Elections can permit peaceful tranfer of power though they may also cause an insurrection or Civil War. They have no magical power of their own. Is it important that elections are 'free and fair'? Not really. There will be places where there is an element of gerrymandering or even outright electoral fraud. Sometimes, cracking down on such fraud sends a signal powerful enough to alter electoral outcomes. But, most of the time, it makes no difference.
Currently, in India. there are some cosmetic protests which, in the case of Rahul Gandhi's Congress party, may have to do with firing up the troops for upcoming elections in UP. The Communist parties too may be seeking to restore morale amongst the dwindling numbers of their 'permanent student' apparatchiks.
Meanwhile, the real battleground is UP. It appears that Congress has asked Akhilesh for 175 seats. But they only have 2 seats now, down from 7 in 2017. True, Congress got 7 Lok Sabha seats in 2024 but Akhilesh got 37. He, more than anybody, ensured Modi didn't get a majority. Akhilesh is projecting himself as willing to give seats on the basis of population share while seeking to revive old alliances with Muslim leaders- some of whom are now incarcerated. But Owaisi- who did well in Bihar- is said to be eyeing 200 seats. If Congress is instransigent, could Akhilesh ally with Owaisi? Probably not. In Bihar, Owaisi was able to ally with disgruntled factionalist OBC & Dalit leaders in a specfic geographic area. Still, one can't discount Owaisi's potential as a vote splitter.
Good journalism in UP requires a lot of patience, stamina, and local knowledge. But, at this crucial time of candidate selection, the big boys are keeping their cards close to their chest. It may be that Yogi will prevail as the Law & Order candidate. If so, he becomes Modi's natural successor- or can be projected as such in the Hindi belt.
UP politics, at this moment, is either opaque or banal. This creates a 'news desert'. In this 'silly season', the Media is creating news by means of street theatre of an adolescent sort. Some see it as a conspiracy to take oxygen away from Rahul. Others take the opposite view. The 'cockroach' ringleaders may be autditioning for posts in the Congress's, still quite well-funded, party machine.
Asim Ali, who appears to be wholly ignorant of Indian politics, writes in Time magazine
A Fine Balance, one of the finest novels
it is shit, written by a nice Parsi boy who emigrated to Canada at the age of 23. Since that country has too many trees, emigrants were required to publish worthless shite in the hope this would raise the demand for paper.
about modern India set in the 1960s and 1970s,
Maharashtra didn't have a non-Congress Ministry till 1978.
Rohinton Mistry powerfully conveys a sense of the social meaning of the vote for the Indians at the bottom of the ladder.
It was something he knew nothing about. The struggle to get the fuck out of India and to get the right to vote in Amrika/Yurop was what he had special expertise in.
Narayan, a Dalit tailor, insists on marking his own ballot in an upcoming election instead of allowing an upper-caste landlord’s men to vote on his behalf.
Under Congress rule, a Dynasty perpetuated itself by booth-capture & vote rigging. Also, under Indira Gandhi, there was forcible sterilization.
Dukhi, his father, warns him against it. “It is still my right,” Narayan replies. “And I will exercise it in the next election, I promise you.”
Dukhi urges him not to risk his life.
“Life without dignity is worthless,” Narayan replies.
Indians laughed out loud when they read this shite. The truth is, what Narayan said to Dukhi was 'hyrbridization of the Homo Baba catacrhesis of Spivakian strategic essentialism is hypotenused by the catachresis of the hybridization of socio-economic scotomization under conditions of Neo-liberal repressive desublimation. Mind it kindly. '
Dukhi replied 'fuck the police! Attica!'.
I have been rereading Mistry’s novel over the past few weeks
because the thing is fucking hilarious. Canadians truly are humourless twats.
as a series of protests has turned October into a month of fierce battles over the integrity of India’s elections, the accountability of its institutions, the right to protest, and the soul of its democracy.
Mamta wasn't able to steal the election in West Bengal. Sad.
A nascent Gen-Z movement, Cockroach Janta Party,
started by a pair of the anti-corruption 'Common Man Party' hacks after its administration imploded because of collossal corruption.
which organized protests over education and unemployment in Delhi in June and July and forced the resignation of India’s higher education minister,
He wanted to go back to Orrisa which is now BJP ruled.
gave the call for the October protests. Young protestors answered with an insurrectionary energy in the summer
as Ghalib said 'ik tamasha hua, gila na hua'- there was a spectacle, there was no petition or redress.'
and soon found support from a broader coalition comprised of opposition parties, social movements and other pillars of Indian civil society.
Rahul Gandhi is leading it. Mamta & her few remaining acolytes are on board. Akhilesh put in an appearance. But, the biggest Muslim leader, Owaisi is staying away. Why? 'Vote chori' (vote stealing) is seen as depriving Muslim immigrants of the vote. Hindus like that. Like the anti-CAA protests, this agitation helps the BJP consolidate the Hindu vote.
These assorted protesters see the stakes of the current moment as existential:
careerist. They hope to grow rich as 'strategic consultants' or Social Media influencers.
the sanctity of the vote in India, the essential ingredient, in other words, of democracy.
Which Rohinton said in 'Fine Balance' didn't fucking exist under the Dynasty.
Throughout October thousands joined the cause in Delhi and other Indian cities, their marches spurred by anger directed against an ongoing national exercise to overhaul the country’s electoral register.
Why are dead people not allowed to vote in India? Is it for the same reason they are not allowed to vote in Canada?
Known as the Special Intensive Revision, the exercise has, according to the protestors, resulted in more than 130 million voters being removed from electoral lists.
Whereas, under the Dynasty, dead people could vote many times for the Congress party.
Although electoral rolls have been revised periodically, this is the first time such an exercise has placed the burden on citizens to establish their eligibility,
This was always the case. The Bench has repeatedly affirmed that voting is a statutory not constitutional matter. Eligibility is established by law. The onus is on the citizen to establish eligibility and to seek a judicial remedy if it is denied by the Election Commission.
raising fears that millions of legitimate voters, particularly the poor and marginalized, could be disenfranchised.
This is why political parties enlist voters and do 'booth management'.
Maybe a better approach would be to say there is a constitutional duty to go to each voter, establish eligibility, and record their choice. Otherwise, lazy people could be disenfranchised.
Seeking accountability, they have been calling for the resignation of Gyanesh Kumar, the country’s chief election commissioner, who oversees the Election Commission of India, the body charged with conducting and safeguarding the sanctity of elections across the nation.
By undermining the independence of the E.C, the BJP as the party entrenched across 75 percent of the country, will be able to perpetuate its rule in the same way as the Dynasty did- till assassination tempered autocracy & Rahul became too frightened to take the top job.
The protestors accuse Kumar of abandoning his constitutional obligation to act impartially. In their telling, the mandarin has set the table in a way to favor the interests of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party, a charge denied by those in power.
Election Commissioners are appointed by the ruling party. Even if the Chief Commissioner complains about a tainted and partisan Commissioner (e.g. Chawla appointed by Sonia) nothing happens.
Already shaken by the summer protests over education, this time the Indian government responded with coercive force, effectively turning central Delhi, the political and administrative heart of the capital, and the place where India goes to protest, into a garrison.
The BJP rules Delhi & Delhi's people are sick and tired of 'cockroaches' overruning the place.
On Oct. 10, it deployed tens of thousands of police and paramilitary personnel, restricted internet access, detained thousands of protesters, and sought to deny the protesters access to public spaces across the capital.
It succeeded.
The crackdown was intense.
Not really. The thing is a side-show. What really matters is the upcoming UP election. Recent surveys show Yogi is ahead because of his 'bulldozer justice'.
On the night of Oct. 16, there was a palpable sense of panic on social media in India as an urgent question was asked repeatedly: Where is Neha Bora?
a member of a Maoist party which lost votes in the recent Bihar election.
A 29-year-old doctoral student and left-wing activist, Bora has emerged as one of the most articulate and formidable leaders of these protests,
Wrong caste and wrong State (Uttarakhand) to have any chance in Bihari politics- which is the only place her party has MLAs. Maybe, like Kanhaiya, she will shift to Congress. Alternatively, she may fuck off to Canada to do transgender street theatre.
which have rattled Modi’s government and—despite valiant attempts to construct a counter narrative by BJP leaders and other party apparatchiks—become a significant challenge to his popularity and legitimacy.
This is sheer fantasy. Why not simply say- 'Neha Bora's hunger strike is causing 1.2 billion Hindus to convert to Islam. Modi is shitting himself.'
Bora was detained by the police on their way
not 'her way'. Is she transgender? Yes! She is growing a beard and has joined Taliban! 1.2 billion Hindus are following suit. Time magazine should tell its readers this wonderful news!
to join the thousands of protesters who had converged on Connaught Place,
Rajiv Chowk. The Duke of Connaught was British.
a prominent commercial district in the capital, waving the national flag and reiterating demands to protect the right to vote and the sanctity of electoral democracy in India. For several hours after sunset, there was no news of the whereabouts of Bora, who uses they/them pronouns. Their lawyers spoke about the police refusing to reveal their location. Eventually, around midnight, their lawyers located them at a police station.
Where they were growing beard and saying namaz. Kaffir media is not disclosing this.
When Bora was released on Saturday morning, they tweeted, “Fighting for democracy and the Constitution cannot be criminalized.”
In a Democracy- sure. But fighting for the Taliban can't be criminalized in Kabul so long as the hajis are in control.
It was a neat summation of the sentiment moving so many Indians to take to the streets, namely a sense of being robbed of something of existential proportions.
Very true. Many Indians woke up non-binary. What happened to their dicks or vaginas? Why have they disappeared? Does this have something to do with French Existentialism or the recent riots in Paris? I suppose so.
“Now if they take away our right to vote,” a protester told a reporter, “what is left with us?”
Sodomy is little fun if dicks have disappeared.
The emotional charge behind the protests has its roots in the birth of the modern Indian nation-state itself.
The Brits held general elections in 1923 but on a restricted franchise. Ceylon got universal suffrage in 1931.
India always took great pride in adopting universal franchise rights as the Constitution of India came into effect on Jan. 26, 1950.
Burma had universal franchise before India.
In its historic first general elections in 1952,
Manipur, a princely state, held elections under universal adult suffrage in 1948.
every Indian above the age of 21, irrespective of caste, religion, gender, race or wealth, had their constitutionally guaranteed right to vote.
Muslims who had crossed the border in panic lost both their citizenship and their right to vote. Also, they lost property.
It was, as many legal and constitutional scholars have since remarked, a colossal feat, and one that became a touchstone for the modern idea of India.
If you can conduct a census, you can have universal franchise.
Hence the current upheaval in the country.
Rahul is a very stupid man. He thinks this agitation will help his party. It won't. That's just as well. If he becomes PM some nutter will want to kill him.
The Modi government may be reversing decades of democratic gains by
refusing to convert to Islam. At the very least, Modi could chop off his own dick and become a transgender Maoist
recasting the act of voting as a privilege, conferred at the discretion of bureaucrats or as a favor from the ruling party, rather than a right guaranteed by the constitutional order.
If the Election Commission becomes supine, the BJP can entrench itself in the same manner as the Dynasty did.
Now, every prospective voter must first complete an enumeration form,
which is prefilled for most people. The problem is that the last such exercise was in 2002. It would be better to have continuous revision otherwise a huge administrative burden is created.
and many may subsequently be required to produce onerous documentary evidence, such as birth certificates and educational records to establish their eligibility to vote.
More worryingly, some may be subject to a deportation order.
Tens of millions of Indians from marginalized communities either lack documentary records or possess documents that are riddled with mistakes such as spelling errors, making it harder for them to navigate any process of bureaucratic verification.
Which is why political parties need to have good booth management. I suppose, now the EC is facing the music, they will become more cautious. As ex-Civil Servants, they well know how to do nothing. There will be voter fraud & gerrymandering at the local level and opaque deal making at higher levels. The BJP as a cadre based party with an increasingly strong image as the Hindu Nationalist Party par excellence gains a permanent advantage. Politics goes back to being Hindutva vs Hindutva lite.
The fear is that India is—to put it bluntly—being yanked back to a darker time,
Dynastic rule ending in mass incarceration of the Opposition & forcible sterilization?
ne from which it emerged in no small part because of the work done over decades to firmly establish the credibility and broaden the depth of its democratic franchise.
The Election Commission, under Sheshan, did receive a boost in public estimation. But the return of the Dynasty meant a return to the likes of Navin Chawla. Things have gotten better since then because Modi's power comes, not from birth, but from the ballot box. But that may not be true of his successors.
In the 1950s, India was an overwhelmingly rural country, with around 83% of its population living in the villages and only about 17% in urban areas.
It was about 80 percent in 1970, 75 percent in 1990 and less than 70 percent in 2010. What is it now? We don't know. The last census was postponed by COVID. Some say 'functional urbanisation' has been achieved for 85 percent. But there may also be significant depopulation which is not captured in the available figures.
Its nascent democratic system confronted entrenched social hierarchies of caste and power.
Democratic systems created entrenched social hierarchies and a Dynasty where a nice Italian lady took the role of Queen Regent for her moon-calf of a son.
Early accounts of grassroots democracy in India describe how higher-caste landowners controlled the votes of their lower-caste dependents, sometimes even marking ballots that the voters had to authenticate with their thumbprints.
Somewhat later accounts focused on booth capture by gangsters.
The pioneering Indian sociologist M.N. Srinivas showed how politicians campaigning for votes treated villagers not as individual voters with agency but as members of “vote banks.”
A couple of years later, the Communist victory in the Kerala election was put down to votebank politics.
I think the term 'voting blocs' was first used in the 1920s in the US.
Politicians approached landlords or community leaders to deliver these blocs of votes in return for favors from the government, from “licenses for buses and rice-mills to seats in medical and technological colleges for their kinsfolk.”
How shocking! Politicians should approach people in a non binary manner displaying their lack of any sort of secondary sexual characteristics.
And well into the 1960s, millions of Indians were still unable to exercise their constitutional right to vote.
Nehru- eh? What a bastard!
In the eastern Indian state of Bihar, landlords used club-wielding enforcers known as lathaits to keep Dalits, members of the most oppressed caste, out of polling booths. “I remember watching members of my caste being dragged out of a polling booth,” an elderly Dalit man in Bihar’s Siwan district recalled in an interview with The Print, an Indian news site.
I remember an elderly Bihari man who told me that members of his family were butchered by Hindus. He was fortunate that he was staying with his maternal uncle who was an Army officer. Thus the family was able to escape to East Pakistan.
On the other hand, I also remember Youth Congress workers going to Patna to turn out the Dalit vote for Chacha Ghafoor.
During the state elections in 1967, Jagdish Master, a teacher turned activist,
a Maoist belonging to the Khushwaha caste. His son-in-law is a Minister in Bihar.
challenged the veto of the landlords
Bhumihars
over Dalit suffrage by escorting a group of Dalits to a polling booth in Ekwari, a village in Bihar’s Bhojpur district. The landlords’ henchmen brutally beat him and drove him out. He returned to the village as an armed guerrilla, recruiting Dalit laborers and other poor peasants in a Maoist-style rural insurgency that would flare across the region for decades.
The Maoists were against the Soviet Union and for China and, its ally, Pakistan. Thus, in Bangladesh, they were for the Pakistani army which was raping and killing innocent people and against Mujibur Rehman. As part of their broader aim to help China and Pakistan, Jagdish, along with Rameswar Ahir and Latafat Hussain, organised a massive rally and candle march in support of Harijanistan- a separate State for Dalits.
Sadly, he was killed by a group of Dalits who mistook him for a bandit.
The power of the vote in Indian consciousness transformed radically after the “Emergency,” the period between June 1975 and March 1977 when Prime Minister Indira Gandhi suspended constitutional rights, assumed untrammeled powers, imprisoned opposition leaders and silenced the press. Much of India’s elite—bureaucrats, businessmen, newspaper editors and movie stars—bent the knee and welcomed Mrs. Gandhi’s promise of “order” and “discipline.” Wealth and connections offered protection from the state. India’s poor, stripped of their electoral power, suffered terrible abuses of an unaccountable bureaucracy and police from slum demolitions to forced sterilization of men.
Mrs. Gandhi defeated the Pakistan Army. She was very evil.
In the general elections held in March 1977 after the end of the Emergency, Mrs. Gandhi’s Congress Party was decisively defeated by the people and tossed out of power for the first time since Indian independence in 1947. The principal victims of abuses of the Emergency—Dalits, Muslims, and the poor of the populous northern Indian states—voted against the Congress party for the first time and contributed significantly to its removal from power
The current ruling party- the BJP- gained its first Cabinet posts at the Centre during this period. Sadly, they did not convert to Islam or even chop off their own dicks. Life can be very unfair.
The power of the vote has gradually forced India’s high-handed bureaucracy to recognize the human dignity and political citizenship of ordinary people.
High-handed bureaucrats, as independent Election Commissioners, safeguarded the rights of ordinary people. Sadly, they didn't convert to Islam or, if they were already Muslim, didn't chop off their own bollocks and thus were all very evil.
The electorate delivered its verdict on Mrs. Gandhi’s breach of the sacred covenant between the Indian state and its people: the people confer legitimacy on the state in exchange for their rights, including its protection of the sanctity of the vote.
Why did their vote her back to power?
Having asserted their power, voters proved difficult to subdue again. As the political theorist Partha Chatterjee put it, it was the 1977 defeat of Mrs. Gandhi and the Congress party that established the “capacity of the vote.”
Chatterjee had shit for brains. Congress started losing elections in the mid-Sixties. Mrs. G saved its bacon by lurching to the left but the old guard were able to make a brief come-back before sinking back into senility.
India’s poor and marginalized took proper control of their voting choices three decades after independence.
There was some booth-capturing, but the vast majority of Indians could exercise their vote freely since 1923.
In the years after the Emergency, they leveraged the vote as a means to a secure livelihood or as a tool for ensuring justice.
No. Politicians leveraged their control of the State apparatus to bribe voters so as to get reelected.
Politicians could no longer rely on local patrons to intimidate people into voting for them
Mamta did for quite a while. Police squads from other states had to be brought in to curb the power of her bully boys.
and had to compete on representing their interests. A new competitive politics emerged in the 1980s and led to an upsurge, as Chatterjee wrote, “of popular demands of a kind that had never before been allowed to disturb the order and tranquility of the proverbial corridors of power.”
of which Chatterbox knew nothing. The fact is Communist Ministers- like Hare Krishna Konar- had rolled up their sleeves and done some land redistribution in West Bengal back in the Sixties.
By the 1990s, political leaders from socially disenfranchised castes and Dalit communities were taking power in the populous, northern Indian states of Bihar and Uttar Pradesh.
Governance worsened. Crime flourished. Capital fled. Industries folded. Urban areas declined.
Political scientist Christophe Jaffrelot memorably described it as “the silent revolution.”
If you believe fairy stories about upper class brutality- sure. I may mention a similar 'silent revolution' in London. Previously, under David Cameron, black people were hunted on the streets of London by White aristocrats riding horses and wielding light sabres. Thankfully, black women- like Sir Keir- and Muslim trangender goats- like Andy Burnham, have fought back against the Tory toffs who used to terrorise darkies like me. Indeed, I was even permitted to vote at the last General Election.
This revolution, ushered in by the votes of the historically oppressed communities, did not quite transform the economic and social structures of the region.
It empowered gangsters who turned the place to shit.
But it changed the everyday relations of power. Indrajit Roy, a scholar of development studies, recalled a refrain he heard frequently during his fieldwork among Dalits in Bihar in the late 2000s: “There has been development, change has come. Today, we can look the landlord in the eye and speak as equals.”
Nitish was credited with curbing criminality and actually building roads,etc.
Vote banks had thus turned into vehicles of collective political assertion.
No. You can't assert yourself against the local gangster who, more likely than not, belongs to your own caste or is allied with the MP or MLA who is.
Marginalized communities had become adept at pooling their votes to secure political favors and advance their shared interests.
They struggle for government jobs has intensified. But only the private sector can generate enough jobs to solve the problem of migration.
They chose their own patrons, preferring their own caste leaders to represent their interests and negotiate with the state on their behalf.
The state is the politicians. It doesn't have a lot of money.
Over time, the clientelist politics of vote banks became associated with an entrenched culture of corruption. This helped pave the way for Modi’s successful national campaign in 2014, in which he cast himself as
a guy who had brought balanced 10 percent growth to Gujarat. He could do last mile delivery of essential public services.
a populist strongman who embodied the aspirations for “development”
why the scare quotes? Development means more jobs and higher productivity- i.e. higher real wages.
of all Indians while portraying the Congress and regional parties as beholden to their respective vote banks.
Congress was shit. Rahul was a moon-calf too scared to take the top job.
Modi’s attacks on vote bank politics also carried a more sinister charge: that successive governments had appeased India’s Muslims minority, which accounts for around 14% of the population, for their votes at the expense of the national interest.
Modi's strategy had to do with universal entitlements such that the poorest get disproportionate benefits regardless of caste or creed. This reduces 'leakages'.
Bangladesh borders the Indian state of West Bengal and Modi reserved his sharpest, xenophobic barbs for Bengal’s Muslims, whom he tarred during his 2014 campaign as “Bangladeshi” and “illegal immigrants,” establishing a template for their vilification that persists to this day.
West Bengal, like Assam & other North East Sttes, has switched to the BJP precisely because demographic replacement was all too visible.
In an inflammatory campaign speech, Modi issued an ominous warning: “After May 16 [the day of the results of the 2014 elections], these Bangladeshis better be prepared with their bags packed.”
The alternative would be for Hindus to pack their bags as a greater Bangladesh was carved out of Indian territory. The fact is, when Muslims ruled India, they committed a lot of atrocities on kaffirs of all types. Indeed, they continued to do so in Pakistan. The poor, marginalised, Hindu had to cometogether and elect Hindu leaders so as to turn the tables on the Muslims.
A dangerous exclusion
The Modi government invoked that very specter of the “illegal, Bangladeshi Muslim” to push through revisions to electoral rolls across most Indian states. India’s home minister, Amit Shah, who had earlier likened Bangladeshi immigrants to “termites,” responded to the ongoing protests by calling them an “action plan to protect infiltrators.”
In other words, the BJP is hoping that Rahul's 'vote chori' campaign will cause Hindu consolidation. Why not explain this for the American reader?
There are no reliable estimates of how many Bangladeshi immigrants live in India. In 2016, a minister of the Modi government told the parliament, without citing a source, that the country was home to some 20 million “illegal immigrants from Bangladesh.” The government later acknowledged that it had no accurate data on the number of illegal immigrants in India.
There are no accurate figures for the population. India hasn't had a census since 2011. The supicion is that those figures were flawed.
Yet the Indian government has used unfounded speculation about “illegal” Bangladeshis to overturn the fundamental logic of the country’s electoral registration system, shifting the burden of ensuring registration from the Election Commission to the voter herself.
This is where the burden always lay. The difference was that it became a little too easy to report suspected illegal voters.
The commission was responsible for ensuring that every citizen made it onto the electoral rolls.
No. It was responsible for revising the electoral roll as the law dictates. That is what it did. If there were flaws in its work- that is a justiciable matter.
The exercise has already disproportionately disenfranchised the poor, migrants, religious minorities, women—and is bound to continue doing so.
Who is poorer or more disadvantaged than the dead? Why are they being denied a vote?
“The majority of voters in Bihar who were excluded from the list were in rural areas,” said retired Maj. Gen. Anil Verma, who heads the Association for Democratic Reforms, a nonprofit group that challenged the electoral rolls revisions in the Supreme Court. “Those worst affected were the poor and the marginalized—they had no documents.”
Why didn't political parties ensure they got them so as to receive their votes?
Opposition parties have also alleged that the electoral roll revisions tilted the electoral field in the BJP’s favor in the West Bengal election held earlier this year, helping the party win power in the state for the first time.
Mamta wanted to pass power to her nephew. Her chief lieutenant rebelled & won on a BJP ticket.
An analysis by the SABAR Institute, a public policy research institute, lent some credence to that charge: a disproportionate share of the 9.08 million voters removed from West Bengal’s electoral rolls came from constituencies held by the then-ruling Trinamool Congress or those with large Muslim populations.
Which were where illegal Bangladeshis were concentrated.
The Election Commission has denied the charge that the deletions were politically motivated, arguing that it applied uniform criteria to remove entries for voters who had died, were registered more than once or had permanently relocated. But that claim is difficult to reconcile with the disproportionate representation of certain groups among those deleted from supplementary lists issued for some constituencies after an adjudication process.
It is easy to reconcile with the evidence that Bangladeshi Muslims have illegally entered and settled in neighboring Indian States.
For instance, although Muslims make up around 23% of the population of Nandigram, a constituency in West Bengal, the SABAR Institute study found that they accounted for 95.5% of the deletions across seven supplementary lists released by the Election Commission for the constituency.
The Left front benefitted by protecting and settling share croppers there. However, there was a reaction against their heavy-handed goons as farmers feared they would lose land to industrial projects.
Voting carries an almost existential significance for Indians
No. It has no importance whatsoever. Entitlements and Citizenship are not established merely by your name bieng on the electoral roll.
whose equal citizenship has not been fully recognized by the institutions of the state.
A convicted criminal has equal citizenship but can't vote.
Indians see the vote as an affirmation of their existence.
No. They see voting merely as a means of choosing between candidates.
If the vote is no longer a gift freely given or withdrawn by the people
votes can be bought. When I was young, a bottle of brandy and a package of biryani did the trick.
but a resource controlled by the state,
it is controlled by the voter.
it reduces ordinary voters once again to supplicants dependent on the favor of political elites.
No! It reduces ordinary voters to rent boys. They present their arseholes to political elites in the belief that elite jizz is actually ballot paper securing which they will be able to vote and thus affirm their own existence. What can I say? Indians are like that only.
The electoral revisions and mass deletion of voters have provoked such widespread revulsion because many Indians see it as an assault on their identity as citizens and a threat to the social recognition they have won through a long, arduous struggle. Many Indians might have forgiven Modi for his numerous missteps but they are determined not to let him devalue their voting power.
Yet, he will continue to win unless the opposition stops being so shit.
The young protesters moving through Delhi’s barricaded streets carry a palpable sense that they are living through a historical moment. References to the Quit India movement against the country’s erstwhile British colonizers
If the Brits had quit India, the Japs would have conquered it.
and the protests around the Emergency have become commonplace.
There were no protests during the Emergency. I remember. I was there.
Memories of seminal events of the past offer a lens through which to consider the present. The future seems open to change through collective action. This sense of a turning point imbues individual actions with a larger purpose and drives protesters to confront a police force intent on clearing the streets by whatever means necessary.
Are all the protestors nutters? No. Some are proper careerists or opportunists while others may enjoy participating because they have nothing better to do.
On Oct. 9, a day before Delhi was placed under a lockdown, Bora invoked India’s struggle against British imperialism
The Communists supported the Brits once Hilter attacked the Soviet Union.
to denounce the pre-emptive detention of protest organizers. “History is repeating itself. Just like in 1942, the arrest of leaders could not stop the Quit India movement; this movement will also not stop,” Bora said.
The Quit India movement collapsed. Britain defeated Japan, held elections and got the fuck out of a shithole.
“This is nothing but a state of open emergency in the country.”
If it gets nutters off the streets, well and good.
The convergence of young people’s anger over education and employment, fears of authoritarianism, and concern for the sanctity of the vote poses a serious challenge to the Modi government.
No. Poorer women are the swing voters. Targetted benefits for them is what enables you to win elections.
It could forge a broad popular coalition of unemployed young people,
they can be recruited by poltical parties and set to beating each other in the streets.
urban poor, Dalits and religious minorities, united in challenging the legitimacy of the government.
Also include the drug addicts and those who smell really bad and you are bound to win.
Unless the government retreats on electoral roll revisions,
The EC will back down. Who needs the aggravation?
sustained protests could drain its political capital.
Or increase it if the protests are about giving illegal migrants the vote.
One of Indian democracy’s great achievements is that even its poorest citizens have proved adept at recognizing when the power of their vote is being wrested away, gauging the consequences and organizing to resist.
But the votes of the poorest hasn't been wrested away. Political parties- like the BJP- have enrolled them and will provide transport or other help to ensure they get to the voting booth.
A government in India can retain its legitimacy despite failing to provide functioning schools or decent employment. It cannot do so if it also violates the sanctity of the vote.
Only the law can say whether or not a government is legitimate. The opinion of an ignorant shithead is wholly irrelevant.
No comments:
Post a Comment