Tuesday 23 January 2024

Deblinka Chakrabarty on why the Prophet was an atheist

 After 9/11, the British Government waged war on Muslim terrorists in Afghanistan, Iraq and other such places. Currently, Britain is shelling Houthi militants in Yemen. 

Deblinka Chakrabarty lives in London- a City she first came to as a student more than 20 years ago. Yet, she is not concerned with Britain's role in the killing and displacement of millions of Muslims. She is obsessed with what happened when the Babri Masjid was razed to the ground.

She writes in Print.in

BABRI MASJID DEMOLITION

From the Babri demolition to the Ram Temple inauguration, a personal history of New India

That history begins when 'Mullah' Mulayam Singh Yadav's police opened fire and killed Hindus in October/November of 1990. This silly girl knows nothing about India. 


A 32-year quest for answers.

by a silly girl who, however, had the sense to emigrate to You Kay because Prince Harry was very good at killing Muslims. 

From the Babri demolition to the Ram Temple inauguration, a personal history of New India

by someone who left India as soon as she could. Sadly, You Kay now has a Hindu Prime Minister. Deblinka must search for answers for why this might be.  


I don’t usually have a good memory for past events.

Also you are as stupid as shit.  

But some events poke through like a needle jab, drawing blood, leaving a stain.

Deblinka has stained herself. Chee chee!  

December 6, 1992. A non-state mob army of kar sevaks destroyed the Babri mosque in Ayodhya. Exactly a month later on January 6, 1993, its violent aftermath continued to ripple across Bombay and trickled into our sheltered girl’s convent in Colaba. Around noon, parents of classmates zoomed into school to pick up their children and ferry them to the safety of their homes.

Because Muslims were killing Hindus. Sadly, the Hindus soon got the upper hand. Muslims also detonated some bombs. They had to run away to Pakistan or else spent long years in prison. It is noteworthy that in BJP ruled states, Muslims no longer run amok. Sadly, even the UK has an unenlightened attitude towards Muslim terrorists. This is the fault of Rishi Sunak- right? 


I wasn’t sure my father would be able to make it. He was with my mother who was battling a different army of internal intruders;

OMG! The girl is referring to Islamic terrorists as a cancer! She has shown the kaffir cloven hoof! 

her own body cells turned malignant marauders in an onslaught of primary lung cancer. She was in hospital for her monthly chemotherapy, a treatment so raw and brutal in 1992 that it demolished her into exhausted submission, never mind her legendary resilience.

Mummy succumbed to cancer. India did not succumb to Islamic terror.  But many Muslim nations weren't so lucky. 

But he did show up. And drove me home with relieved reassurance that we were safe since we lived in buildings nestled under the bungalows of ministers in Malabar Hill. Democracy wouldn’t save us,

from Muslims 

but the selfish interests of its elected representatives just might.

actually they had a selfish interest in politically instrumentalizing communal violence- unless, of course, they weren't 'secular' at all.  


As riots raged in Bombay, I stayed alone at home with a kind, distant uncle sent to babysit me

to keep her safe from Muslim rapists 

as my father kept his vigil with my mum at the hospital.

Sadly, cancer can't be beaten into submission.  

Babri ignited a fire that consumed Bombay and other parts of India with no prior history of communal violence across December 1992 and January 1993.

The Muslims learned their lesson. Don't start a fight you are bound to lose.  

The twin spectres of Dawood Ibrahim and Shiv Sena became the stuff of cautionary lore and Bollywood impersonations.

Ibrahim had to run away. The Sena took power.  

The same Shiv Sena who had orchestrated the Bombay riots eventually came into state government in the mis-’90s. The carnage had been blurred by Vajpayee’s National Democratic Alliance model of centre-right wingism. There was Kargil on one side,

Pakistan lost that war 

but then there was Pokhran 2, Samjhauta Express

which the ISI was able to derail 

and India Shining.

the price of onions forced Atal to weep bitter tears.  


By the time Godhra happened in 2002, I had been motherless for nine years, alone as a student for the first time in the freezing London winter.

Blair had sent British forces to kill Muslims in Afghanistan. He provided Bush with the 'sexed up dossier' which was the excuse for the invasion of Iraq. This silly girl doesn't get that 9/11 caused America to put a nuclear gun to Musharaff's head. He tried to get out of helping them in Afghanistan by getting the ISI to stage a terror attack on the Indian parliament. The Godhra atrocity may have been spontaneous (Muslims be kray kray- right?) but North Block thought it was an ISI conspiracy designed to hamper Indian army logistics so the Paks could start something in the Rann of Kutch.   

My widowed father, floundering through grief and finding strange comfort in the Hindutva sermons of mail-order Gita Press audio cassettes now thought Godhra would teach the Muslims a well-deserved lesson.

She means the post-Godhra riots.  

Alienated by a hostility I didn’t know had entered my home, I encountered a question from a left-wing professor at the London School of Economics: is your father a communalist?

She should have said 'Is Tony Blair an Islamophobic racist? Why are you paying taxes to a government which is invading Islamic countries and slaughtering their people?'  

I didn’t have an answer then, I suppose I still don’t.

Because you are as stupid as shit. Why did you move to a country which was an active participant in the slaughter of 1.3 million Muslims and the displacement of tens of millions more? India did not fight in either Gulf War. Yet, this silly sausage thinks only Hindus kill Muslims. Nice White Christians give kisses and cuddles to Islamic folk. The Crusades have been misrepresented by Hindutva historians. Richard the Lionheart got naked and invited Saladin to sodomize him. Saladin suggested that they just suck each other off instead.  


My father is no different from the millions like him who nodded in acquiescence in 2002, who chose the perpetrator in 2014, and who continued to surrender to Brahminical supremacy

Rahul is a Brahmin. Modi is Backward Caste. This woman truly is as stupid as shit.  

and monotheistic frenzy,

Islam is more monotheistic than Trinitarian Christianity- never mind Hinduism with its thousands of Gods and Goddesses.  

in an India that was always a pluralistic idea far grander than reality, always an ambitious work in progress.

Sadly, nice monotheistic where not able to frenziedly rape and decapitate Deblika back in 1993.  

Just before I was to leave my home country, the Allahabad High Court ruled in 2010, 18 years after the Babri demolition, that the rioters were on the right side of history. They would get the majority of the disputed Ayodhya land.

The Supreme Court decided in 2019 that they would get none of it. Why did Deblika move to Britain which was occupying sovereign Muslim territory and killing Islamists abroad while locking up or keeping surveillance on Muslims at home? Is it because London was safer from Pakistani terrorists than Bombay's Taj hotel had proven to be? 


It was Partition yet again, this time served up in puréed legalese and blithely simplistic headlines that underscored the emotional and blood cost the nation had paid.

There was no Partition precisely because Muslims were slaughtered or incarcerated. 

This tongue-in-cheek photograph

showing a newspaper headline 'two parts to Hindus, one part to Muslims' 

creates a fittingly banal mis-en-scene for a banal headline. (In 2019, the Supreme Court endorsed and upheld this travesty.)

No. The Supreme Court gave all three parts to the Temple Deity. This woman truly is as stupid as shit.  


Thirty two years after breaking Babri, on January 22, 2024, as the nation converges onto the scene of crime, we have now entered a new India.

Deblika hasn't. She remains in London. I suppose she has had the sense to become a naturalized British citizen.  

This India celebrates the Babri desecration

Deblika lurves Islam. Sadly, her Uncle prevented monotheists from frenziedly raping her when she was a kid. Truly, Hindus are a devilish people.  

with a flashy new temple, an ominous high priest,

God alone knows what she means. The chief purohit seems a nice, scholarly, guy.  

hordes of blinkered acolytes and anodyne drawing-room discussions about the growth opportunity that Ayodhya now represents, from the people that represent money and power in this new India.

Many of those people represented money and power in the old India. That's why they didn't emigrate. 

History has shown us repeatedly that temples, mosques, churches, are but transient buildings,

unlike houses which never fall down 

vessels for masculine power struggles.

Queen Victoria had a dick- right?  

They are built, broken, redesignated as per the whims of the times.

That is what happens to buildings of any type. 

Hagia Sophia is a poignant reminder of the same.

As is the Mosque-Cathedral of Cordoba.  

For those who know me, they know how little I care about any religion as a social force of any relevance or good.

Which is why they don't believe you really think the Babri Masjid was 'desecrated'.  

I swing between agnostic and atheist. Dare I say though, people who kill and destroy in the name of religion are the real infidels, because no one who believed in any god would desecrate one for the sake of another.

In which case, Prophet Muhammad was an atheist. I hope Deblika explains this to muscular young Muslims at the local Mosque.  


No comments: