Showing posts with label Adam Tooze. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Adam Tooze. Show all posts

Sunday, 18 January 2026

Tooze as Narcissistic cooze

Robert P Baird writes beautifully. His article on Adam Tooze 'the crisis whisperer', published by the Guardian, is a joy to read. 


In late January 2025, 10 days after Donald Trump was sworn in for a second time

i.e. 30 Jan 2025.  

as president of the United States, an economic conference in Brussels brought together several officials from the recently deposed Biden administration for a discussion about the global economy.

What Conference was this? There was a 'European way of growth' conference back then. But it was in Cracow. 

In Washington, Trump and his wrecking crew were already busy razing every last brick of Joe Biden’s legacy, but in Brussels, the Democratic exiles put on a brave face. They summoned the comforting ghosts of white papers past, intoning old spells like “worker-centered trade policy” and “middle-out bottom-up economics”.

this isn't a reference to sodomy. The notion is that stimulating middle class consumer demand is key to successful macro policies.  

They touted their late-term achievements. They even quoted poetry: “We did not go gently into that good night,” Katherine Tai, who served as Biden’s US trade representative, said from the stage.

We will die, but we will scream and shit ourselves as we do so.  

Tai proudly told the audience that before leaving office she and her team had worked hard to complete “a set of supply-chain-resiliency papers, a set of model negotiating texts, and a shipbuilding investigation”.

China does the shipbuilding. Let us investigate why we don't any longer.  

It was not until 70 minutes into the conversation that a discordant note was sounded, when Adam Tooze joined the panel remotely. Born in London, raised in West Germany, and living now in New York, where he teaches at Columbia, Tooze was for many years a successful but largely unknown academic. A decade ago he was recognised, when he was recognised at all, as an economic historian of Europe.

He thought Varoufakis wasn't stupid and evil. He was wrong.  

Since 2018, however, when he published Crashed, his “contemporary history” of the 2008 financial crisis and its aftermath,

from which Europe didn't recover which is why its share of world GDP is in the crapper.  

Tooze has become, in the words of Jonathan Derbyshire, his editor at the Financial Times, “a sort of platonic ideal of the universal intellectual”.

He is a fucking historian. That's low IQ.  

Though he still teaches history, Tooze is also widely acknowledged as an expert on the infrastructure of global finance and the economics of the green-energy transition.

This is like saying a guy who writes about Caesar is a kick ass Roman centurion.  

He is the rare commentator who can speak credibly about the political economy of Europe,

he can talk to other shitheads. Does he move markets? No.  

the US and China, and he has been an outspoken advocate on issues ranging from central-bank reform to Palestinian rights.

The more advocacy Palestine receives, the worse off its people. 'Central bank reform' just means the Government should print money and bail out places which have been bankrupted by their politicians.  

In addition to being the author of five books, he writes regular columns and essays for outlets like the Financial Times and the London Review of Books, hosts podcasts in English and German, and publishes a wildly popular and influential Substack newsletter called Chartbook, which he sends out daily in English to more than 160,000 subscribers, including Paul Krugman, the Nobel prize-winning economist, and Larry Summers, the former US treasury secretary.

In other words, he is stupid and vacuous but not as mad as Summers or as consistently wrong as Krugman.  

Chartbook also goes out in a Chinese-language version that, Tooze estimates, received 30m total impressions last year.

10 trillion Chinese flies eat shit. This proves that eating shit is good for you.  

Yet for all that, and despite being motivated occasionally by what he calls “an energy of wanting to put the world to rights”, Tooze is not generally regarded as an eager controversialist. (Last year, Krugman sounded delighted to see “the normally calm Tooze come across as a bit angry” in one of his Chartbook posts.)

Apparently, Krugman got 'mad as hell' back towards the end of 2024 when the NYT asked him to write much less for them.  

In person as in his work, Tooze prizes connection and synthesis, a tendency that helps explain why he is equally at home, and equally welcome, talking to activists in South Africa,

kill Whitey. Not me, South African Whitey.  

or senators in Washington,

useless ones- sure 

or development economists in the West Bank,

till violent 'setttlers' redevelop their asses  

or financial executives in London,

who are planning to move to Dubai unless they are so useless Dubai doesn't want them.  

or Chinese Communist party officials in Beijing,

they can always find some use for a useless idiot 

or finance ministers in Berlin.

which is the definition of stupidity.  


It was notable, then, that after joining the Brussels panel, Tooze didn’t waste much time before stating flatly that the Biden team had “failed in its absolutely central mission, which was to prevent a second Trump administration”.

Kamala was supposed to be a prosecutor. Why couldn't the Dems lock up Trump? Also why didn't they reform the Supreme Court?  

Not only that, he argued, but the dismantling of the liberal world order – something discussed with much rueful lamentation at the conference – had been hastened, not hindered, by the Biden veterans on stage. As he’d written a few months earlier, Tooze saw Biden no less than Trump aiming “to ensure by any means necessary” – including strong-arming allies – “that China is held back and the US preserves its decisive edge”.

To be fair, the Chinese overcame all obstacles on their own. With hindsight, Biden should have soft-soaped the Chinese. But, at that time, it was not known that they could overcome their own vulnerabilities and create very effective threat points against US & Europe.  

“I feel the need to say something,” Tai said, when Tooze was finished.

Which is like the corpse at the wake feeling the need to say 'I'm not dead. Please don't bury me'.  

She recalled a parable Martin Sheen had delivered in front of the White House during the 25th anniversary celebration of The West Wing, the haute-liberal political fantasia that remains a touchstone for professional Democrats.

 Trump, in his own way, is laying claim to that mantle. He wants people to think he has stopped eight wars and thus should get lots of Nobel prizes. 

Sheen’s story concerned a man who shows up at the gates of heaven and earns an admonishment from St Peter for his lack of scars. “Was there nothing worth fighting for?” St Peter asked the man.

'The others didn't think so', the man replies, 'because I killed them before they could start any rough stuff. That's how come I converted millions to Christianity.' 

Tai turned the question on Tooze: “Where are your scars, Adam? I can show you mine.”

Tai cuts herself and then cries herself to sleep. This is because, like Kamala, she believes mean girls in the West Wing are said nasty things about her.  

Recalling this exchange several months later, Tooze was still flabbergasted. “I’d be silly if I didn’t admit that it was a bruising encounter,” he told me recently, in one of three long conversations we had over the past year.

Trump wouldn't have been bruised. He'd have said 'Tai cuts herself. Bitches be kray kray.'  

Nevertheless, he said, “it confirmed my underlying theory about what was going on. These were a group of entirely self-satisfied American liberal elites who were enacting a morality tale in which Sheen and The West Wing and that whole highly sentimental vision of power and politics is a central device. She says this, I think, meaning to sound tough, like, ‘I’m the warrior. Who are you? You’re just some desktop guy.’

She was a trade negotiator. He was a professor. But was she any good? No. Was he any good? Who cares? He taught useless shite. 

Which just shows how little she understands what I’m saying, which is: ‘You people are a bunch of sentimental schmucks who don’t understand that you lost.

No. They did get that they had lost. Was it because Kamala had a vagina? Sure. Let's go with that. The alternative is to admit Biden was senile in which case the question arises why he wasn't forced out of office by his Cabinet.  

If you had any self-respect, you would not be on any podium again, ever, sounding off about anything.

No. Dems should be talking to EU ministers and getting them to form a cohesive group so as to gain countervailing pressure over Trump. Maybe this has in fact happened. The EU, working in concert with BRICS, starts retaliating  a few months before mid-terms such that cost of living goes through the roof and key swing states start experiencing lay-offs. That way Trump turns into a lame duck. Congress can impeach him at leisure. SCOTUS, too, becomes cautious because if they persist in backing Trump, the Dems will take their revenge by taking away life-time tenure when they return to power. 

Because comrades, if we were in the 30s, I would have taken you out and shot you. You fail like this, you don’t get to come back and show off your wounds.’”

Tooze has gone mad. He thinks he is Stalin.  

Though it’s difficult to remember now, there was a time when Joseph R Biden was hailed as a president with the transformative potential of a Franklin D Roosevelt or a Lyndon B Johnson.

He started off well. People thought that, like LBJ, he would have networks within both Houses which would assure passage of 'build back better' bills on the scale of the New Deal or Great Society.  

During the 2020 campaign, Biden had positioned himself explicitly as the moderate alternative to both Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump. After the election, however, he quickly made clear that he did not intend to govern as a doddering centrist placeholder. He seemed particularly keen to flatter the aspirations of the left wing of the Democratic party, which, despite Sanders’ defeat, was experiencing its most significant resurgence in half a century.

In other words, Biden himself was the biggest enemy of the rising element in his party.  Sadly, this meant Kamala too was tarred with the same brush. 

The early days of Biden’s presidency saw what appeared to be a new rapprochement between centrist liberals and the rising left. Tooze, a self-described “left-liberal”, was perhaps the representative intellectual figure of this development.

i.e. stupid and living in a fantasy world.  

Some of this had to do with Crashed, which established him as a leading economic commentator and found an admirer in Chuck Schumer, the leader of the Senate Democrats.

Progressives are furious with Schumer.  

Some of it also had to do with Tooze’s longstanding interest in climate policy, which was shaping up to be a central focus of the Biden administration.

Obama had a 'Green New Deal' consisting of pissing money against a wall.  

And some of it, too, had to do with a belated but intense engagement with Twitter, which he joined in 2015 at the urging of his daughter (then a teenager) when he was in his late 40s, where he soon gained a huge following.

of stupid people.  

Five years after Biden’s inauguration, the political atmosphere in the US could not be more different. Yet Tooze remains no less relevant as an intellectual force.

To whom? The brain dead. Dems need to win the mid-terms. By all means, coordinate with EU finance ministers. Pick out key constituencies where lay-offs caused by a trade war will alter electoral outcomes. Suggest ways to target big donors to Trump over their overseas assets or operations. Some may call this treason, but if treason prosper then it isn't treason at all.  

Whereas once he had personified the appeal of high-technocratic expertise – the feeling that if you could just read widely enough and understand deeply enough, you might be able to chart a sensible approach to crises like climate change

coz writing for the Guardian magically creates solar panels- right? The fact is, China stands alone as the biggest and best at battery production and tech. Look at the recent trade agreement with Canada. China sells Electric Vehicles and Canadian farmers avoid bankruptcy. But the terms of trade move against primary producers. China wins and goes on winning.  

– today Tooze stands as one of the more eloquent analysts of a new and confusing world order.

No. He was and is a shithead. This is a nutter who thought Varoufakis had a point! 

“My basic wager in interpreting modern history is to bias toward the thought that it might be unprecedented,” Tooze told me.

Everything has a precedent- including stuff which genuinely is unprecedented precisely because unprecedented shit has always gone down.  

“I’m interested in the way the present continuously breaks us.

Does it also sodomize us and say 'you like it don't you, you fucking retard bitch?'  

It challenges us.

To suck its dick? Kick it in the goolies and go back to sleep.  

It does not, when you’re honest and serious about it, confirm what you know.”

Unless what you know is true and useful.  

In The Deluge, his 2014 book about the legacy of the first world war, Tooze described the way early-20th-century world leaders confronted “the radical novelty” of a world in which the US economy was newly dominant.

They didn't confront it. They played 'extend and pretend', till the money spigot ran dry.  

These days, Tooze spends most of his time tracking a dynamic that he believes is similarly unprecedented and consequential: the rise of China as an economic superpower.

Which is like the rise of Japan over which Trump got his knickers in a twist back in the Eighties. Don't forget he was with Ross Perot at some points during the Nineties.  

In Tooze’s view, what he calls the “radicalism of the present”

meaningless gibberish 

keeps many people, including policymakers, from seeing the world as it actually is.

We don't know what the world 'actually is'.  

Hence his argument to the Brussels panel that Biden and his staff were not the defenders of the liberal world order that they imagined themselves to be.

Because they were shit. But that was already obvious. Why rub their noses in it?  

Hence, too, the claim he made in this newspaper, a few weeks before the 2024 election, that “Bidenomics [was] Maga for thinking people”.

Pissing money against a wall is what 'thinking people' like- if they are fucking libtards.  

And hence his belief that – even though the past year has seen the darkest warnings of the Biden and Harris campaigns come to gruesome fulfilment – the American liberal obsession with Trump is too often framed in terms borrowed from decades past.

It is silly to say 'Trump is a Nazi'. The truth is he is a werewolf who only sodomized Zombie Hitler once- but it it happened in Vegas and, anyway, Hitler signed an NDA.  

“Why can’t we have new bad things?” he asked me at one point. “Like really new, really bad things?”

Kamala as POTUS? Sadly, people would have to vote for her to make this happen.  

Though he only leads two courses a year at Columbia, Tooze still thinks of himself primarily as a teacher. His job, he told me, “is to help people understand the situation that we’re in, as clearly as we can. It’s to go, ‘Look at this, look at this: what does this tell us if we pin our eyes open and don’t flinch and don’t blink?’ And then to say that out loud.”

And try to get paid for it. That's what matters. Any nutter can go on substack.  


A glance at Tooze’s family tree or his sterling CV makes it tempting to imagine his career as an untroubled glide among warm updrafts

that's good prose. Is it true? No. He did Econ at Cambridge at the wrong time. The future lay with Econophysics or, if you weren't smart enough for that, an MBA and then a soft landing with a hedge fund. 

carrying him along from the day he was born. In conversation he does not obscure his many privileges: the fact, as he puts it, that he is “the product of five generations of university-educated women”, or that his mother’s parents were wealthy cosmopolitans who published influential reports on nutrition and took Le Monde as their daily newspaper, or that his father was a prominent molecular biologist.

That's 'professional middle class'. Highgate or Oundle are good schools but not Eton or Harrow good. Anyway, smart peeps Tooze's age made billions in private equity. Their second home is a castle. 


Yet Tooze’s upbringing was more complicated than that sketch implies. His maternal grandfather, Arthur Wynn, was a civil servant who had also been – as Tooze and his family learned alongside the public in the 1980s – a Soviet spy. Tooze still speaks fondly of Arthur and his wife, Peggy; they are the joint dedicatees of Wages of Destruction, his 2006 book about Nazi economics. But he also describes Arthur as “a tough, tough, mean son of a bitch”.

Why highlight your connection to a Commie ? I suppose, at the time, the thing was fashionable. Mandleson's dad got him to join the Hampstead Young Communist League and to do voluntary work in Nyerere's Tanzania.   

Tooze describes his father, John, as “a guy that got shit done”

He was of working class origin. A brilliant man who studied something worthwhile.  

and also as someone with a well-deserved reputation for what we now call toxic masculinity: “I regularly would have people come up to me in life-science centres and say, ‘Does your name mean what I think it means?’ And then the reaction would be, ‘I’m sorry,’ or, ‘I hate your father.’”

He'd worked with James Watson. He had Yankee 'get up and go'. The Europeans didn't have the same work-culture. Also, the fellow was a bit of a pleb.  


It was John’s work that took the family to Heidelberg in 1974, when Tooze was six years old. West Germany was reckoning with its Nazi past, and Tooze says that the ambient political atmosphere weighed heavily on his youth. “I spent a lot of time identifying with the perpetrator, asking myself what kind of a Heydrich I would have been.”

He wouldn't have been a Heydrich- unless he joined the Navy. Given his Dad's background, he would have been a Mengele trying to find more effective bio-weapons like those which featured in Alastair Maclean's 'the Satan bug'.  

At that time in that place, the question was far from abstract. “I went to school with Albert Speer’s grandson.

Speer had been released in 1966. Oddly, his books became popular.  

We were the big science dignitaries that arrived in the little village outside Heidelberg where the Speers lived, and they made us welcome. My parents were invited to dinner, and the Speers said, ‘Do you need some furniture? Here’s a table.’

I'd have demanded a lampshade made from human skin.  

Literally the whole time we were in Germany we were eating off Albert Speer’s table.”

I was born in West Germany. My nanny had been in the Hitler Youth and had married a guy who was only de-Nazified in the late Fifties. The only German thing about me is my sense of humour. My jokes are no laughing matter.  

The difficult legacy of the difficult men in his family ultimately steered Tooze away from economics, his first academic love.

It is mathsy. If you are stupid you do Econ History. Kwarteng's PhD was in Econ History. He was as stupid as shit.  

Though he was fascinated by the field, and good at it, he also recognised in it “an absolutely toxic culture”.

Toxicity doesn't matter. Stupidity does. Work with cretins and you become a cretin. Tooze must have come across Wynne Godley's 'stock-flow consistency' model at Kings. The problem is that nobody knows what either are. Accountancy is all about fudging the numbers after sitting with the auditors and considering what the markets want to hear. Toxicity is generally highly correlated to arbitrariness and ipse dixit assertions- i.e. bullying other people till they nod their heads. 

Tooze sees a therapist. I wonder whether this was because Godley saw a therapist- the crazy Masud Khan. 

By the time he graduated he knew he had to leave the discipline. “I had a terrible relationship with my father, and I couldn’t be around that kind of academic man,” he says.

His dad was doing something useful. Did he understand that Cambridge Econ was useless? Perhaps. Cambridge said 'markets don't matter. Prices are administrative and cost based. Quantities depend on demand'. This is a caricature of Hicks 'fix-price' which was fine when, as Hicks thought, the Government was effectively setting the profit rate, but it was not fine after Bretton Woods collapsed and Exchange Controls were evaded or abolished. Godley & Cripps were protectionists (like Trump!) demanding import controls to 'make Britain great again' in the Seventies. Sadly, voters understood this meant a slippery slope to the reintroduction of rationing. 

With this resolution in mind, Tooze moved back to West Germany in 1989, just in time to see the Berlin Wall come down. That experience was something other than exhilarating:

Fuck off! It was exhilarating. Even ugly dudes got laid that night.  

“I was quite shaken by it, to be honest, because I realised at that point that the West German bubble that I’d grown up with was disappearing before my eyes.”

It didn't disappear. It prevailed. The problem was that young men in parts of the East did not prosper. Women left. Wolves moved in. Fucking a wolf is little fun.  

Like Brexit a quarter-century later, Germany’s reunification “massively destabilised” the hybrid identity he’d built for himself.

The guy is a hysterical clown. Blame daddy for not stroking his hair and saying 'you aren't stupid and you aren't studying worthless shite'.  

In the newly unified Germany, Tooze did historical research that ultimately prompted him to undertake a doctorate in history at the London School of Economics.

If you aren't studying Econ at the LSE, you are announcing your stupidity to the world. Still, maybe the guy would turn out to be a dynamite econometrician. But that's not what happened.  

The change in field suited him, but it did not exactly settle his existential unease. It was not until he got a teaching job at Cambridge, after his PhD, that he felt entitled to start assembling a library of his own. “Before that I felt so insecure. I didn’t feel I should own anything permanent.”

Coz Commies might expropriate it?  


Though he was writing books for general audiences, even as late as 2015 Tooze was still, in his self-deprecating description, “a secret name that grad students knew about”. Crashed changed all that. The book had its origins in a seminar on the philosophy of history he taught at Yale, which included a group of students who were involved in left politics.

useless idiots who wanted a paranoid theory of history. Did you know Obama was secretly white? Also, his real name was Barry not Barak. Trump lied about his being born in Nairobi so as to make him look cool. The truth is he was blonde and blue-eyed and attended Vassar.  

“Working with that cluster really just changed my life,” Tooze says, not least because it reawakened in him a political impulse that had more or less fallen dormant.

This is like the film 'Blue Angel' with Marlene Dietrich, except some smelly lefties play the part of the siren.  

The class showed Tooze that there was an opening for a comprehensive account that would help his new friends on the left understand what had happened during the financial crisis.

Govt. took on the downside so the US had a long bull run. Europe didn't. Stupid Krauts were left holding the dirty end of the stick.  


Gillian Tett, Tooze’s fellow columnist for the FT and the provost of King’s College, Cambridge, his alma mater, told me that “before 2008, it was incredibly hard to get a picture of how the entire global financial system worked as a single organic unit”.

It doesn't work as a single organic unit. That's why some countries were unaffected.  

In Crashed, Tooze analysed the global economy as a matrix of interrelated corporate balance sheets,

It can be no such thing because of impredicativity- i.e. one balance sheet depends on another balance sheet.  

rather than as a point-to-point comparison of national economies. Tett says that this approach gave him “a very good overarching framework” for analysing how money actually moved around the world, which proved crucial for understanding the crisis.

We already knew how 'money' moved around. What changed was who took over the down-side.  

Joseph Stiglitz, a colleague of Tooze’s at Columbia who won a Nobel prize in Economics in 2001, says that being a historian gave Tooze “a big advantage” in analysing the crisis.

But being a cat would give you an even bigger advantage. This is because it is difficult to refute the argument that 'miaow miaow miaow miaow'.  

Modern economics tends to focus on mathematical models, an approach that, while fruitful in some cases, often struggles with multifaceted events like the financial crisis.

Modern accountancy uses arithmetic. That's why it struggles with multifaceted events like the Zombie apocalypse.  

“The world is complicated, and when you put all the pieces together, the mathematical model becomes so difficult that you can’t understand it,” Stiglitz told me recently.

He can't understand shit. He probably still believes in the Greenwald-Stiglitz theorem.  

For Tooze, by contrast, “the freedom from the constraints of writing down a fully articulated mathematical model gave him the ability to give a true story of what was going on”.

Anyone can tell stories. If yours is true, you must have a better Structural Causal Model which means you ought to be a fucking billionaire.  


Crashed was published in 2018, two years after Trump’s first electoral victory prompted many Democrats to reconsider the party’s longstanding embrace of neoliberalism.

That happened when Hilary abandoned support for TPP under pressure from Sanders.  

Against the foundational neoliberal presumption that the point of politics is to serve the market, Tooze supplied a 600-page demonstration of the “irreducibly political” foundations of the global economic system.

Sub-prime was 'affirmative action'? That's a story as good as any.  

Crashed was especially popular among Democrats who wanted to argue that Obama’s fiscal caution in the wake of the 2008 crisis was responsible for the rise of Donald Trump.

Obama should have tanked the economy. Trump would have gone broke. He'd have been offering blow-jobs at truck-stops instead of running for the White House.  

Tooze thinks the situation was more complicated than that, but he makes no secret of the fact that he wrote Crashed “under the influence of left Dems from whom I’d acquired this narrative of the basic conservatism of the Obama response to the crisis”.

In other words, Tooze wrote some modish shite- a kind of  Godley sectoral analysis for dummies- aimed at a particular market and did well by it. But David Icke made more money.  

In 2019, Chuck Schumer, the leader of the Senate Democrats, invited Tooze to Washington DC, to address a caucus luncheon. Schumer’s interest reflected a new determination on the part of Democrats in Washington to test the Keynesian dictum that “anything we can actually do, we can afford”.

If you are borrowing to do it and can't repay the debt thanks to higher earnings- you can't afford it.  

Tooze recalls the senator engaging him in a conversation after his keynote. “Schumer said: ‘OK, Tooze, am I hearing you right? Are you saying that what we should be doing here is focusing on a massive investment surge? We should not be prioritising debt as a main concern? I said, ‘Yeah.’ He looked around at three people in the audience and said, ‘Do you hear what this guy’s saying? Next time we have a chance, we go big.’ I walked out and went, ‘Jesus Christ, did that just happen?’”

To be fair, Biden was actually less profligate than the first Trump administration. But cost of living took a bigger hit.  

Crashed vaulted Tooze into what he calls a “global existence” that has him travelling frequently and speaking earnestly about the community of people he runs into at conferences and in airport lounges around the world

He is what Arthur Koestler called a 'call girl'.  

. Though not a journalist – with a few exceptions, his contemporary histories rely on documents more than interviews – Tooze shares the journalistic impulse to see “policy processes reasonably up close”.

i.e. schmoozing with Senators 

He also clearly enjoys being a sounding board for people with the power to set national, continental and even global agendas: “They have the sense that you understand the way in which these pieces move. And so you become a point of confidence, somebody they feel they can speak to openly because you clearly get it,” he told me.

You are the 'amen corner' for stupid pork-barrel proposals. 


When Covid hammered the global economy in March 2020, Tooze recognised echoes of the events he had written about in Crashed. “The crazy thing was,” he told me, “we all knew we were playing a version of 2008, but it wasn’t quite the same and somebody needed to explain how. There’s a handful of people in the world that are going to try to explain this to people, and one of them is me.”

He failed. 

A month later, in the Guardian – and later in his book Shutdown, published in 2021 – he did just that, detailing the unprecedented measures central banks deployed to stave off a total collapse. All through the early months of the pandemic, he says, “there were days when I was publishing two things a day: the Guardian, the New York Times, the FT. This was before I was doing Chartbook. I wasn’t sleeping.”

He was sleep-walking.  

In Germany, when Olaf Scholz was finance minister, Tooze was invited to speak on panels to provide intellectual support for Scholz’s efforts to move the ministry away from its traditional fiscal conservatism.

 Hyperinflation has a bad rep. Also, why not appoint Varoufakis as your Economy Tzar? What could go wrong? 

And in the spring of 2020, during the delicate negotiations over an EU pandemic-recovery plan, Tooze acted as an informal messenger between the German and Italian governments.

No wonder the EU response was so utterly shit.  

In the US, meanwhile, Schumer continued to use Crashed as a policy playbook. “In the spring of 21, I started getting these texts from friends on the left wing of the Democratic party going, ‘You’re not going to believe this. I’ve just been in a meeting with Schumer and he said, we all have to read this guy, Tooze, on going big. Schumer was going, like, do you know this guy? T-O-O-Z-E?”

as opposed to cooze. Same thing really.  


Tooze says that Schumer’s staff stayed in contact with him throughout the drawn-out negotiations over what would become the Inflation Reduction Act, Biden’s signature climate bill.

Hilarious! It raised inflation and brought Trump back to power.  

In 2022, he was summoned to the White House for consultations. He accepted the invitation – largely, he says, because “it’s the one and only time I’ll ever get to the White House, so whatever, let’s go and see.”

Trump should invite him for a slap-up meal there as a thank you. 


The encounter was disillusioning. Already by that point Tooze had been frustrated with Biden on a number of fronts, including the compromises of the Inflation Reduction Act, which was vastly smaller than originally intended,

i.e. did not cause hyperinflation 

“conservative in its political framing”, and “larded with concessions to fossil fuel interests”.

Thus leaving the lights on.  

Yet nothing seems to have disturbed Tooze quite as much as seeing what he calls the “narcissism” of the Biden team at close proximity.

They were low IQ shitheads.  

In all his many years of therapy, he told me – he has been seeing a therapist multiple times a week for a decade – there were only two occasions on which he sought help specifically in response to political incidents. One was Brexit – “if there’d been an armed-resistance wing I would have wanted to be Michael Collins,”

he was killed by the more extreme anti-treaty wing.  

he says – and the other was his encounter with the Biden administration.

“Part of what motivated the unhinging of my relationship with the Biden people was being invited on to calls with their climate team,” he told me. He cited a conference call with Jake Sullivan,

quite well regarded. It was Blinken who was the blinking idiot.  

Biden’s national security adviser, that took place in 2023, not long after a Chinese balloon drifted into US airspace and sparked an international incident that Tooze described in Chartbook as “the first, bona fide war scare of our new era of Sino-US confrontation”.

Its a balloon for fuck's sake. It isn't even the balloon from Steven King's 'It'.  

On the phone call, he said, “It was just, ‘Oh Jake, you guys are rock stars.’ This was in the middle of the balloon incident, where we were sliding towards war and everyone in DC knew it.”

If they go crazy over a balloon, fuck will they do if they see a kite?  

One of Tooze’s friends, the novelist Zoe Dubno, told me that Sullivan is often “enemy number one” at Tooze’s dinner parties, where many of the guests, like Sullivan, are products of elite Ivy League educations: “He hurts everyone because they’re like, ‘That could be me. If we decided to be completely compromised fuckheads, that’s the kind of evil that is available to me.’”

In other words, he did his job fairly well.  

Despite his political flirtations on both sides of the Atlantic, Tooze says he has “a very ambiguous relationship to power”, an uneasiness he traces back to his lifelong effort not to be like his father. “The thing that haunts me is that I know perfectly well that I could be that kind of person in the world,” he said.

No. You studied useless shite.  

For these reasons, he has tried to maintain an “obliqueness” and a “distance” from power. “I look at myself and say, a system which puts somebody like me in charge is a bad system.”

Nobody has put him in charge of shit.  

Not everyone thinks this effort has been successful. In 2019, in the New Left Review, Perry Anderson,

who went to Eton and thus was posher than Tooze, who went to Highgate 

the venerable leftist historian,

he is the same age as the Iranian Supreme Leader but less in touch with modern trends.  

published a scathing 16,000-word review-evisceration of Tooze that took for its formal targets the loose trilogy comprising Wages of Destruction, The Deluge and Crashed, and ended up attacking his entire modus vivendi.

Presumably modus operandi is meant. But Perry too was bluffing he understood 'stock flow consistency'. The truth is, it is 'anything goes'. Indeed it could end up as MMT. Still back when I was a kid, Godley was considered smart. Could he help the UK?  No. He was a reverse Cassandra. Everybody believed nothing could be done whereas it was fucking obvious that there were mechanisms to get rid of real-exchange or real-interest rate uncertainty and thus prevent a 'shakeout' turning into permanent deindustrialization. 

Apparently Godley, having advised Lamont after Black Wednesday (i.e. after everybody realised the Treasury had no 'wise men' at least not when compared to Soros), went off to 'Bard College' in America where he co-authored a silly book in partnership with a Frenchman. It is entirely vacuous. It begins thus

The premises underlying this book are, first, that modern industrial economies have a complex institutional structure comprising production firms, banks, governments and households and, second, that the evolution of economies through time is dependent on the way in which these institutions take decisions and interact with one another.

Why is this nonsense? The answer is because it doesn't mention foreign competition. Why did the UK or, later the US, stop being the world's biggest ship-builder? It is because other countries did it cheaper or better.  

Our aspiration is to introduce a new way in which an understanding can be gained as to how these very complicated systems work as a whole.

We say it works well if we are doing better than our rivals. If we aren't, we say it doesn't work well at all.  

The fiercest aspect of Anderson’s essay addressed Tooze’s politics.

Why isn't he a Communist? At the very least he could stab a banker or two to death. I don't say he should also eat them. Chaps who went to Highgate can be very picky eaters.  

All three books, Anderson argued, share a telling fault: namely, a failure to reckon adequately with the deep forces that gave shape to the events he described. In Wages of Destruction and The Deluge, Anderson says Tooze approaches each of his subjects “in medias res, dispensing with a structural explanation of its origins”.

That 'structural explanation' is that Capitalist get up in the middle of the night and enter the hovels of the proles and drain them of their vital bodily essence through aggravated acts of fellatio and cunnilingus. That why the working class are too dazed to resist exploitation and surplus value extraction.  


Anderson is a Marxist, and so it’s not particularly surprising that he was unimpressed by Tooze’s self-description as a “left-liberal”, a compound phrase that, he noted, “has often, perhaps typically, proved unstable”. Nor was it difficult to see how someone with Anderson’s theoretical views would decide that Tooze was no true leftist at all.

Also, he isn't really a nice black girl from Shanghai who is in a committed lesbian relationship with a Guatemalan goat.  

By the end of the essay, however, that latter judgment has expanded well beyond the content of Tooze’s books into a sneering indictment of his whole public existence. The breadth of interests, audiences and sympathies that for so many of Tooze’s admirers mark his signal virtue stood for Anderson as proof of his political unreliability.

Very true. The dude was invited to the White House. Did he eat Joe Biden? No. He made some excuse about not having brought along the bottle of HP Sauce his proletarian grandfather had bequeathed him and left early.  

“Tooze spreads himself widely, and his accents

those of Hampstead rather than Eton?  

and formulations vary from place to place,” Anderson wrote. “That’s often the price of a growing reputation [and] shouldn’t be taken too seriously. To criticisms of inconsistency, he can in any case reply quite reasonably that nothing he has written falls outside the parameters of a basic commitment to liberalism as it has developed in the west from the time of Wilson and Lloyd George to that of Geithner and Macron.” (In the context of the New Left Review, these points of comparison could hardly be more damning.)

  The verse I wrote (in imitation of Jonathan Swift) on first reading the New Left Review was

Here's a proof of Lefty sense.
Here Lefty wit is seen
With no values worthy of defence
they bring out a new magazine!

I didn't know at the time- I was 14- that the magazine was older than I was. Also, it had no pics of nekkid ladies.   

Anderson’s implication that Tooze is essentially keeping two sets of books – one set of accounts for his lefty graduate students, another for his discussion partners at Davos – becomes the basis for his essay’s bitter final judgment: “In today’s world, the question can be asked: how far does that differ from running with the hare and hunting with the hounds – indignant sympathy for the hare, awed admiration for the hounds?”

Lefty graduate students will chase after and eat Davos Man. Tooze couldn't even take a bite out of Biden.  

Tooze does not hide the devastation he felt on reading Anderson’s essay,

he cried and cried. Did he also cut himself? No. That's why he has no scars to show.  

or the fact that he still thinks about it often. He told me that his disorientation had much to do with his longstanding admiration for his antagonist.

Perry Anderson was even stupider and more useless than his brother.  

Tooze has subscribed to the NLR since his 20s, has written for it several times, and says he always read Anderson’s essays “religiously”.

I wish Anderson were my daddy. He would gently lower my drawers and wreck my rectum very lovingly. Benedict Cumberpatch would play me in the sequel to Patrick Melrose- Tooze as cooze.  

Perhaps predictably, Tooze rejects much of Anderson’s critique. He is also plainly offended that his attempt to be honest about who he is, and where he’s coming from, was taken by Anderson as a kind of shiftiness, or even hypocrisy. Over the past decade or so, Tooze’s politics have shifted notably leftward.

Start from irrelevance and move rapidly towards absurdity. It's the classy thing to do- more particularly if daddy didn't wreck your rectum.  

Yet Tooze still feels it imperative to acknowledge “how deeply I am the product of the circumstances I was raised in”.

If I'd gone to a posher skool, my rectum would surely have been more effectively wrecked.  

As he put it to me at his office, last April, “I take that more seriously than the average academic leftist. Because I don’t imagine that by virtue of thinking a bunch of radical thoughts, I can get more than a little bit of the way towards escaping my professional upper-middle class identity. I’m a senior professor at an immensely rich private university. Where do I get off kidding myself about this?”

Also I iz White and don't have to sit down to pee. How is that fair?  

In another conversation, in October, Tooze noted that he had done “a lot of activism around green politics and central banking and naming and shaming the IMF economists”.

This is like my activism around claiming to be better at twerking than Beyonce.  

His voice rose to an exasperated pitch as he imagined a conversation with Anderson: “It’s like, ‘Show me your cards. Where the fuck have you been on any of these issues? What’s your position on climate? Where were you with the Green New Deal? Where have you been on Gaza?’”

Also, fuck were you doing during the War of the Roses? Not having been born then is no excuse.  

More surprisingly, Tooze said that Anderson’s attack helped him clarify his own principles and practices. Anderson used the phrase “in medias res” as a jab at Tooze’s neglect, as he saw it, of the deep political and economic forces that shaped his narratives. Yet Tooze has come to embrace in medias res both as “a very succinct summation of the challenge that I’m particularly interested in” and as a simple but profound description of the basic human situation. In his view, there is no escaping the middle of things: every one of us is born, lives and dies in a rushing flow of events that precedes us and will outlast us.

Shitting and pissing are part of a simple description of the basic human situation. 'In medias res' is a description of a particular type of narrative which doesn't begin 'ab ovo'- with the egg from which Helen was born. In looking at an event- e.g. the financial crash- you need that egg- i.e. a theory of why a class of assets (e.g. 'sub-prime') got mispriced. Saying 'stocks & flows' is mere handwaving. There was a mechanism design fault. Diagnose it. Fix it. Simples.  

He told me that he is not a Marxist in part because he thinks treating a body of theory produced in the middle of the 19th century as “the be-all and end-all” – a stable point from which one might stand outside history and discern its hidden forces and patterns – is “a lazy way of dealing with reality”.

Sadly, reality has been rather lazy in dealing with us. It should have slapped us straight ages ago.  

To accept the radicalism of the present, he says, means acknowledging that you can’t understand history before it happens:

The owl of Minerva flies by night- as Hegel said. He was early nineteenth century.  

“If you’re in the middle of shit, you don’t actually know what the shit is that you’re in the middle of.”

Yes you do unless 'shit' is a metaphor. But you do know what is causing you to want to retch- unless you are merely virtue signalling.  


Last spring, Tooze became an American citizen. The decision predated Trump’s return to office and had mostly to do with the precarity Tooze felt previously: “If you’re in a green-card situation, you do not want to be arrested. And it is remarkably easy to get arrested in this country.” Nevertheless, he admits that he considered leaving the US after Trump was re-elected. He was particularly frustrated by the situation at Columbia.

The had a good British-Egyptian President who had played hardball as Director of the LSE. They should have stuck with her.  

On the one hand, he was not eager to watch, as he had during Trump’s first term, another “ding-dong battle between Trump and indignant New York Times-reading liberals” on the faculty. On the other hand, he’d been appalled to see how many of his colleagues, including serious leftists, had gone quiet during the Gaza turmoil on campus.

How fucking appalling do you have to be to get appalled that appalling shitheads are making less noise?  

Tooze himself has been vocal in his defence of the rights of both Palestinians and pro-Palestinian protesters;

and any other nutcases who want to disrupt the teaching of useful subjects 

an online watchlist featured video screenshots that showed him in an orange faculty vest at a 2024 Columbia protest. He acknowledged that he felt a freedom to speak his mind for “thoroughly bourgeois reasons”.

Islamists may cut his head off but they won't sodomize his corpse because they too went to Highgate.  

Thanks to Chartbook, he said, which brings him more income than his salary at Columbia, “If I get fired from this job, I walk away. I’m totally fine.”

No. If he gets fired for plagiarism and sucking off little boys, his income from Chartbook will collapse 

Still, he was dismayed at how much the fear of losing their accumulated academic privileges had “constrained people in what they’ve been willing to say. They are so fucking scared of losing that. It’s disgusting how scared they are.”

Very true. Use the wrong pronoun and suddenly you are unemployable.  

Tooze says he decided to stay in the US in large part because his daughter lives here. He was confirmed in that decision, however, by news that three of his former colleagues at Yale, Timothy Snyder, Marci Shore and Jason Stanley, were moving to Canada.

That's a good reason not to go there.  

“Their decision just radically clarified it for me. Because it’s absolutely the wrong decision in every respect: it’s wrong politically, it’s wrong ethically. Even if, as Tim Snyder has claimed, it has nothing to do with politics, the optics are terrible. They should have deferred the move for 12 months.”

These aren't good looking people. The optics are already terrible.  


Tooze is still reluctant to use the word “fascist” to describe Trump’s government,

Fascism only exists if the police can't handle a Communist threat. The US never had that problem.  

even as he recognises “the possibility of a kind of escalation here towards something truly catastrophic”.

That's nuclear Armageddon. But that could happen under any POTUS.  

Tooze told me that his increasingly lonely resistance to that term has much to do with not wanting to shoehorn the present into the past. When I pressed him on the question, though, he also admitted a frustration with the kind of people who invoke the analogy, and the reasons they invoke it.

Jason Stanley invokes it coz he's of Jewish heritage. All Tooze can whine about is that his grandpappy went to Oundle and he too was privately educated.  

He allowed that “fascist” might be a useful way to emphasise the radical character of Trump’s rule but said he still didn’t like the way the analogy encouraged the kind of smug moral satisfaction that he came to despise in the Biden administration.

You should be cutting yourself and crying yourself to sleep every night. At least see a therapist twice a week- for pity's sake.  

He noted that he keeps several models of Soviet T-34 tanks in his office at Columbia to remind himself, and his visitors, that it was not high-minded western ideals like democracy and freedom that defeated the Nazis in the second world war. “If you’re willing to admit that it was the Red Army that beat fascism,” Tooze said, somewhat grudgingly, “then you can have your fascism analogy.”

Armies didn't matter. Munitions and machine guns and tanks and fighter planes did. The superior industrial might of the Allies prevailed. But, against Japan, what worked best was nukes. Since then, whatever regime you have, the way you get to keep it is by having lots of nukes and effective delivery systems.  


Over the past year, in all the many parts of the Toozeosphere – the newsletters, the podcasts, the columns – Tooze has diligently tried to make sense of Trump’s second term. He has covered Trump’s tariffs, his Gaza peace plan, his abduction of Venezuela’s president, and his soya bean deal with Xi Jinping. He has also wrestled publicly with one of the central questions that any analyst of this bizarre period in American history must confront: namely, whether the possibility of “making sense of Trump” is its own kind of delusion – sanewashing, as it’s sometimes called. Tooze doesn’t think so. Though Trump himself is “obviously a degenerate buffoon”, Tooze’s analysis goes further. “If it’s true that the key to decoding what’s going on is facelifts and boob jobs at Mar-a-Lago, why? How do we make sense of that?”

Follow the money. Maduro's kidnapping means ten billion extra dollars for a big Trump donor.  

Yet in our conversations as well as in his writing, he often seemed less than energised whenever the subject turned to Trump. He acknowledged as much. Though he sees Trump undertaking a “profound reshaping of American society”, Tooze also made it clear that he interprets Trump as a symptom rather than a cause of the US’s decline. And that decline, while consequential, is far less interesting to Tooze than the concomitant rise of China, which has recently become his all-consuming obsession.

Once again, this is about industrial economics. The truth is China had risen militarily by the end of the Sixties and Nixon acknowledged this. Could it imitate Taiwan and South Korea? Sure. That's it. That's the whole story. I omit a long passage about Tooze's belated discovery of China's rise. 

Tooze thinks there are two available choices. One involves a “truly escalated hard-power competition”.

Which is happening and will continue any way.  

The other option involves finding an accommodation with Chinese partners that, as Tooze puts it, “include Stalinists – proper Stalinists”.

Fuck that. Sullivan said the US no longer supported any type of regime change in China. It would not seek to intervene in its internal affairs.   

He told me that while he sometimes gets accused of being a “useful idiot” for the Chinese Communist party, he is

a useless idiot 

not naive about the regime. In Tianjin this summer, he was overcome by a “sadness” when seeing a massive conference centre that was under construction.

The Chinese have big conferences. What has changed is that more and more countries will send delegations to them.  

“It’s as though you were watching the pyramids being constructed. The pyramids are very impressive, but you don’t get to see the forced labour.

Archaeologists don't think there was forced labour. Working on the pyramids was well rewarded.  

China right now is like watching the pyramids being constructed in real time. You see all of the inequality. You see the Pharaonic ambition. All along the edge of it you’ve got these people sleeping in their cars and slumped over their mopeds.

That is 'frictional'. China has housing over-supply.  

“The moral weight of that is what we have to wrestle with,” Tooze says.

Masturbation isn't wrestling.  

Still, it’s clear which option he prefers. “My deep conviction is that the west needs to accept the end of its era of global domination.

Which the UK did before I was born.  

That doesn’t mean that we have to give up our own values,

or that we have to suck off elephants- even if those elephants are bleck.  

or not defend our own perfectly legitimate interests in our own system, or that we should not be absolutely clear-eyed about the nature of the Chinese regime.” What it does mean, he says, is embracing a deep realism of a sort that the west – and the US in particular – has never exactly been famous for.

Trump did it by saying there is now just a Group of 2- US and China.  

Actual progress, he believes, will require us to accept the humbling imperatives of the unprecedented present moment.

Sadly, accepting stupid shite doesn't entail any type of progress.  

As he put it in his New School lecture: “Ours is a bit part and not the starring role.

The US still has about 16 percent of global GDP. It is still the tops in transoceanic force projection. Trump is the star of the movie but, if he loses the mid-terms- it is a shitty Jerry Lewis movie rather than Dean Martin as Matt Helm.  

We’re not the love interest.

That's the co-star.  

This song is not about us.”

Tooze's song is 'it's my party, I will cry if I want to.' Greater Narcissism no man can show than to say Biden's crew were nauseatingly narcissistic because fuckers like Sullivan made quite a good fist of serving the National interest.  

 

Saturday, 12 October 2024

Revising Adam Tooze on Revisionism

Writing for the Guardian, Adam Tooze notes that

Facing war in the Middle East and Ukraine, the US looks feeble.

Because Biden looks senile.

But is it just an act

No. He really is senile. Still his job now is to look so decrepit, Harris looks Presidential by comparison.  

Still, Kamala may need Muslim votes to push her over the top. Till then, America arms Israel but asks them not to kill anybody with those weapons. Harris wants to be a two term POTUS. This means she can't have the same foreign policy as Biden- who isn't even a boomer. He is actually part of the 'silent generation' which, we now understand, was silent for a very good reason. It is obvious that the world has changed and a new foreign policy is needed. But will it be isolationist? Perhaps. Obama said America's foreign policy consisted of doing stupid shit. It may be that not doing stupid shit involves not having a foreign policy. Just be transactional.                  

The idea that Biden is just muddling through these global crises isn’t convincing.

Why not?  The world thinks he is senile. He can't make any big moves just in case it will help Trump. His job is to look so utterly decrepit that Harris shines by comparison. 

Look closely and his foreign policy has been as radical as Trump’s

His big swing was 'Quad' which had re-emerged under Trump but which Biden said would have a 'defining role in the region' . Everything else was incremental albeit often cackhanded or counterproductive. But is Quad a paper umbrella? The fact that Biden just said 'it's here to stay' means it will soon go away.

Writing on-the-spot histories always comes with risks. But the urgency of the situation demands it.

Not really. The elections aren't that far away. Either Israel hits Iran after the election or the signal is that the  US is abandoning Taiwan and Israel. This is a major reset. What will post-boomer diplomacy look like?  

We need some explanation for why the US is not doing more to calm the situation in the Middle East

Biden is senile. That's the explanation. He had been quick to react by air-lifting arms to Israel to the October attack because he remembered Nixon's Operation Nickel Grass from 50 years ago when he first became a Senator. But after that he dithered. Nice guy, but not Presidential material. This had been the verdict on both his earlier bids for the White House. Then, after he had retired, he was brought back precisely because he wasn't Presidential. Indeed, he wasn't even CFO material. Veep for DIE was the vibe which got him the White House. If Trump was the anti-Christ, Biden was the anti-Trump. He would make America lame again. 

and to push for negotiations between Ukraine and Russia.

It must be said, Biden always hated Putin and believed that Russia was in terminal decline. True, like the rest of us, he didn't predict that Zelensky and the Ukrainians would prove so tough or Putin's mercenaries so utterly crap. The other thing nobody saw coming was Hamas's atrocious war-plan. In one case, a comedian turned out to be a hero of Churchillian stature. In the other, a gerontocratic, Leninist, kleptocracy showed tactical genius of a rare order. By 'front-loading' the most atrocious aspects of the attack, they ensured that, sooner or later, they would get what all Leninist parties want- viz. unconditional support from 'useful idiots' no matter what atrocity is committed. 

There is one school of thought that says the Biden administration is muddling through.

Which enables Harris to shine by comparison. She looks Presidential. Her party has no choice but to unite around a vapid diversity hire who couldn't even run her own office properly.  

It has no grand plan. It lacks the will or the means to discipline or direct either the Ukrainians or the Israelis.

It has no objection to resisting Putin's aggression to the last drop of Ukrainian blood. Also, if we lost the war against terror, why shouldn't the Israelis take a beating for a change? 

As a result, it is mainly focused on avoiding a third world war.

Even Biden can manage to avoid pressing the nuclear button. He is senile not sociopathic.  

If so, that is a sad testament to the decline of American hegemonic ambition.

Biden's 'summit for democracy' was foolish. He has pushed more and more countries into the arms of China. Meanwhile, Putin's failures in Ukraine have soldered together a cohesive Eurasian block including Iran. My own impression is that under Biden 'strategic ambiguity' over Taiwan disappeared. How can it be resurrected? Quad? Australia will probably realize that waiting for Anglo-American nuclear submarines, which don't have nukes, is simply silly. As for Japan, that dog won't hunt. This leaves India which will never be a naval power. It will use its demographic advantage against China in the high Himalayas but its economic interest is in allying with China- this was the original 'Panchsheel' plan. America has been a destabilizing force in Asia and the MENA. Maybe it is time it just fucks the fuck off. 

No wonder there are calls in the US for Washington to develop an “independent” foreign policy – independent, that is, of Ukraine and Israel.

& Taiwan. What happens if Putin does nuclear proliferation into Latin America? Cartels with nukes won't be deterred by a wall. Come to think of it. the Israeli's had a 'smart wall' didn't they? 

But what if that interpretation is too benign?

It is too benign to say that US foreign policy is a muddle. As Obama said, it is stupid shit.  

What if it underestimates the intentionality on Washington’s part?

Washington wants to make America utterly lame so it can concentrate on scolding the world for being naughty.  

What if key figures in the administration actually see this as a history-defining moment and an opportunity to reshape the balance of world power?

The balance of world power has moved greatly against the US over the Biden Presidency. His plan was to spend lots and lots of money. But the US can't become the arsenal for democracy once again. On current projections, it may not be able to meet its own defence requirements by the 2030s.  

What if what we are witnessing is the pivoting of the US to a deliberate and comprehensive revisionism by way of a strategy of tension?

It has taken Iran decades to implement a 'strategy of tension' in the Arabian peninsula. What violent struggle can America sponsor? If Putin really does start exporting nukes to Latin America, sooner or later you will have Cartels which have countervailing power over the DEA. 

Revisionist powers are those that want to overturn the existing state of things.

Stupid powers don't know what the existing state of things actually is. This may also be true of transactional powers, but they learn from the 'discovery' they do or else stop being able to transact anything at all.  

In an extended sense, this can also mean a desire to alter the flow of events; for instance, to redirect or halt the process of globalisation.

Which started happening when the Neanderthals failed to prevent us taking over their territory.  

Revisionism is often associated with resentment or nostalgia for an earlier, better age.

So is eating hotdogs at the football stadium. Why don't they still taste great? Also, why am I as fat as fuck?

What makes us shrink from this interpretation of Joe Biden’s foreign policy is

his shitting himself and running away from Kabul. The Biden doctrine is 'American soldiers are very precious. Wait till we evacuate them before defending yourself. After that, we will criticize you for human rights violations and threaten to disinvite you from our Democracy summit.'  

the sheer aggression of Russia since February 2022 and Hamas on 7 October.

Which ought to have been anticipated. What couldn't have been anticipated was the reaction of Zelensky and his Ukrainians. It remains to be seen whether Europe creates its own army and weans itself off military dependence on the US. But this means having its own defence industry. In a multi-polar world, there must be multiple military-industrial complexes.  

The US-led west is generally seen as reactive, not proactive.

It is seen as having lost the war on terror and as declining in significance relative to a cohesive Eurasian bloc. Henceforth, it must seek to drive a wedge between Russia, China and Iran. No doubt, such a wedge would emerge in any case but the West could stop being 'proactive' in soldering together such disparate powers.  

But focus not on the process

which involves virtue signalling and fucking over your friends 

but on the outcomes of US policy, and a different interpretation seems plausible.

America truly wants to return to splendid isolationism. Europe needs more and more Muslim migrants to keep ticking over. This may be tough for the Jews and the Homosexuals and trans people but you can't deny that Muslims have a great work ethic and proper family values.  

Under Donald Trump, after all, the demand to make America great again was quite literally revisionist.

Biden's too slogans were 'build back better' and 'America is back'. Biden sought to create the impression that America had been hegemonic and had been enforcing a rules based International order and spreading Democracy and Human Rights till that nasty Trump had become President. Now he was in charge, America would lead the world towards freedom, prosperity and being nice to darkies and homos and transgender people. 

He had no interest in the existing rules of the game. He tossed trade treaties out the window. He slapped tariffs on China.

like Biden and now the EU 

“America first” was the mantra.

Rather than 'America last'.  

By comparison with Trump, the Biden team boast of their commitment to a rules-based order.

Which involved invading Muslim countries and killing lots of innocent people.  

But when it came to the world economy and the rise of China, Biden has been every bit as aggressive as, perhaps more so than, his predecessor.

He telegraphed his punches and then, it turned out, there were no punches.  

Under Biden, Washington has been committed to reversing years of decline apparently brought on by excessive favour shown to China.

This could succeed. Industrial policy needn't be utterly shitty. But what are the chances?  

The US has tried to stop China’s development in tech. To do so, it has strong-armed allies such as the Dutch and the South Koreans.

Sadly, this may result in China doubling down on R&D and ultimately taking the lead. The wider problem is that richer countries may have a perverse incentive to produce expensive shite. Poor countries have no choice but to go with what is cheap but effective.  

When the World Trade Organization dared to protest against US steel tariffs, the White House reaction was contemptuous.

The WTO is a joke. But the US made it that way. 

Bidenomics is Maga for thinking people.

No. It is senile shite. Thinking people tend to substitute words for action.  

In what is now called the Indo-Pacific, the US is not merely defending the status quo.

If the US can't stop the Houthis hitting shipping in the Red Sea, fuck can they defend? Just yesterday, the American flagged tanker 'Olympic Spirit' was hit by 11 ballistic missiles and two drones. There are all sorts of Islamist insurgent groups stretching all the way to the Philippines which can do what the Houthis are doing. 

Currently, Biden & Co think they have scored big by turning Myanmar into a disaster zone and toppling Sheikh Hasina in Bangladesh. But, it is likely both will become Chinese clients albeit with Islamist insurgent groups operating from their soil. The question is who will control those groups? 

The very definition of the strategic arena is new.

Doing stupid shit is not new.  

In the Quad (Quadrilateral Security Dialogue), Washington is putting in place a new latticework of alliances that ties India, Japan and Australia to the US.

But, if the US does not defend Israel, it will have zero credibility.  

If nothing else had happened in the past two years, the judgment would be clear. The geo-economic policy of the US towards China under Biden is a continuation of the revisionism first seen under Trump.

In other words, Biden followed where Trump had led.  

It was because it was focused on confronting China that the White House sought detente with Russia in 2021.

Since the time of Nixon, American policy has been to try to keep China and Russia apart.  

What spoiled that were two miscalculations made by Vladimir Putin. The first was to assume that his assault on Ukraine was a bagatelle. The second was to underestimate the willingness of the west to use Ukraine as a proxy against Russia.

I think this 'willingness' was a direct product of the incredible valour shown by the Ukrainians. Many had assumed that the comedian would run away and some Moscow friendly goon would have been installed in Kiev.  

Two years into the war, the position of the west has hardened into its own revisionism. In relation to both Ukraine and Russia, the status quo ante is no longer acceptable.

I think the West would accept some territorial gains for Russia. The other point is if Putin dies or is overthrown, somebody competent may take charge.  

In the Middle East, the situation is even more clear cut.

No it isn't. We had no idea of Hamas's military strength or that the Houthis could rain down rockets on ships in the Red Sea. The question now is whether the Muslim Brotherhood can revive its political fortunes in Egypt (if so, Israel can't afford to leave Gaza) and Saudi Arabia. The bigger question is when and if Hanafi Hamas will break with Shia Iran.  

Here, too, the Biden administration was not looking to escalate. Trump’s Abraham accords between the United Arab Emirates and Israel had opened up a promising vista. But Russia’s growing ties with Iran, and China’s involvement in the region darkened the picture.

Actually, we'd have been relieved if China brokered a deal between Hamas and Israel. Perhaps they could turn Gaza into a thriving manufacturing centre. 

Once Hamas launched its attack on 7 October, and once the Israeli government’s determination to end the modus vivendi with Hamas and Hezbollah became clear, Washington gave the green light.

Biden's knee jerk reaction was to start a big air-lift- like Nixon's 'Operation Nickel Grass'. But Hamas's resilience changed the picture. Moreover, people who had been appalled by Hamas's atrocities are now their unconditional supporters. What percentage of young Americans fall into this category? If it is growing, Harris is likely to pivot on this issue- or appear to do so- more particularly because her husband is Jewish. 


The US is paying for more than 25% of Israel’s rampage as it physically annihilates Gaza, victimises the West Bank and sets about uprooting Hezbollah. It has pulled allies such as Germany and the UK into line.

Under Starmer, that may change. Labour can't afford to alienate Muslim voters.  

It is shielding Netanyahu against the reach of international justice.

Israel has nukes. The Hague doesn't want to be turned into a pile of radioactive dust. Islamic terrorism has been bad. Jewish terrorism would be worse because Jews are hella smart.  


Of course, unlike in Ukraine, the US has continued diplomacy. But to what effect? First and foremost to keep Iran boxed in and the powerful Gulf states on side.

That's failed. The Gulf countries are asking Biden to stop Netanyahu bombing Iran's oil facilities even though it is other oil exporters who have most to gain.  

Meanwhile, Israel is wiping out Iran’s network of influence

but young high quality recruits must be pouring in. These are kids of whom Mossad knows nothing. It will have to build up Humint from scratch. 

and annihilating the 1990s vision of a two-state solution.

Which the PLO and Hamas annihilated all by themselves.  

In all three arenas – China, Ukraine and the Middle East – the US will say that it is responding to aggression.

It is prepared to fund, but not to fight. But the money too may run out.  

But rather than working consistently for a return to the status quo it is, in fact, raising the stakes.

Is it really? Biden may have had some such delusion. Does Harris?  

While insisting that it supports the rules-based order, what we are witnessing is something closer to a revival of the ruinous neoconservative ambition of the 1990s and 2000s.

The neocons were pals with a guy whom they thought could replace Saddam. He promised to love them long time and give them lots and lots of money.  

With regard to China, the revisionist strategy was clear from the start.

What is clear is that it has failed. If Harris wins, she is bound to piss off the Indians who will withdraw from a Quad which is too costly. Ultimately the economics involved in the division of labour means that India must develop weapons systems in partnership with poorer, more reliable, countries. But, as China and India face a common problem in Myanmar, why might this not be China? Let us see what happens after the Dalai Lama dies. Interestingly, Biden had attacked Trump for being the first POTUS not to meet the Dalai Lama. But, he himself neglected to do so. This calls into question the support that the State Dept. are claiming to extend to the Tibetan government in exile. Here, it is India's position which matters. If Harris becomes President, she might well make an equation between Kashmir and Tibet. India will then go back to its traditional anti-Americanism. The question is whether China is interested in a modus vivendi. 

In Ukraine and the Middle East, Washington has responded to events. But that isn’t evidence against strategic intent.

It is evidence there was no fucking strategy. Intending to have one, doesn't mean you have one. 

Using your enemy’s aggression, the desperation of your friends and the ruthlessness of your allies to your own advantage is simply smart policy. Washington has not been entirely reckless. Biden has resisted the most radical calls for engagement in Ukraine. He pulled out of Afghanistan

he postponed the Trump negotiated pull out but, because he called President Ghani plain Mr. Ghani, that expert on failed states soon had to run away from his failed state. America's retreat from Kabul was shambolic.  But Karzai, whom they had toppled, is still in Kabul. 

and has refused to put American boots on the ground.

He firmly believes that American soldiers should be wrapped in protective foam and kept out of harm's way.  

At some point the White House may decide that ceasefires are necessary.

At some point it may ask its allies to surrender. The enemy won't take kindly to any such requests.  

But there is more going on here than simply muddling through. First the Trump and now the Biden presidencies are willing contributors to the controlled demolition of the 1990s post-cold war order.

Biden willingly contributed to a great erosion of American power and credibility. Trump may not care greatly about either. He wants to make profitable deals. Ultimately, everything is transactional. If he gets back into the White House, there are lots of things he can very quickly do to improve the lives of Americans. Sadly this requires a foreign policy which does not consist in mindlessly doing 'stupid shit' even if it be of the Obama/Biden stripe. 

Thursday, 5 July 2018

Adam Tooze on some shite Slobodian.

This is Adam Tooze reviewing  'Globalists: The End of Empire and the Birth of Neoliberalism'. by Quinn Slobodian in Dissent magazine.

 For Slobodian, the earliest and most authentic brand of neoliberalism was from the outset defined by its preoccupation with the question of world economic integration and disintegration.
Imperialism was about world economic integration. But, it was discovered, it was unnecessary. Resources would flow to where they were needed without it. Countries would voluntarily club together- as Europe did after the second world war- and so there was no need for a Hitler or a Stalin.
In the 1970s, neoliberalism’s proponents would help unleash the wave of globalization that has swept the world.
Nonsense! 'Proponents of neoliberalism' means pointy headed academics or bottom feeding denizens of think tanks. What unleashed globalisation was the stupidity of the Trade Union movement and the cowardice and incompetence of the managerial class. Leaders all over the world decided to ignore those shitheads and let them price themselves out of the market. So what if unemployment went back up to Great Depression levels? There was no danger that either the Nazis or the Stalinists would take over because you only had to look at them to see they were as stupid as shite and as crazy as bedbugs.
But, as Slobodian shows, their advocacy for free trade and the liberalization of capital movement goes back to neoliberalism’s founding moments in the wake of the First World War.
All sorts of shite had its founding movements back then- including psychoanalysis and nudism and talking shite about Universal Peace and so forth.
The movement was born as a passionately conservative reaction to a post-imperial moment—not in the 1950s and ’60s but amidst the ruins of the Habsburg empire.
Passionately conservative? Nonsense! Hayek started off as an admirer of Weiser's democratic socialism before shifting to Menger's classical liberalism which however dispensed with a Whig landed aristocracy as the ultimate cordon sanitatire against mob rule. Thus it wasn't 'passionately conservative' at all. None of its members was a big fan of the Church or the landed magnate or the traditional Officer class.
Torn apart by self-determination, the collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Dual Monarchy in 1918 was not just the failure of a complex multinational polity. In the eyes of von Mises and his ideological allies, it threw into question the order of private property.
Urm... it was the Bolshevik revolutions and the insurrections of Bela Kun and so forth which did this.
It was the First World War and the Great Depression that birthed democratic nation-states, which no longer merely shielded private property but claimed control over a national economy conceived of as a resource to be supervised by the state.
The two events were widely separated in time. Neither was inevitable. Had Germany been occupied, disarmed, and made to pay reparations, it could not have tried a revanchist war which led all combatants to adopt command type economies.
Private property that had once been secured by a remote but even-handed imperial sovereign was now at the mercy of national democracy.
Bullshit! Remote 'imperial sovereigns' could order pogroms or Kulturfamfs. Private property wasn't secure at all. The Irish absentee landlord could be forced to break up his estate and sell to his tenants. Plenty of Austro-Hungarian magnates were under no illusions regarding what their future might be.
Faced with this shocking transformation, neoliberals set out not to demolish the state but to create an international order strong enough to contain the dangerous forces of democracy and encase the private economy in its own autonomous sphere.
They may have set out to do so just as the nudists may have set out to extirpate the aggressive instincts from our species by getting us all to play nude volleyball and go hiking while bollock naked, but they failed completely and entirely.
Before they gathered at Mont Pèlerin, von Mises hosted the original meetings of the neoliberals in the Vienna Chamber of Commerce, where he and his colleagues called for the rolling back of Austrian socialism.
That worked out a treat! Incidentally, the Soviet Union only permitted the re-unification of Austria because they were losing money on their occupation of a portion of it.
They did not think that fascism offered a long-term solution, but, given the threat of revolution, they welcomed Mussolini and the Blackshirts. As von Mises remarked in 1927, fascism “has, for the moment, saved European civilization.”
So, the guy was a shithead. That's why nobody listened to him.
Even in the late 1930s, Wilhelm Röpke, another leading neoliberal, would unabashedly declare that his desire for a strong state made him more “fascist” than many of his readers understood. We should not take this as a light-hearted quip.
We should not take it as anything at all. Germany's fate was decided by men with guns. History has forgotten him because 'ordoliberalism' has been revealed to be hot air.
The neoliberals were lobbyists for capital. But they were never only that. Working alongside von Mises, the young Friedrich Hayek and Gottfried Haberler were employed in empirical economic research. And it was the networks of interwar business-cycle research that drew key figures from Vienna to Geneva, then home to the League of Nations. The Swiss idyll is the site for much of the rest of Slobodian’s narrative, giving its name to the brand of globalist neoliberalism he labels the “Geneva school.”
Like the League, this 'Swiss idyll' had about as much impact as nudism or Rudolph Steiner's anthroposophy.
In the 1930s the League of Nations was a gathering place for economic expertise from across the world. But as Slobodian shows, what marked the Geneva school of neoliberalism was a collective intellectual crisis. In the face of the Great Depression, they not only came to doubt the predictive power of business-cycle research, they came to see the very act of enumerating and counting “the economy” as itself a threat to the order of private property. It was when you conceived of the economy as an object, whether for purposes of scientific investigation or policy intervention, that you opened the door to redistributive, democratic economic policy. Following their own edicts, after crushing the labor movement, the next line of defense of private property was therefore to declare the economy unknowable. For the Austrian neoliberals, this called for reinvention. They stopped doing economics and remade themselves as theorists of law and society.
So, they were crap economists and had to settle for being ex-pat lecturers in England or America or Istanbul. Had they not done so, they would have died unmourned and unlamented either at the hands of the Nazis or under bombardment by the Allies.
Evidently, this put them profoundly at odds with the technocratic spirit of the midcentury moment. The most famous expression of this alienation was Hayek’s The Road to Serfdom (1944), which takes up surprisingly little space in Slobodian’s account. In part, this is no doubt due to the focus of Hayek’s attack on European totalitarianism and the Beveridge plan for Britain’s postwar welfare state.
So, Hayek was wholly irrelevant to his own milieu. Later on, the British Trade Union shat the bed so thoroughly that working class people elected Thatcher to kick them in their collective goolies. Thatcher read Hayek because she was a bit dim- a Chemist, not a Physicist- and couldn't hack equations. Also, unlike Friedman- who was too Jewy and opinionated- Hayek was a gentlemanly Austrian who knew his place.
Slobodian’s Geneva School neoliberals, by contrast, focused their attention on global political economy. In the aftermath of the Second World War, they struggled to defend capital mobility against the restrictions of Bretton Woods. In the 1960s they inveighed against the postcolonial order, rallied to Apartheid, and did their best to undercut the visions of a fairer and more regulated New International Economic Order pushed by the global South. The idea of a government-regulated system of exchange dominated by commodity producers was anathema to neoliberalism.
And to the rest of us coz OPEC meant greasy Oil Sheikhs turning Knightsbridge into a drag strip for their sports cars or else, nutjobs like Gaddaffi or Chavez or Saddam running amok creating mayhem.
Slobodian gives us not only a new history of neoliberalism but a far more diverse image of global policy debates after 1945. Even in the heyday of Keynesianism and developmentalist policies, the neoliberals were never silenced. Neoliberalism was always part of the conversation, though it was not the secret blueprint of twentieth-century history. As Slobodian observes, from the 1930s, many neoliberal ideas were deliberately utopian. They weren’t aiming to change policy, at least not right away. Their interventions were polemics designed to break open the debate.
These poor bastards were running away from the continent to get ill paid teaching jobs. They wrote a couple of books to make a little money and thought Mcarthyism was their ticket to a better life.
It was in the 1980s that the neoliberals’ long march through the institutions of global economic governance finally carried the day.
Why? Coz the Liberals had shat the bed very thoroughly during the Seventies. Reagan was elected because of the incontinence associated with, what he called, the 'L-word'.  No doubt, because of the G.I bill, a lot of people thought quoting a Prof. was a cool thing to do. Still, these shitheads changed nothing. Precisely the same processes obtained even where their names were unknown. Gorbachev was convinced by his own mathematical economists to surrender Party control of the Economy. This immediately led to a scissors crisis and the collapse of the Soviet Union.
In this Slobodian agrees with the more familiar narrative. But rather than concentrating on national programs of monetarism, privatization, and union-busting, Slobodian focuses on the transnational dimension: the EU and the WTO. The protagonists of his story are people you have never heard of, second-generation students of the original Austro-German founders, trained as lawyers, not economists—men like Ernst-Joachim Mestmäker and Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann, who shaped the agenda in Brussels and helped to steer global trade policy.
'Helped to steer'? Bureaucrats don't help steer anything. They just are- like death and taxes.
It is a measure of the success of this fascinating, innovative history that it forces the question: after Slobodian’s reinterpretation, where does the critique of neoliberalism stand?
First and foremost, Slobodian has underlined the profound conservatism of the first generation of neoliberals and their fundamental hostility to democracy.
Though only democratically elected leaders- like Thatcher, Reagan, Mitterand and now Trump- can kick the intellectuals in the goolies and disintermediate them from political processes.
What he has exposed, furthermore, is their deep commitment to empire as a restraint on the nation state. Notably, in the case of Wilhelm Röpke, this was reinforced by deep-seated anti-black racism. Throughout the 1960s Röpke was active on behalf of South Africa and Rhodesia in defense of what he saw as the last bastions of white civilization in the developing world.
So what? BOSS paid a whole bunch of third rate people to write articles supporting the Apartheid regime. Even some Indians were offered a little money towards this end.
As late as the 1980s, members of the Mont Pèlerin Society argued that the white minority in South Africa could best be defended by weighting the voting system by the proportion of taxes paid. If this was liberalism it was not so much neo- as paleo-.
As late as the late eighties, South Africa was our ally. After the Wall fell, we pressurised Botha to do a deal with the ANC. Then Mandela became our hero.
If racial hierarchy was one of the foundations of neoliberalism’s imagined global order, the other key constraint on the nation-state was the free flow of the factors of production.
If nude hiking was one foundation of nudism's imagined global other, the other key constraint on the nation state was the free flow of air around everybody's genitals.
Neo-liberalism and nudism are only as important as each other. The fact that we all, in the year 2018, get nude before showering does not mean that nudism 'marched through the institutions' nor that it was not complicit in Adolf Hitler's own ablutions.
This is what made the restoration of capital mobility in the 1980s such a triumph. Following in the footsteps of the legal scholar and historian Samuel Moyn, one might remark that it was not by accident that the advent of radical capital mobility coincided with the advent of universal human rights.
Worthless shite. There was more 'radical capital mobility' in 1911 than 2018. I could have bought agricultural land in India or Egypt or Uganda in order to create a plantation. Now, such an action would be illegal or involve high compliance costs.
Both curtailed the sovereignty of nation states.
Nonsense! Greece just reimposed capital controls a couple of years back. Their sovereigny wasn't really impaired at all. They were just pretending it was because they thought Germany would write off their debts so as to avoid being accused of being neo-Nazi.

What about Universal Human Rights? Britain's sovereignty hasn't been curtailed because May now says she'll get rid of the thing.

Anyway, nobody believes that shite anymore- now Trump is in the Oval office and Merkel, not Orban, is on the run.
Slobodian traces that intellectual and political association back to the 1940s, when Geneva school economists formulated the argument that an essential pillar of liberal freedom was the right of the wealthy to move their money across borders unimpeded by national government regulation. What they demanded, Slobodian quips, was the human right to capital flight.
Which the tax-dodging 'Belgian dentist' achieved through the Eurodollar. Incidentally, it was the French who caused the Americans to rescind Roosevelt's executive order which prevented citizens from holding gold.
That irony curdles somewhat when we recall the historical context. After 1933, the human right to capital flight was no neoliberal joke. Money was the binding constraint both on the ability of German and Austrian Jews to leave the Third Reich and on their being accepted by potential countries of refuge. It may be typical of neoliberal hyperbole that defenders of capital mobility accused the U.S. government of resorting to “Gestapo” methods in tracking down the wealth of “enemy aliens.” But it was no coincidence that Reinhard Heydrich, future head of the Gestapo and the architect of the Holocaust, made his leap to prominence in the Nazi regime in 1936 as head of the foreign-exchange investigation division of Hermann Göring’s Four Year Plan. The neoliberals are onto something in insisting on the interconnections between the movements of money and people. Certainly restricting the former is a sure way to restrict the latter, especially in a world of national welfare where the right to entry depends on proving that you need neither social assistance nor a job.
Bilge. China keeps trying to crack down on capital flight- which is why it was manipulating its currency- but it keeps failing though it is ready and willing to put a bullet in the brain of anyone it catches.
Neoliberals have as much to do with this as German nudists of the Twenties have to do with the fact that I am currently nude and typing this in bed.
It was these entanglements of unfreedom that the Road to Serfdom dissected so effectively, which brings us to the ticklish question of its author. By the 1990s it can hardly be denied that neoliberalism was the dominant mode of policy in the EU, OECD, GATT, and WTO. But what kind of neoliberalism was it, and what has Hayek got to do with it?
It was the kind of neoliberalism which detected nothing but rent-seeking in complaints from Industries or Trade Unions of 'unfair competition' or 'the national interest'.

It had nothing to do with Hayek. Rather it was based on the memory of the stagflation of the Seventies when Governments had to subsidise Corporations and feather-bed Unions. Once you give into rent-seeking on one issue, they will demand more and more and more. In the early Eighties, there was a sketch on 'Not the Nine O'clock news' where the Trade Union leader, in addition to everything else, demands the right to sleep with the Manager's daughter. He offers his wife instead but the Unionists have seen her and won't be budged. Neoliberalism was about cutting down the Unions to size before they demanded droit de seigneur with respect to the daughters of management.
Slobodian works hard in his concluding chapter on the GATT and the WTO in the 1980s and 1990s to bring us back to the central Hayekian theme of the impossibility of representing the world economy as a whole.
Mathematics can represent the world economy as a whole. Hayek was a big silly.
In the case of key personnel at the WTO, he can show direct neoliberal lineage.
So what? Bureaucrats don't matter.
As a matter of intellectual biography this make sense. But as Slobodian knows only too well, there is an obvious counterargument to any claim that such organizations represent Hayekianism in action—Hayek’s profound skepticism toward anything that smacks of conventional economic policy, growthmanship, or, indeed, the very idea of the economy as such. This does not stop practical neoliberals from doing their stuff, any more than his disciples are bound to either the letter or the spirit of Keynes’s General Theory of Employment. Much of the political success of neoliberalism depends on the willingness of its practitioners to discard key ideas of its purist thinkers. What remains in real, “actually existing” neoliberalism is precisely its relentless emphasis on growth and competitiveness as the measure of all things.
Nonsense! Neoliberalism is about not letting Labour shit the bed and telling cartels quit bothering the bureaucrats and go bribe Congress in time honoured fashion.
The result as far as Hayek is concerned is profoundly ironic. After 1989 he was feted as the godfather of the global capitalist revival. No doubt, as a lifelong anti-Communist, he took satisfaction at the end of the Soviet regime. But for Hayek, the Cold War had never been more than a “silly competition” in which both sides took a crude quantitative measure of the economy as their benchmark of success and offered their citizens essentially the same promises. Turbo capitalism of the Friedmanite-Reagnite variety was, for Hayek, “every bit as dangerous” as anything Keynes ever proposed.
In a world framed by what, according to Slobodian, ought to be considered a contradiction in terms—neoliberal growthmanship—how should the left respond?
The overwhelming stress on the priority of “the economy” and its imperatives leads many on the left to adopt a position that mirrors Hayek’s. Following thinkers like Karl Polanyi, they criticize the way that “the economy” has assumed an almost godlike authority. Nor is it by accident that the libertarian left shares Hayek’s distaste for top-down economic policy, what the political scientist James Scott has dubbed “seeing like a state.” As the neoliberals realized in the 1930s, the nation-state and the national economy are twins. If this remains somewhat veiled in the histories of countries like France and the United Kingdom, the conjoined emergence of state power and the developmental imperative was stamped on the face of the postcolonial world.
Worthless gibberish. India found out that Economists have shit for brains. Wait till they go to sleep because 'India grows at night'.
Such critiques can be radically illuminating by exposing the foundations of key concepts of modernity. But where do they lead? For Hayek this was not a question. The entire point was to silence policy debate. By focusing on broad questions of the economic constitution, rather than the details of economic processes, neoliberals sought to outlaw prying questions about how things actually worked. It was when you started asking for statistics and assembling spreadsheets that you took the first dangerous step toward politicizing “the economy.” In its critique of neoliberalism, the left has challenged this depoliticization. But by failing to enquire into the actual workings of the system, the left has accepted Hayek’s injunction that economic policy debate confine itself to the most abstract and general level. Indeed, the intellectual preoccupation with the critique of neoliberalism is itself symptomatic. We concentrate on elucidating the intellectual logic and history of ideologies and modes of government, rather than investigating processes of accumulation, production, and distribution. We are thus playing the neoliberals at their own game.
Yup. You are talking worthless shite. So what? You are incapable of doing anything else. What is important is that you are not masturbating in public and jizzing in your student's faces. You are welcome to pretend your worthless Academic Department has some sort of Social utility. The truth is it is a collapsing Credentialist Ponzi scheme.
Given neoliberalism’s association with globalization, it might be tempting to see reclaiming the national economy as a way out of this trap. This is the impulse that lies behind “Lexit,” which, at its best, is a call for a return to the ambitious, left-wing social democracy of the 1970s. Given that this was the moment that provoked the neoliberals into their most vicious counterattack, one can see the attraction. The question is whether it is a real possibility. After all, the global South in the 1970s proposed not a series of go-it-alone national solutions, but a New International Economic Order. And in that moment, the global South could call on the energy of the first flush of postcolonial politics.
Hilarious! In the Seventies, post-colonial societies were ruled by corrupt gerontocrats. I recall the Brandt report. It was pure shit.
The passions that have been unleashed in the United Kingdom and the United States since 2016 are of a more rancid vintage.
As long as it remains at the level of abstract gestures toward “taking back control,” the impulse of resistance mirrors what it opposes. We are still not engaging with the actual mechanisms of power and production. To move beyond Hayek, what we need to revive is not simply the idea of economic sovereignty, whether on a national or transnational scale, but his true enemies: the impulse to know, the will to intervene, the freedom to choose not privately but as a political body.
That's Trumpism's Fart Act- selective tarriffs on everything to make America great again like it was when Fred Flinstone first moved to Bedrock.
An anti-Hayekian history of neoliberalism would be one that refuses neoliberalism’s deliberately elevated level of discourse and addresses itself instead to what neoliberalism’s airy talk of orders and constitutions seeks to obscure: namely, the engines both large and small through which social and economic reality is constantly made and remade, its tools of power and knowledge ranging from cost-of-living indicators to carbon budgets, diesel emission tests and school evaluations. It is here that we meet real, actually existing neoliberalism—and may perhaps hope to counter it.
By talking worthless shite.