside these poetic visions, unbroken to the time of T.S.Eliot and of Robert Lowell, is that of specific 'elementals' and guarantors of felt meaning, namely Virgil, Horace, and Ovid, without whom the entire climate of recognitions on which our sense of poetic meaning is grounded would be hollow.
The reverse is the case. We first read poetry in our mother tongue and only gradually come to the classical languages.
But if other poetry is often the primary agent of context, so is, potentially at least, 'everything that is the case'.
Or everthing that can't be the case.
A poet can crowd his idiom, his landscape of motion, with the minutiae of history, of locale, of technical process (a key passage in Hamlet turns on the arcane technicalities of dyeing).
There's lots of dying in Hamlet.
He can cram hell, purgatory, and paradise with gossip so private that elucidation hinges on an almost street-by-street intimacy with thirteenth-century Florence.
Plenty of juicy gossip back then.
The occult node of vision may be just that: an esoteric, a system of hermetic nomination and rites as in the poetry of Yeats.
Some of it. The point about Blake or Yeats is that you don't need to know the details.
These several orders of difficulty, of that which needs to be looked up, constitute almost the entire fabric of Pound's Cantos, a meta-epic or paradistic epic whose essential tropes are those of inventory, private journal and almanac.
Subscribing to a shitty economic theory turns your brain to shite.
At the close of Canto XXXVIII: Opposite the Palace of the Schneiders Arose the monument of Herr Henri Chantier de Ia Gironde, Bank of the Paris Union , The franco-japanese bank Francois de Wendel, Robert Protot To friends and enemies of tomorrow 'the most powerful union is doubtless that of the Comite des Forges,' 'And God take your living' said Hawkwood 15 million: Journal des De bats 30 million paid to Le Temps Eleven for the Echo de Paris .... And granted that one's homework is done - that the ephemeral scandals of high finance in the steel and armaments industry, that the collusions between rotten republic and fascist empire, between bourse , bank and press, have been unravelled: what then of 'Hawkwood', not one suspects a fortuitous shard of private allusion, but a pointing to, a 'tuning towards' the characteristic dialectic of 'debate', of 'time' and of 'echo' in the lines following?
Hawkwood was a mercenary in 14th century Italy. According to legend, two friars greeted Hawkwood by wishing him peace ("May God give you peace"), to which the mercenary replied, "And may God take away your alms (living)," pointing out that peace would ruin his livelihood just as it would theirs. Obviously, this is a deeply silly story. In peaceful times, there will be plenty of friars.
Pound's paranoid shite is tedious, not difficult.
To be looked up. As are the Greek tag and the high name of battle in one of the rapt sequences in Canto XXI: And after that hour, dry darkness Floating flame in the air, gonads in organdy, Dry flamelet, a petal borne in the wind. Gignetei kalon. Impenetrable as the ignorance of old women. In the dawn, as the fleet coming in after Actium Shore to the eastward and altered .... And the looking up lies at the heart of the music ; the one falls mute without the other. This is the point. Witness what is perhaps the epiphany, the leap to annunciation in the whole ramshackle majesty of Pound's design: the climax to the famous adjurations in Canto LXXXI: But to have done instead of not doing this is not vanity To have, with decency, knocked That a Blunt should open
Blunt served roast peacock to Pound and some other poets in 1914.
To have gathered from the air a live tradition or from a fine old eye the unconquered flame This is not vanity. Fair enough : but why 'a Blunt', and who is he? That proud old crank, Wilfred Scawen Blunt, and if so, what was there in his life and work to account for this luminous insertion?
The dude dressed up as an A-rab though it was his wife who spoke that language. He was a pal of some Islamist. Islam is against usury. Jews are money-lenders. Connect the fucking dots.
This entire genus of difficulty and its main species conjoin in a fairly typical passage in the later style of Shakespeare - Timon of Athens, IV,3: 0 blessed breeding Sun, draw from the earth Rotten humidity: below thy Sisters Orbe Infect the ayre. Twin'd Brothers of one wombe, Whose procreation, residence, and birth, Scarse is dividant; touch them with several! fortunes, The greater scomes the lesser. Not Nature (To whom all sores lay siege) can beare great Fortune But by contempt of Nature Raise me this Begger, and deny 't that Lord, The Senator shall bear contempt Hereditary, The Begger Native Honor. It is the Pasture Lards the rothers sides, The want that makes him lean: who dares? who dares In puritie of Manhood stand upright And say, this mans a Flatterer. lf one be, So are they all; for every grize of Fortune Is smooth 'd by that below. The Learned pate Duckes to the Golden Foole. All's oblique ....
Lines worthy of Savonarola" Brown.
'Grasp ' in such a case is a concentric process, rippling outward from an immediate, almost instinctive, blurred apprehension ('I do know what this is about, in a sort of general way ; the dramatic situation and certain key markers and emblematic sign-posts tell me ') to successive levels of decoding.
Only if you are teaching it or are an actor or director deciding which words to emphasize and which to hurry over.
Of these, the first is purely lexical: depending on the degree of relevant literacy or familiarity with seventeenth-century diction, we find ourselves looking up, say, orbe, dividant, rothers (or should it be, as many editors emend, wethers or, as I suspect, an 'undecidable ' active between both possibilities as they congrue in 'brothers?'),
Fuck off! Rother means cattle. There's a Rother Market in Stratford-upon-Avon.
grize, pate. But 'purely' lexical is, of course, wrong. The truly arduous terms, those which Empson would cite in his studies of · 'complex words', are Nature, Fortune, Native Honor, Manhood and, possibly, Golden Foole (leaving aside the intriguing question as to whether it is by Shakespeare 's design that the First Folio alternates between upper and lower case with respect to 'Fortune' and 'Nature') .
Empson was a cunt. That's a complex word for you.
In rigorous tum, the probing of these words would lead from the dictionary and Shakespeare-concordance to the study of the very most dense, central topics in Elizabethan thought.
There was no monolithic Elizabethan thought. Even the 'proto-Scientists' (e.g. Gibert & Frances Bacon) were bitterly at odds. Shakespeare may have been one up on Bacon because he knew Thomas Digges quite well and thus may have supported his heliocentrism & theory of infinite space.
Still, even if 'thought' wasn't unified, we may certainly speak of what was well received on the Elizabethan stage.
It would lead to a study of the doctrine and metaphor of fortuna with its intricate background in antiquity and the Latin Middle Ages;
not that intricate. By a certain age, if you write verse, you would have pretty much wrung that theme dry.
to an investigation of the tight-meshed skein of abstract and imaged meanings around the concept of natura ;
I suppose, a coffee table book on the topic would pretty much write itself.
to an analysis of the crucial but problematic notion of 'honor', an ambiguous notion in the light of Christian values, and one made even more many-valued here by Shakespeare 's addition of Native.
We achieve this anyway better than any Professor of worthless shite.
Manhood pivots on the whole renaissance paradigm of virtu ,
which, oddly is the same our paradigm of a guy who doesn't take it up the arse while weeping bitterly.
and one suspects that the Golden Foole has behind him those precedents of parable, of allegory, of archetypal figuration which provide the economy of Shakespeare 's late manner with its resonance.
No. It just means a rich dude with shit for brains.
And surrounding all these incarnate topics is the literal sphere of the Aristotelian-Boethian firmament with its 'Sister Orbes',
The supernova of 1572 had pretty much buried the Aritotelian cosmos. Was Shakespeare on the side of Digges or that of Bacon? Nobody cares.
its pharmacology of noxious exhalations, and its vehemently direct influence on the cosmic mysteries of 'procreation, residence, and birth' - a sphere, whose decipherment requires a fine understanding of medieval and Renaissance systems of astronomy and astrology, together with some notion of the medical theory of 'humours'.
Fuck off! In 1583, Cambridge scholar and astrologer Richard Harvey published an Astrological Discourse predicting catastrophic weather and political upheaval tied to the conjunction of Saturn and Jupiter. When that date passed, Harvey was mercilessly mocked by Greene & Nashe.
Indeed, the invocation of the breeding Sun may point to more hermetic considerations, to those filaments of Gnostic and alchemical belief which so often brush the far edges of Elizabethan and Shakespearean cosmology.
The ague (malaria) was common till the twentieth century. People didn't understand the role of the anopheles mosquito. The Sun seemed to draw 'vapours' out of the ground. The word malaria is related to miasma and means 'bad air'.
Homework : mountainous, and becoming more so as our twentieth-century brands of literacy recede from the vocabulary, from the grammars, from the grid of classical and biblical reference which have mapped the contours of Western poetry from Caxton and Chaucer to the archival gathering or museum-catalogue in The Waste Land and the Cantos.
The Wasteland is short and had footnotes. The Cantos were a tedious and interminable labyrinth whose Ariadne had a bee in her bonnet about fractional reserve banking and the steel cartel.
Homework which is, in a real sense, interminable, as there is always more 'to look up' (what reticulations are dynamic in the possibility that grize, the single step or stair in a flight, chimes with 'graze ' as on a 'Pasture ', and is a variant on grece with its evident pointers to 'Lards' and to 'smooth'd' in the line following?). 'Looking things up ' does not stop because the context pertinent to a major poem or poetic text is that of the whole ambient culture, of the whole history of and in the language, of the mental sets and idiosyncracies in con temporary sensibility.
There are diminishing returns to doing so. We get that some nutters think there was something super-special about some particular period in the history of some particular country. But nutters of every sort we will always have plenty of.
(The issue is philosophically vital : a language-act is inexhaustible to interpretation precisely because its context is the world.)
But interpretation is a 'convergent series'. Pound had a crazy economic theory. He really wasn't talking about the neighbour's cat.
Moreover, there is an inevitable feed-back: with every particular clarification, comes a motion of return to the poem. What we have looked up of Elizabethan teachings on astral influence works back on our reading of Timon's monologue.
But does not appreciably change it.
It makes that monologue richer, which is to say that it raises new questions: what, for example , was Shakespeare 's own addendum to or variation on the prevalent picture of the origins and kinship, literal and allegoric, of sun and moon?
There was none. Timon is a nutter. He is raving away in the semi-literate fashion of such people.
In practice, the homework of elucidation may be unending. No individual talent or life-span, no collective industry, can complete the task.
Just as nobody can compute the value of Pi to its last decimal.
But not in theory, not formally. This is my point. Theoretically, there is somewhere a lexicon, a concordance, a manual of stars, a flon"legium, a pandect of medicine, which will resolve the difficulty. In the 'infinite library' (Borges's 'Library that is the Universe') the necessary reference can be found.
No. Cantors 'diagonal argument' explains why.
Waltet Benjamin suggests that there are cruces and talismanic deeps in poetry which cannot be elucidated now or at all times; they were understood formerly, they may be rightly glossed 'tomorrow'. No matter: in some time, at some place, the difficulty can be resolved.
Aristotle says that akreibia- seeking for greater precision than the subject matter affords- is a mistake in rhetoric. You have to trade off the cost of further inquiry against the likely benefit. This is 'economia'.
Conceivably, the distance between a culture and certain texts can grow so drastic that everything has to be looked up {this is almost the case when a twentieth-century student tries to read Pindar, say, or Dante or certain stretches of Milton).
Once diminishing returns have set in, a field will only attract imbeciles.
In practice this may make the given text inaccessible ; it slips over the horizon of pragmatic perception as do the retreating galaxies. But the point is pragmatic , not ideal or theoretical. Granted time and explicative means, even every thing can be looked up.
Where? The problem is that people may be moving away from the text to look up stupid shite that was the product of other savant's 'looking up'.
I suggest, therefore , that we label this first class of difficulties {statistically by far the most compendious class) as 'epiphenomenal ' or, more plainly, as contingent difficulties. In the overwhelming majority of cases, what we mean by saying 'this is difficult' signifies 'this is a word, a phrase or a reference which I will have to look up.'
Because the text does not have enough redundancy- i.e. does not contain enough information to allow the reader to 'fill out' gaps in her own knowledge.
In the total library, in the collectanea and summa summarum of all things, I can do just that.
No. By Cantor's diagonal argument, there will always be an infinite number of works on looking up looking up in that context.
And find that aptyx is a conch.
That is an ipse dixe assertion of an arbitrary type.
Contingent difficulties are the most visible, they stick like burrs to the fabric of the text. Yet we may find ourselves saying 'this is a difficult poem' or 'I find it difficult to grasp, to place this poem' {the shift in to a first-person register of experience is, here, significant) even where the lexicalgrammatical components are pellucid.
That may be a 'you' problem. You face a difficulty which another person may not by reason of their different 'Life-world'.
We have looked up what there is to look up,
but need to look up an infinite number of works on the looking up of looking up in that context.
we have confidently parsed the elements of phrase -and still there is opaqueness.
This is like Suhrawardy's notion of 'barzakh' as the opaqueness of what exists which can only be overcome by going to the 'na-koja abad'- the land of no-place where there is nothing but light. Perhaps, Pound's own 'light from Eleusis' was similar. It appears he saw an Islamic influence on Cavalcanti's 'donna mi prega' but, like Suhrawardy, saw this as transmitting a more ancient Meditteranean wisdom.
In some way, the centre , the rationale of the poem's being, holds against us. The sensation is almost tactile. There is, at empirical levels, 'understanding' - of the rough and ready order represented by paraphrase - but no genuine 'comprehension', no in-gathering in the range of senses inseparable from the archaic Greek legein (to 'assemble', to 'enfold in meaningful shape').
Again this is a mere ipse dixit assertion. Still, one may certainly say that one can't respond to a particular poem because it concerns things you have no experience of or interest in.
The experience of obstruction is at once banal and elusive. A move in American slang, though already somewhat dated, may pinpoint the cardinal distinction: we 'get the text' but we don't 'dig it' (and the suggestion of active penetration is exactly apposite).
Apparently, the phrase comes from American College students in the 1820s who used 'dig it' to mean to study the subject diligently. It was adopted by Jazz musicians in the in 1930s.
The poem in front of us articulates a stance towards human conditions which we find essentially inaccessible or alien.
or simply stupid or paranoid
The tone, the manifest subject of the poem are such that we fail to see a justification for poetic form, that the root-occasion of the poem 's composition eludes or repels our internalized sense of what poetry should or should not be about, of what· are the intelligible, morally and aesthetically acceptable moments and motives for poetry.
This is particularly the case when a good lyric poet starts banging on about some crazy economic theory or pseudo-science like alchemy.
The poem enacts language in modes we find illicit; there is radical impropriety be tween its performative means and what we take to be the spirit, the native pulse, the constraints of the relevant tongue or idiom.
Bis repetitia placent. We like what we are already familiar with. We find it difficult to appreciate work which wanders away from what pleased us before.
Here the notoriously abbreviated and there fore elusive Aristotelian notion of 'propriety', of that which is proper to a given poetic genre, would be pertinent. Again, to be sure, there is one sense, at least, in which this type of difficulty is referential. The poet may have left an explanatory statement telling us what he is about, what his intentions and formal co-ordinates were. There . may be a document which will clarify the occasion or anti-occasion of the poem's composition. But even then, we may find that the region of difficulty has only been displaced or better defined.
If the 'region of difficulty' has intrinsic merit, we may be grateful for having been led to it in a graceful manner. Thus, one may start of by liking the romantic aspect of a poet's work and being impatient of the author's spiritual or religious beliefs. However, at a later point, we may find greater comfort in the religious texts to which he led us.
The process of 'looking it up' does not lead to an unambiguous solution ; or, more precisely, it falls to one side of the operative distinction between surface-understanding or paraphrase on the one hand, and penetrative comprehension on the other.
Looking up involves going to the commentaries and the commentaries on commentaries. It may itself lead to your commentary on a commentary on a commentary. But this commentorial tradition may become more and more removed from the original text and accumulate errors at an exponential rate.
The objection would now be this: 'are you not confusing what you call genuine insight with merely aesthetic judgment?
an insight may well be an aesthetic judgment. The question is whether it is anchored in reality. It is possible to read Dante as a crypto-Muslim or Marxist. But, the truth is, he was neither.
Are you not muddling questions of difficulty with those of taste?'
Some have a taste for what is obscure.
The overlap is undoubtedly there, and the nuances are blurred. Nevertheless, there is a real discrimination to be made : as between our pleasure in or displeasure at something that we have thoroughly apprehended, and our reaction to, our atrophy of response towards a text whose autonomous force of life, whose raison d'etre in the strict sense of the phrase, escape us.
Sadly, we don't know our own raison d'etre let alone that of anybody else. Still, we may read in the introduction to a text which is enjoyable in itself, that the writer had some cock-eyed theory which he was seeking to promote. Some 'easy' texts- e.g. Gullivers Travels- may actually be a recondite satire on early Eighteenth Century politics.
We have done our homework, the sinews of the poem are manifest to us; but we do not feel 'called upon ', or 'answerable to', in both of which tags the primary bonds of interaction between the poem and its listener or reader are active.
We may like a religious or ideological poet while disliking the creed he espoused. Equally, one may like the advertisement for a thing but dislike the thing itself.
And it is just because this failure of summoning and response can lie wholly outside the categories of 'liking' or 'disliking' that it is not, or not only, a question of taste .
Taste is 'co-evolved'. It serves a eusocial function. It is likely that our 'hardwired' taste is for that which embodies 'the law of increasing functional information'. The great writers 'show more than they know'. Their tutelary genius allows them to reveal what they themselves may be unaware of.
The difficulty which we are up against is of a class which I propose to call modal (a term used by C.S.Lewis). I can instance it with regards to Lovelace's fifteen-line lyric, La Bella Bona Roba: I cannot tell who loves the Skeleton Of a poor Marmoset, nought but boan, boan Give me a nakedness with her cloath's on. Such whose white-sattin upper coat of skin, Cuts upon Velvet rich Incarnadin, Ha's yet a Body (and of Flesh within) . Sure it is meant good Husbandry in m en , Who do incorporate with Aery Jeane, T' repair their sides, and get their Ribb agen. s Hard hap unto that Huntsman that Decrees Fat joys for all his swet, when as he sees, After his 'Say, nought but his Keepers Fees. Then Love I beg, when next thou tak'st thy Bow, Thy angry shafts, and dost Heart-chasing go, Passe Rascall Deare , strike me the largest doe.
We get that the dude likes to fuck fat ho-bags. This is neither moral nor modal.
Contingent difficulties swarm; but they are tractable. Once we know that a bella bona roba is Caroline argot, very likely of Venetian provenance, for a 'whore ', much falls into place. Marmoset is tricky,
a small monkey
but the various senses and intonations center on somthing like a small monkey or emblematic grotesque known for lechery. The whole lyric pivots on the dual meaning of 'venery' as sexual chase and the hunt of animals - a twinning as old as the myth of Meleager and heavily routine in European love-poetry and erotic satire from the twelfth century on.
You don't get syphilis when you kill a deer.
Hence the twofold agency of Huntsman, of Say (for 'assay'), of the Keepers Fees (referring simultaneously to the brothel and to the huntsman 's tract of woodland or moor), of Bow (hunter Cupid) , of the angry shafts, which are both 'arrows' and, to this day, 'phallus', and the obvious play on Heartchasing and on Rascall Deare - a technical term signifying a particularly lean animal. Another routine turn is that on Husbandry in the sense of economy and conjugality. This line of duality is taken up in the allusion to Adam's rib , whose excision has left men bereft.
Steiner has explained the poem well. Where is the difficulty?
Quite evidently , the text energizes and elaborates on a richlyavailable stock of verbal-emotive congruencies between eros and the slaying of game. Thus a nakedness, the white-sattin upper coat of skin, the velvety carmine beneath it, and the motif of gauntness in boan, boan, in Aery leane, the contrastive Fat joys and the Rascal/ Deare , meld the worpan's bone and flesh with that of the slain quarry. But these elements, all of which are subject to 'being looked up' and verified by analogy with a host of Petrarchan and contemporary verse, do not take us very far.
Unless we are wanking as we read that shite.
There is something palpably unsettling, even repellent, about the movement and lunge of the whole poem. The order of difficulty is not removed by clarification of word and phrase. It functions centrally.
Fucking whores is like hunting a tethered animal. The difficulty we face is that the thing is ugly. Perhaps that is the point.
Another circuit of reference seems to be in Lovelace's text, at a covert, 'in-group ' level -
was he taking a dig at Queen Henrietta who was small and thin? No. She had shown him much favour. He expended his considerable fortune in the Royalist cause. Still, Henrietta's Catholicism had harmed the Royal family.
a set of intimations that lies behind the tried and public carapace of sexual connoisseurship. If I am 'hearing' rightly, and one is obviously on very tentative ground, there is some sort of witty, marginally blasphemous dialectic being sparked off around the two poles of Adamic and New Testament incarnation. The mystery of the flesh and of its waxing and waning is vividly present: in Skeleton, in boan, boan , in nakednesse , in Incarnadin (which, of course, contains the radical for 'flesh') , in the open proposition on a Body (and of Flesh) within. But also, and with what may be a glance at the paradox of transubstantiation, in incorporate. 'Carnality' with its liturgical over- and under-tones, is insistent.
Lovelace was High Church and affirmed the 'real presence' in the Eucharist. The Puritans considered there to be only a spiritual presence. They rejected the idea that the Mass was a re-offering of Christ's sacrifice. Lovelace confess his sins, gain absolution, and then participate in Communion. For the Puritans, there must be public confession of sins and a 'brotherly watchfulness' rather than the facile forgiveness Priests purveyed.
If Adam and Eve are present in the structure so, one begins to suspect, is Christ, whose carnal self-revelation and self-sacrifice is so explicitly a counter to Adam's fall, and the spear-thrust in whose ribs is so manifestly a counter-figura to Adam's loss from which all evils sprang. It is these awesome changes that would appear to be rung on that haunting phrase: Who do incorporate with Aery leane. In short : what we have before us is a brilliantly-turned, burnished Cavalier lyric, whose ostensibk matter is one of sexual prescription: 'do not lose your swet and Keepers Fees on a bony whore ; pick a girl in the Rubens vein.' The generalizing title may well refer to a particular woman or erotic contretemps in Lovelace 's circle. Already, we may be sensing difficulties of a modal sort : is this piece of gamy advice , this roue's tip, the kind of occasion and locus for poetry with which we can engage at any but the cerebral level?
Are you banging fat ho-bags? If not, your engagement is merely cerebral.
Is this the class of experience and concern which poetry is readily about?
Yes. Whores gave some poets a free ride in return for a poem talking up their skills.
Is the substratum of sensibility, the nonchalant identification of woman's flesh with the deer's carcass, one that is still in reach of our feelings? But even as we pose these questions, their inadequacy shows itself to be crass. So much more is going on in the text.
For Anglicans, there is still some tension between High and Low Church. But what is going on in a text by Lovelace is much less than what can be found in Crashaw who went the whole hog and embraced Rome.
The rhetorical acrobatics are so evidently out of tune with an underlying current of concentrated, possibly clandestine association. Is it theological? One is not certain. And if it is, at what remove do we post ourselves and our reading from a style of language and a climate of consciousness in which venery and transubstantiation mesh?
Mary Magdalen, at that time, was considered a 'sinful woman' if not a fat ho-bag. Now she is the 'apostle to the apostles'.
Here, there are no answers to be 'looked up '.
Because his letters have not survived.
Which is, precisely, what distinguishes a contingent from a modal difficulty.
In other words, paucity of evidence allows us to entertain different possibilities. Why is this a difficulty? It is easy to imagine possible worlds in the absence of evidence. Looking stuff up may be tedious but it isn't difficult in itself.
Current man seeks to efface this distinction. Heir to Rousseau, our culture professes to know less but to feel more than any before it.
The opposite is the case. We know more and feel less. We are more likely to go to the psychiatrist and start taking medication if we keep seeing angels and demons.
We may have to look up even the most elementary of scriptural, mythological, historical, literary or scientific terms and references; but we claim confident empathy with Benin bronzes, the shadow-dramas of Indonesia, the ragas of India and every genre and epoch in Western art.
We are more affluent and thus some of us can devote themselves to the study of such subjects.
Ours is now Malraux's musee imaginaire in which collage and reproduction make possible the juxtaposed intimacy of the archaic and the romanesque,
this existed in Roman times.
the primitive and the surreal.
Unless the surreal was eaten by the primitive.
We are ashamed to concede any modal inhibition, to confess ourselves closed to any expressive act however remote from our own time and place.
Nonsense! We really don't want to know what it feels like to eat a Missionary.
But this ecumenism of receptivity is spurious. It deliberately confounds the reconstructive acquaintance achieved by virtue of knowledge and archaeology of feeling with authentic apprehension, with penetrative inscape.
One can say this about anything. I took a taxi to work. I did not enter into the being-for-itself of the taxi. Also, I didn't actually do any work at work. That is why they sacked me.
Learning, the suspension of reflex, can make us understand at the cerebral level the �ynamics of judgment which made of Rosa Bonheur a painter far more highly valued than Cezanne or which induced Balzac to set the novels of Mrs. Radcliffe above those of Stendhal (whom he was one of the first to praise).
We do the same thing all the time. The thing is not cerebral. It is psychological.
But we cannot coerce our own sensibility into the relevan t frame of perception. Large, sometime radiant, bodies of literature have receded from our present-day grasp.
I suppose the market has so expanded that there is more variety to be found in every genre. I used to watch TV shows about all sorts of things. Nowadays, if it hasn't got vampires and werewolves in it, I am not interested.
Who now reads, who experiences at any adequate depth of response, the tragedies of Voltaire,
not a vampire. Fuck him.
which once dominated the European canon of tragic drama from Madrid to St. Pe tersburg, or the high dramas of Alfieri that came after?
Who then read Harry Potter?
A substantial measure of European literature from the sixteenth to the later nineteenth centuries drew constantly and with intimate recognition on the epic poetry of Boiardo, Ariosto, and Tasso.
Who drew on what went before.
It was in this poetry that writers as diverse as Goethe, Keats, and Byron
all three were romantic. That's what sold well back then.
found a primary body of reference and instigation. European art and music are ubiquitous with the presence of Rinaldo and Angelica, of the distracted Orlando and Armida's garden.
Englightenment had ended in ennui. In any case, Europe suddenly became full of drama. Napoleon read Tasso & Ariosto & Ossian.
To mid-twentieth-century literacy this entire syllabus of sentiment and allusion is either a closed book or the terrain of academic research. Now it is only the scholar who knows that Ariosto is one of the two or three acutest witnesses of the nature of war in the whole of moral history, that he stands with Homer and Tolstoy among the few who have assessed the ambiguous profits of combat in the economy of human affairs.
What he saw was trivial. We have enough H-bombs to blow up the World.
But his idiom and orders of apprehension are no longer natural to us. The difficulty is modal and it is real.
Steiner wrote this at a time when college students could read whole books.
Contingent difficulties arise from the obvious plurality and individuation which characterize world and word.
the difficulty is contingent on a gap in the information set.
Modal difficulties lie with the beholder.
I suppose some people can't conceive some possibility because they are naive in that respect or don't have a particular disposition. This begs the question, can a man truly understand what a woman writes? In my case, the answer is yes. When my g.f says 'fuck off you sad fat loser', I understand she means I'm a cutie-pie.
A third class of difficulty has its source in the writer's will or in the failure of adequacy between his intention and his performative means.
It is difficult to understand him because he is retarded.
I propose to designate this class as tactical.
you can write something simple whose real meaning is tactical. I suppose you may deliberately make your writing difficult so as to render it esoteric- i.e. only the initiated will understand it.
The poet may choose to be obscure in order to achieve certain specific stylistic effects.
There is a 'mantic' quality to some poetry where obscure words or recondite concepts serve the same function as the magician's abracadabra.
He may find himself compelled towards obliquity and cloture by political circumstances: there is a very long history of Aesopian language, of 'encoding' and allegoric indirection in poetry written under pressure of totalitarian censorship (oppression, says Borges, is the mother of metaphor).
censorship, not oppression. Metaphors aren't going to keep the secret police from torturing the fuck out of you.
The constraints may be of a purely personal nature. The lover will conceal the identity of the beloved or the true condition of his passion.
He may also conceal the fact that he has a tiny dick.
The epigram, be it Martial's or �Ian delstam 's, v.ill be couched in terms translucent to the few, but initially closed to the public eye.
This is esotericism.
But there is also, and often decisively, an entire poetic of tactical difficulty. It is the poet 's aim to charge '"ith supreme intensity and genuineness of feeling a body of language, to 'make new' his text in the most durable sense of illuminati,-e, penetrative insight. But the language at his disposal is, by definition, general, common in use . Its similes are stock, its metaphors wom down to cliche. How can this soiled organon serve the most indi,idual and innovative of needs?
I the need to be taken for a smart dude rather than a boring shithead.
There have, throughout literart history, been logical terrorists who have taken the implicit paradox to its stark conclusion. The authentic poet cannot make do \\ith the infinitely shop-worn inventory of speech , with the necessarily devalued or counterfeit currency of the every-day . He must literally
shit higher than his arsehole
create new words and syntactic modes: this was the argument and practice of the first Dada, of Surrealists, of the Russian 'Futuro-Cubist' Khlebnikov and his 'star-speech '.
Franco and Stalin won that argument. Both yielded to Walt Disney & Coca Cola.
If the reader would follow the poet into the terra i1lcognita of revelation, he must learn the language.
Pretending to have read that shite works just as well unless you run into the cunt.
In effect, to be sure, this logic of the occult is autistic.
hypo-mentalist? It may be simply stupid.
A secret tongue will not communicate outward, and if it loses its mystery, if it is acquired by many it ''ill no longer contain the purities of the unprecedented.
Sadly, Life imitates Art. The fad of the few may become the bargain basement costume of the many.
The position of the radical but working poet is, therefore , a compromise. He will not forge a new. tongue but ,,ill attempt to revitalize, to cleanse 'the words of the tribe' (Mallarme's famous formula gives pointed summation to what is, in fact a constant compulsion in poet!)' and poetics).
The guy taught English. The line comes from his poem on the tomb of Edgar Allen Poe.
He will reanimate lexical and grammatical resources that have fallen out of use. He will melt and inflect words into neological shapes.
As do Advertising copy-writers.
He will labour to undermine, through distortion, through hyperbolic augment, through elision and displacement, the banal and constricting determinations of ordinary, public syntax.
Alternatively, he may write something entertaining or informative.
The effects which he aims at can vary widely: they extend from the subtlest of momentary shocks, that unsettling of expectation which comes with a conceit in Metaphysical verse, to the bewildering obscurity of Mallarme and the modernists.
If you don't have genius, you can go in for grandiosity.
The underlying manoeuvre is one of rallentando .
i.e. slowing down
We are not meant to understand easily and quickly.
Though dismissal may be both.
Immediate purchase is denied us. The text yields its force and singularity of being only gradually.
In other words, we put in something of our own. But is it apposite? Sadly, it is likely to be trite. My reading of Mallarme consists in preferring jam to marmalade.
In certain fascinating cases, our understanding, however strenuously won, is to remain provisional.
Ars longa, Vita brevis. This means life is too short for much in the way of Art.
There is to be an undecidability at the heart, at what Coleridge called the inner penetralium of the poem
if get to the heart, chances are we decided the thing wasn't a turd.
(there is a concrete sense in which the great allegories of ingress, of pilgrimage to the centre, such as the Roman de Ia rose and the Commedia , compel the reader to re-enact, in the stages of his reading, the adventure of gradual unfolding told by the poet).
Only in the sense that a railway timetable compels commuting.
There is a dialectical strangeness in the will of the poet to be understood only step by step and up to a point.
He genuinely believes he isn't a shithead. Sadly, he is likely to be wrong.
The retention of innermost meaning is, inevitably, subverted, and ironized by the mere fact that the poet has chosen to make his text public .
This is like saying our intention not to go around in the nude is subverted or ironized by the fact that we try to wear clothes which enhance our sex appeal. Poetry isn't thought going naked into the world. It is a game of dress up.
Yet the impulse is an honest and crucial one, arising from the intermediate status of all language between the individual and the general.
Language differentiates between the two. Some statements are about an individual. Others apply to a large class of beings.
The contradiction is insoluble .
There is no contradiction. Either the individual exists or he doesn't. I say 'Omlette is Sheikh Pir's finest play'. You contradict me. Hamlet is Shakespeare's finest play.
It finds creative expression in tactical difficulties. When Michelangelo addresses Cavalieri, he pounds the rubble of Petrarchan phrases and conceits into fantastic shapes: Si amico al freddo sasso e 'I foco interno che, di que! tratto, se lo circumscrive, che l'arda e spezzi, in qualche modo vive, legando con se gli altri in loco ettemo. E se 'n fomace dura, istate e vemo vince , e 'n piu pregio che prima s'ascrive, come purgata infra I 'altre alte e dive alma nel ciel tomasse da I 'inferno.
Limestone is burned in a kiln to make quicklime for mortar. For Michaelangelo, this is a metaphor for how the fire of love and spiritual suffering purifies and gives eternal life to his soul
. This isn't difficult to understand.
The initial crux is that of ardent flame somehow vital inside cold stone , then blazing out of the stone and circling it with fire (se lo circumscrive); thus making of the rock or marble what is literally a living ash or mortar (in qualche modo vive) by virtue of which other stones can be knit (legando con se gli altri) into a form that will endure everlasting (in loco etterno ) . If it can resist the furnace 's heat, stone will the more readily vanquish summer and winter (istate e verna vince). Doing so, it will acquire a worth beyond its own first nature (piu pregio che prima) , as does the soul that has returned purified, burnt clean (purgata) from a sojourn in hell and heaven (alte e dive) . The trope unfolds in the closing triplet in which the poet, now made smoke and ash (jatto fummo e polve ), sees himself as ever-enduring (etterno ben saro ) , precisely because of his reduced impalpable state, but then, in a closing line which remains unclear, images himself as hammered not by iron but by gold (da tale oro e non ferro son percosso ).
The Virgin Mary is the Domus Aurea (House of Gold) though this usage did not become popular till after the death of Vittoria Collona. However, some of her poetry depicts Mary's pure, sinless body as becoming the the sacred "dwelling place" for Christ- the infinite treasure of heaven.
The counterpoint of matter and spirit, of flame and ash, together with the implicit 'plot' which recounts the lover's fiery reduction by the desired brilliance of the beloved, are the stale props of the Petrarchan idiom.
There is nothing stale in Michaelangelo's poem. He rejected Petrarchan smoothness for 'terribilita'- a hideous strength- such that he spoke 'things' not 'words'.
Michelangelo injects into them the tactile vehemence of his own incomparable intimacy with stone and hammer, and the kindred presence of Dante whose Commedia is a persistent referential touchstone in Michelangelo 's Rime. The tactical difficulties spring from, are intended to make manifest, the fact that l\Iichelangelo 's feelings for Cavalieri
This poem is dedicated to Colonna.
are of such intensity and genuineness that they can make use of the most banal counters of expression.
Rugged, yes. Banal no.
Like others in the garland, this sonnet enacts its own central motif: it consumes and scatters to rubble (l'arda e spezzi) the material of which it is constituted - the Petrarchan diction -
Colonna wrote in that. Berni & Michaelangelo did the opposite. Dante is their common literary ancestor.
in order to give to that material the mystery of fresh and lasting life. Already, Gongora
influenced by Berni (poesia bernesca)
seems to prefigure Mallarme, by his subversion of the common linearity of syntax, by his nominalization of adjectival and adverbial forms.
Gongora is excessively Latinate and goes in for extreme hyperbaton and periphrasis. Zdislas Milner, Hellmuth Petriconi, and Federico García Lorca called Mallarme the French Gongora. Mallarme didn't know Spanish. He said his influences were Poe, Baudelaire & Wagner.
In the sonnet which he addresses to the Flemish painter of his portrait (the painter is unknown, the picture has disappeared), Gongora is poised midway, as it were , between the neo-Platonic and Petrarchan topos of identity and image, a topos routine to Michelangelo, and Mallarme 's paradoxalities on the 'presentness' to the spirit, to the 'sensoriness of the spirit', of that which is absent: Hurtas mi bulto, y cuanto mas le debe a tu pincel, dos veces peregrino, de espiritu vivaz el breve lino en las colores que sediento bebe, vanas cenizas temo al lino breve, que emulo del barro le imagino, a quien (ya etereo fuese , ya divino) vida le fio muda esplendor !eve.
Gongora was from Cordoba and had written 'Moorish ballads'. He was aware of the Islamic prohibition on paintings or statues. He writes in the spirit of Baroque desengaño (disillusionment).
In the Michelangelo text, everything is harshly palpable, even the flame has edge .
everything, quite literally, is concrete.
Here all is diaphanous and mobile.
abstract and removed from the world of five falibile senses.
Again, the secret scandal is that of art which can confer on the most ephemeral of substances (el brevo fino) by means of esplendor leve, a nearly unrecapturable phrase in which the sumptuousness and the extreme lightness of the painter's touch is rendered, the espiritu vivaz of being.
That 'weightless splendor' was Prometheus's gift to his sculpture- Man.
This intangible being takes on the needs of carnal life: the canvas drinks the colours (las co/ores que sediento hebe) as men drink water or - surely the allusion is active if deep-b uried - as the shades of the departed drink ritual libations of life-blood in order to become present to us. But though intense, the 'substantive image ' on the canvas stays mute : vida le fio muda . Which condition makes of a painter's portraiture of a poet a peculiarly peremptory seizure (h urto). Dos veces peregrina is tantalizing: why is the painter's brush 'twice peregrine '?
because the painter was both foreign and extraordinarily good.
What is its twofold pilgrimage? Is Gongora invoking the Platonic paradigm of the twofold remove of art from the archetypal Forms, its double descent, via mimesis, into counterfeit?
No. The artist participates (methexis) in the forms. The Flemish were really good painters.
We are meant to hesitate, to have only gradual, earned access to the crowning paradox of the sonnet, that that which sees, which hears, lasts less (quien mas ve, quien mas oye, menor dura), a paradox in which the living poet salutes the scandalous survival of his own mute image and conjoins the Platonic with the Scriptural meditation on the ephemeral nature of sensory existence.
Sadly, the picture was lost. Perhaps this was because Gongora's style fell out of favour.
But observe the paradox within the paradox: the salute to the enduringness of the impalpable is spoken to a painting, itself a wholly perishable, material genre.
I think the Flemish artist painted it as a model to be copied onto the opening page of a manuscript collection of Góngora’s poems. I believe copies from the engraved copy are still available. However, it is Velasquez's portrait of Gongora which is famous.
The painting itself will only last if it can steal the 'bodily spirit' of the sitter. And thus the spiral of equivocation begins again.
Hurtas mi vulto" means 'You steal my likeness/face'. As for 'y cuanto más le debe / a tu pincel... de espíritu vivaz el breve lino / en las colores que sediento bebe" it means ...'this small piece linen owes more and more to your brush... for the lively spirit in the colors it thirstily drinks". Gongora, a priest, wrote this in 1620. The previous year, Bohemian Protestants had deposed the Catholic Habsburg ruler and crowned the Calvinist Frederick V of the Palatinate. His court chaplain Abraham Scultetus spearheaded a controversial cleansing of St. Vitus Cathedral in Prague in December 1619. Altars, paintings, and sculptures were stripped out Ever since the Council of Trent (1545–1563)—the Catholic Church fiercely defended religious painting against Protestant iconoclasm. Thus Góngora treats painting not as deceptive idolatry, but as a quasi-sacred act of creation. Just as Catholic theology taught that sacred art could elevate the mind toward eternal truths, Góngora suggests that fine portraiture rescues human dignity from time and decay.
It may be no accident that tactical difficulties crop up where poets consider their metier. 'Contingently' and 'modally' .
I suppose a poet may hesitate between two different meanings. It's nice to have your cake and eat it too.
Wallace Stevens's 'Anecdote of the Jar' is transparent: I placed a jar in Tennessee, And round it was upon a hill. It made the slovenly wilderness Surround that hill. The wilderness rose up to it. And sprawled around, no longer wild. The jar was round upon the ground And tall and of a port in air. It took dominion everywhere. The jar was gray and bare. It did not give of bird or bush, Like nothing else in Tennessee.
Was it a jar of moonshine? Many find it difficult not to polish off such jars.
The aesthetic proposition is unambiguous: however simple ('gray and bare '), the work of art reorganizes, sets ordinance upon the surrounding chaos of the organic. The ministration is as antique and imperative as was Orpheus' song: like the forest and beasts crouching to hear the singer, the wilderness gathers around the jar 'no longer wild'. The mildly ceremonious, archaic 'port in air' confirms the classic note. In turn, the motif of a central circle and of a verticality within it, plays on subliminal, possibly archetypal recognitions of order, on intimations patent in art and dreams of how the inchoate world is given sense.
The jar is the product of human artifice. Tennessee becomes a place where moonshine can be made and transported in pick-up trucks. Will the Sherrif give chase? You betcha!
It is the last two lines that obstruct and unsettle. The immediate obtrusion is that of syntax : 'give of' and 'like nothing else ' are either a regional idiom or ungramatical.
I don't see the difficulty. The jar is part of the human world. Perhaps Tennessee, back then, was probably lightly populated by hillbillies wearing coon-skin caps.
There is deflection within deflection as 'to give of' seems to call naturally for 'like anything else '. Yet the 'nothing' is so obviously purposed. So far as I am aware, no reading of the text has come up with a coherent parsing or equivalent transposition into normal syntax .
Some think Stevens saw a mass-produced glass fruit jar, during his 1918 business trip to Elizabethton, Tennessee, called the Dominion Wide Mouth Special. That brand name directly echoes the poem's line, "It took dominion'. I suppose it could be used for suppin' whiskey.
To transpose, to paraphrase into correctness, is to relinquish both the motion and the meaning of the poem's meaning. At one level, and not trivially, we do know, we do 'make out' what Wallace Stevens is saying. The artifact transmutes the organic into the organized, but is not of it. It works via detached centrality. It is itself sterile - 'it does not give' as does the vegetable or the animal presence of 'bird or bush '. It has no affinity with them -if one reads 'to give of' as analogous to such normal forms as 'to smell of', 'to sound like '. In this solipsistic integrity, the jar is unlike anything else in Tennessee. All else in 'the slovenly wilderness' is meshed and partakes of a shared providence ('to provide ' signifying to 'give of itself') .
Grecian urns were found in Greece which we are supposed to admire if we have any claim to culture. Tennessee was a rough place filled with drunken yokels. Still, American industry was not to be scoffed at. Lots of soldiers returning from Europe could tell you that the place was a shithole.
The jar dominates uniquely but is, by definition, empty ('bare' enforces this implication of lofty vacancy).
No. The jar may be filled and emptied umpteen times. It is very useful. I suppose Tennessee had some beautiful landscapes. But were they utile? I suppose, they could always be rendered less slovenly if taken over by the National Parks service. The Great Smoky Mountains National Park was set up in 1934.
'Anything else' would vulgarize the crux of singularity . The 'nothing', with its arrest of rhythm, enacts the requisite twofold motion of extreme differentiation - 'nothing is like the jar' - and of inherent 'nothingness'.
Utility is not in the thing. It is nothing in itself save 'supreme fiction'. Influenced by Santayana at Harvard, Stevens thought religion was just poetry which mistook itself for fact. He argued for creating a "Supreme Fiction"—an imaginative belief or ordering principle that we consciously invent and inhabit because it helps us live in and make sense of a chaotic, secular world. Nothingness is the basis for this imaginal Transcendence.
But Wallace Stevens 's allegory is a radical critique of the proposition abundant in King Lear that 'nothing shall come of nothing'.
Nothing came of the lying devotion two of his daughters professed for him.
The charged 'nullity ' of art centres and cultivates reality.
It is useful enough. That's all we can say about it.
We can arrive at this reading by a sort of semantic approximation.
Or just by making up any shite we like.
We cannot demonstrate or paraphrase it grammatically. As we move with and agains the anti-grammar of the two lines , the effect on us is that of moire , of the meaningful but unstable and reticulating patterns in shot silk.
Moire isn't unstable at all. A bridal gown made of moire won't suddenly disappear as daddy walks you down the aisle leaving you as naked as a jay bird.
There is a di stinct sense in which we know and do not know, at the same time.
The sense is that utility may depend on 'supreme fiction'.
This rich undecidability is exactly what the poet aims at. It can be made a hollow trick (as it often is with the syntactic instabilities in Dylan Thomas). Or it can serve as a true tactical difficulty, forcing us to reach out towards more delicate orderings of perception. It is, simultaneously, a subversion and energizing of rhetoric drawing attention, as poets such as Mlichelangelo, Gongora, and Wallace Stevens do persistently, to the inertias in the common routine of discourse.
Why draw attention to the bleeding obvious? Also, these three aren't seen as difficult. Stevens is seen as approachable. Gongora & Michaelangelo have their own place in Catholic art and culture but don't greatly matter to English speakers.
Contingent difficulties aim to be looked up;
or can only be cleared up after more research has been done.
modal difficulties challenge the inevitable parochialism of honest empathy ;
e.g. the empathy I showed my Professors for being raped by street dogs. This did not endear me to them at all- the Professors, I mean- not the dogs who raped them.
tactical difficulties endeavour to deepen our appre· hension by dislocating and goading to new life the supine exercie of word and grammar. Each of these three classes of difficulty is a part of the contract of ultimate or preponderant intelligibility between poet and reader, between text and meaning.
One can say of even the most pellucid text, that it is too obscure.
There is a fourth order of difficulty which occurs where this contract is itself wholly or in part broken.
e.g. you pick up a book titled 'how to make your dick larger' and find it is a textbook on Quantum Mechanics.
Because this type of difficulty implicates the functions of language and of the poem as a communicative performance, because it puts in question the existential suppositions that lie behind poetry as we have known it, I propose to call it ontological.
e.g. ordering 'how to make your dick larger' from Amazon and receiving a turd in the post.
Difficulties of this category cannot be looked up ; they cannot be resolved by genuine readjustment or artifice of sensibility ; they are not an intentional technique of retardation and creative uncertainty (though these may be their immediate effect). Ontological difficulties confront us with blank questions about the nature of human speech, about the status of significance, about the necessity and purpose of the construct which we have, with more or less rough and ready consensus, come to perceive as a poem.
Is a turd a poem? No. Ontologically, they belong to separate classes of being.
Ontological difficulties, certainly in the modem vein, seem to have their history : they are the object of theoretical argument and stylistic manipulation in the hermetic movement that relates certain elements in Rimbaud, the poetics of Mallarme, the esoteric programme of Stefan George, Russian formalism and futurism, and the dependent impulses which have come after.
These are the same sort of difficulties as arise when you chant a magical formula to make your dick bigger and it doesn't at all. Still, you may pretend to your friends that the magic worked. They should stop referring to you as 'Needle-dick Iyer'.
To ask why ontologz'cal difficulties should come to be seen as a desideratum or inescapable fatality in European literatures of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, is to ask
why all sorts of nutters started gassing on about the occult back then. Some backed away from that shite into Catholicism & Anti-Semitism.
an absolutely fundamental question about the crises of idiom and values in the entirety of modern Western culture .
which is about films and TV series and music videos. Poetry can't compete.
A summary reply would be fatuous. The aetiologies of this inspired movement towards darkness are as various as the individual talents and social circumstances involved.
The Liberal Arts were becoming adversely selective of imbecility. Poets went in for mystagogy because they were too stupid to understand mathematical physics.
Certain broad contours do stand out. The transformation of the visionary elements in the Enlightenment and French Revolution into the philistine positivism of the industrial and mercantile structure of the nineteenth century, brought on a drastic mutual disenchantment of artist and society.
The era of the mass-market had arrived. Talent could make its own way. Stupidity had to retreat into Higher Education. Pretending worthless shite was 'difficult' meant you could speak of your own 'research' as being on a level with that of the STEM subject maven.
Severed from concrete revolutionary possibilities, later romanticism cultivated the posture of inward exile,
i.e. not getting invited to nice parties. Also, your significant other was a cat.
of the poet's isolation in a prosaic society. This stance entailed an essentially private ideal of communication. At the same time , the rapid proliferation of journalistic and popular media of communication - the press, the feuilleton , the cheap book - while beneficial to prose fiction, accentuated the minority status of the poem.
unless you wrote lyrics for musicals in which case you became as rich as fuck.
With this industrialization of language and of the means of dissemination of language came the semi-literacies characteristic of a technocratic and mass-consumer society.
Such a society is characterised by universal literacy and pretty much anybody being able to read pretty much anything they want to read.
To certain poets - and it is at this node that Poe occupies a position much in excess of his intrinsic merits
ordinary people like Poe. Horror is a big genre and there and Hollywood keeps adapting some of his classic stories every few years.
- the ancient trope of inadequate discourse , the conceit whereby words fall short of the unique immediacies of individual experience, became a more general issue.
Poe was a bright guy. His words weren't inadequate at all
Now it was language as a whole that was being cheapened, brutalized, emptied of numinous and exact force, by mass usage.
Coz Joe Lunch-pail is always banging on about the numinosity of his bottle of Coors- right?
This view is implicit in Baudelaire, in Gautier's quest for the rare, unsullied word, in Verlaine's ideal of musicalization. It becomes programmatic in Mallarme 's resolve to cleanse the vocabulary and syntax of common speech, to carve out and preserve for poetry an arcane realm of uncompromising significance.
Cheese-eating surrender monkeys may want to pretend there is something they are uncompromising about.
But behind these motives, complex and multiple as they are , two even deeper instincts or conjectures seem at work. The first is that of an almost subconscious insurgence against the mountainous authority of the classical past, against the hectoring traditionalism which informed high literacy since the Renaissance.
What informed 'high literacy' was a widening market for printed books. Once it became economical enough to publish Greek texts without a Latin gloss, Classical studies really took off. This in turn led to innovations and improvements in the vernacular idiom. One source of 'Modernism' was to retranslate the Classics in a manner more immediate or, at any rate, less fucking gay.
In the hermeticism of poetry after Mallarme there is
shite only of interest to people who have to pass exams in French literature or, worse yet, those who have to teach those imbeciles.
an attempt, not untinged with irony, to shake off the constraints of influence and of public-academic expectation based on the canonic (much in Mallarme is a revolt, only partly successful, against Victor Hugo, and against the fanfares of eloquence in which Victor Hugo proclaimed his own kinship with the eternal accomplishments of the prophets, of Dante, of Shakespeare). To become esoteric was to
Jacques Ranciere suggests that Mallarme was subverting rather than retreating from the envenomed politics of the Third Republic.
break the chain of exemplary inheritance.
In À rebours, Huysmans’s reclusive anti-hero, Duke Jean des Esseintes, enshrines Mallarmé as the supreme poet of the modern age—praising his dense, esoteric style as a "melancholy incantation" that offered the only escape from a vulgar, bourgeois society. This was in 1884. Mallarme became famous overnight. Huysmans moved from an interest in occultism to devout Catholicism. By contrast, Mallarme lost his faith and sought to replace it with Le Livre ("The Book")—an idealized, supreme literary work meant to serve as a secular, artistic replacement for the Mass.
In other words, this was magic by another name.
The second impulse is, on the contrary, one of reversion, of an attempted return to an archaic past in which languge and thought had, somehow, been open to the truth of being, to the hidden sources of all meaning.
Also animals could talk and bears invited you to nice picnics.
This motion is explicit in Mallarme's dictum of 1894 that all poetry has 'gone wrong' since the magisterial, but ultimately erroneous, achievement of Homer.
Very true. Poetry had taken to smoking crack to pay for which it gave beejays at truck stops. Not all the blame should fall on Homer. Hesiod too played a part.
By becoming linear, narrative, realistic , publicly-focused, the art of Homer and his successors - this is to say of the near totality of Western literature - had lost or betrayed the primal mystery of magic.
Which doesn't work. That is why we have to work for a living.
Mallarme 's examplar of this magic is Orpheus who, like the jar in Tennessee, casts the net of order over the organic world, and who descends to the heart of death via the spiralling staircase of his song.
Coz elevators didn't exist back then. Sad.
These are the crucial trials of poetry,
conquering death and not having to work for a living. Fuck you Homer for steering poetry wrong! Fuck you very much indeed!
and they lie outside Homer's 'realistic' and informational purpose. In the late 1920s, Heidegger gave historical-philosophic vogue to a precisely parallel reading of the Western condition. In the riddling fragments of Parmenides, of Heraclitus, of Anaximander, thought and saying are a perfect unity.
Whereas when they were discussing the high price of fish, their thoughts and sayings were fighting with each other.
The logos stands 'in the clearing of being', gathering to itself the 'hidden presentness of Being in beings', the quiddity of autonomous existence and meaning towards which Gerard Manley Hopkins had bent his vision.
Heidi was a spoiled Catholic whose vocation was rejected. Hopkins, a convert, was more fortunate.
What Homer is to poetry in Mallarme 's model, Plato and Aristotle are to the Heideggerian diagnosis of the 'amnesia of true Being' in Western rationalism.
If you have to teach stupid shite, you may as well pretend that Reason has amnesia or syphilis or a bad case of the squirts.
If it is the task of the true poet to force his way upstream to the Orphic sources of his art -
no! The true poet must sodomize the burning bush of the cthonic sources of his farts! I explained all this to TS Eliot who, between you and me, is a drunken bum who still owes me a fiver.
and where there is compulsion there will be difficulty - it is the task of the thinker, of man in his essence , to return to the illuminations of authentic existence reflected in the pre-Socratics.
Study worthless shite and you end up having to teach it. Still, Heidi did fuck Hannah's aunt. That must count for something.
In Heidegger's view, it is the poet-thinker Holderlin who has, until now, come nearest to communicating to us the nature of this homeward turn.
By going mad. My only criticism of him is that he didn't also eat his own shit. Had he done so, Heidi would have literally died and gone to heaven.
Radical modernism in European poetry is, I believe , largely derived from Mallarme's practice and from Heidegger's theoretic metaphor, and from the image of Holderlin in Heidegger.
In Germany, Rilke & Stefan George were influenced by Mallarme. But expressionists- e.g. Else Lasker-Schüler or her husband's Der Sturm- were not. Heidegger's essay on Holderlin was published in 1936. For obvious reasons it didn't have much influence. Maybe Celan- who was mentally ill- was taken with it. The truth is poet's want fame and wealth. They don't want to go mad or drown themselves in the Seine.
In ontological difficulty, the poetics of Mallanne and Heidegger, of the Orphic and the pre-Socratic, express their sense of the inauthentic situation of man in an environment of eroded speech.
Two world wars taught Europe that 'eroded speech' really wasn't worth getting worked up over.
These attitudes coalesce in the mature poetry of Paul Celan - to which fact must be added the specific discomforts of a survivor of the holocaust writing poetry comparable in stature to Holderlin's and Rilke 's, and poetry of the utmost personal compulsion, in the butchers ' tongue.
Poor chap, he was obliged to translate poetry for not very much money. It's the sort of thing which makes you wish you had studied to be a dental technician.
'Largo ', from the volume Schneepart, is by no means uncharacteristic: Gleichsinnige du, heidegingerische � ilie; ubersterbensgross liegen wir beieinander, die Zeitlose wimrnelt dir unter den atrnenden Lidem, da.s Amselpaar hingt neben uns, unter unsem gerneinsam droben rnitziehenden weissen
The man was mad & had to teach a shitty language (German) for a living. He thought Heidi mattered. But the fellow was a charlatan. Poetry is a type of therapy for victims of horrendous epistemic self-abuse. Whatever depth Celan had, the Seine had more.
There are , to be sure, difficulties here of the kind we have looked at before (and it is at these that any attempt at trans· lation, such as Mlichael Hamburger's, will take a stab). Heidegangensch seems to play, as Celan 's later verse frequently will, on the name of the philosopher and on the Heideggerian concept of the Feldweg, the peregrination through, the traverse of, open country;
You have to hand it to Celan. He makes German sound even uglier than Heidi could. I skip over the rest of the passage. Celan's poem has one or two striking images but what we need to explain to our students is that killing Jews is wrong. Take a cold shower or fix yourself a sandwich. Enough with the fucking Final Solution already.
....At certain levels , we are not meant to understand at all,
we are meant to think Celan & Heidi weren't stupid.
and our interpretation , indeed our reading itself, is an intrusion (Celan himself often expressed a sense of violation in respect of the exegetic industry which began to gather around his poems).
Because there were low IQ members of the younger generation who had to earn money by teaching worthless shite.
But again we ask: for whom, then, is the poet writing, let alone publishing?
Poseurs.
This paradox is inseparable from ontological difficulty, and was already the object of incensed argument around Mallarme. For whom was the Master composing his cryptograms?
Paris was in the business it was the Capital City of Culture. It had an interest in pretending its streets were filled with bona fide geniuses rather than stupid cunts with delusions of grandeur.
If one leaves to one side the strategies of historical circums tance - Mallarme's campaign for a purification, for an 'aristocratization' of poetic idiom,
fuck the aristocracy. I want the 'billionaireization' of poetic idiom.
Paul Celan 's anguish at writing poetry, at having to write poetry 'after Auschwitz ' and in the language of the devisers of Auschwitz
he had to teach that language. That's why it is important to learn a trade early in life. Just think how happy he'd have been as a dental technician?
- ontological difficulty seems to point to a hypostasis of language such as we find, precisely, in the philosophy of Heidegger.
This is like finding a hippopotamus in your stool. You are deluding yourself. Yes. you are an asshole. No, your asshole really isn't that big.
It is not so much the poet who speaks, but language itself: die Sprache spn'cht.
Also you don't shit. Shit shits you.
The authentic, immensely rare , poem is one in which 'the Being of language '
as opposed to its soiled nappy
finds unimpeded lodging, in which the poet is not a persona , a subjectivity 'ruling over language ', but an 'openness to', a supreme listener to, the genius of speech.
i.e. has supernatural powers. But why stop there? You can go in for onomatodoxy such that the Name is higher than what it signifies.
The result of such openness is not so much a text, but an 'act', an eventuation of Being and literal 'coming into Being'.
as opposed to coming on Being's tits.
At a naive level, this image yields the suspect expressionistic tag that 'a poem should not mean but be'.
So we can wipe our arse on it.
At the more sophisticated but equally existential level, it generates the poetics of 'dissemination', of 'de-constructive ' and 'momentary ' reading that we find in Derrida and the current school of semiotics.
If you teach idiots you go in for semi-idiotics.
We do not 'read' the poem in the traditional framework of the author's auctoritas and of an agreed sense, however gradually and gropingly arrived at.
Yes we do- unless we have to teach cretins. The good thing about Derrida is that you can say the same thing about Mallarme and Marmalade. True, it doesn't mean anything but that's because, for trillions of years, your people have been sodomized and slut shamed by the elite.
We bear witness to its precarious possibility of existence in an 'open' space of collisions, of momentary fusions betwen word and referent.
Only if we didn't learn anything useful in skool.
The operative metaphor may be that crucial to Mallarme 's famous L 'absen te de taus bouquets,
"I say: a flower! and [...] musically arises, the very idea, so sweet, it is the one absent from all bouquets". Many years ago, I wrote a story called 'The Poet's suicide note' which concluded that the poem must also be the poet's suicide weapon. Sadly, I've never been able to read my own poetry which is why I am still alive.
My point is any low IQ shithead can write nonsense.
to the modem physicist's determination of 'the unperceived event' in the cloud-chamber,
which actually means something and could be very fucking useful
and to Heidegger's equivocation on the 'absence in presence ' (the play on Ab- and Anwesen). In each case the observable phenomenon - the text - is the inevitable betrayal, in both senses of the term, of an invisible logic.
Only in the sense that it is also that umberella which they left in their Aunt's house even though they don't have an aunt.
Yet we do know that the Mallarme envoi or the Celan lyric is poetry, and often major poetry.
Precisely because they aren't really difficult at all.
We do know that we are not looking at nonsense or at planned obfuscation, as in the case of certain Dada and surrealist collages. 'Largo ' is a profoj.lndly moving statement, though we cannot say confidently or paraphrastically 'of what'.
Mental illness. That's real enough. We have friends thus afflicted. Sometimes they kill themselves. That's a type of pain that doesn't go away.
How do we have this assurance, what allows us to discriminate, even within the class of ontological difficulties, between the necessary and the factitious,
it turns out there are no necessary truths. Everything is multiply realisable.
and even between 'the real' and the 'more real '
or the Scotsman and the true Scotsman
(a differentiation which might bear on the distinctions to be made between, say, Rilke 's difficulties in the Duino Elegies and Celan's)?
Both were stupid. But, in many many respects, so are we. That is why we find it easy to relate to both.
This seems to me one of the most urgent questions in the whole of aes thetics and of the modern attempts at a philosophy of meaning.
There is nothing urgent in the philosophy of meaning. There is no hurry when it comes to doing stupid shit.
The subject of difficulty in poetry , in art , is
related to 'naturality' in mathematics. If there is an objective function and a set of constraints, there may be 'unicity' or 'canonicity'- i.e. only one way of getting the right answer.
as large as are the performative means of language and of visual and aural expression.
Which are non-denumerably infinite. Put another way, there is no 'naturality' save with reference to an arbitrary objective function.
It has moved to the very centre of aesthetic experience since the late nineteenth century.
No. What has moved to the centre is cinema and Netflix series about vampires and werewolves.
Neither aesthetic theory nor general public feeling have coped with it satisfactorily.
satisfactorily to whom? Some stupid Professor teaching worthless shite?
It is, as yet, impossible to say whether the hermeticism of so much in the modernistic movements is a transient phenomenon or represents some ultimate break in the classic contract between word and world.
Nothing wrong with a hermeticism which sells like hot cakes. If there is a 'contract' between word and world, it is 'incomplete'- i.e. can't prevision all possible future states. The truth is language merely solves coordination and discoordination games. Some poems become 'Schelling focal'.
The classification into contingent, modal, tactical and ontological difficulties put forward here is, obviously, rough, and preliminary.
It is a mere pretence at pedantry. Steiner was a charlatan but he actually liked books and wanted his students to do a bit of reading for pleasure.
But it would be unusual if any of the difficulties actually met wi th in poetry , and in literary texts as a whole, were irreducible to one of these four types or to the manifold combinations between them.
Anything can be reduced to anything by a shithead.